When I saw Borat: Cultural Learnings of America for Make Benefit Glorious Nation of Kazakhstan on a recent weekday afternoon, there were only five people in the audience, including me. With the theater so empty, I expected it to be a quiet hour and a half, but there was nonstop laughter during the entire film. That’s understandable-Borat is the funniest film I’ve seen in the past year.
British comedian Sacha Baron Cohen plays the title role. His character Borat first appeared in Cohen’s variety show, Ali G Indahouse. Borat is a sexist, anti-Semitic, racist and, above all, extremely ignorant TV journalist from Kazakhstan.
In the film, the president of Kazakhstan sends him to the U.S. to learn about our culture. Borat’s mission is to fly to America, film a documentary about American society and bring back what Kazakhstan hopes will be valuable information to help the government improve their country.
Offending Every One
The film starts out in Kazakhstan, where we get to know the character and his homeland. The jokes get gross early and often. Within minutes we find Borat French-kissing his sister, the “Number four prostitute in all Kazakhstan.” More of the same with the village people, including the town rapist. (The town is fictional, with that scene filmed in Romania, not Kazahkstan.)
Borat manages to offend every group of people imaginable, but at the top of the list are Jews and gypsies. Borat embodies the stereotypical anti-Semite. Every scene has at least one line that bashes Jews. What makes these scenes so ironic is that Cohen is actually an Orthodox Jew. Whenever Borat speaks in his “native” tongue, it’s actually Hebrew with bits of Polish mixed in, according to the film website, imdb.com.
Mocking American Ignorance
The film picks up the pace when Borat reaches America. While his character is fictional, most of the people he films in the U.S. are not acting. It felt more gratifying to laugh at the ignorance of my fellow citizens than at the fake Kazakh people. With a Western education and supposedly a more tolerant culture, I thought Americans should know better.
But the message of the film seems to be that anyone, no matter how intelligent, well-intentioned or paranoid, can be duped if the prankster is skillful enough. It also shows how ignorant Americans can be. Had anyone that Borat encountered in the film studied Central Asia for 15 minutes during world history class, they might have seen through his sham.
In one scene, Borat shocks his American hostess when he goes into the bathroom and comes out holding a bag of feces. For some reason, the educated, wealthy Southern woman actually believes that a foreign journalist doesn’t know how to use a toilet.
To me, the fact that she so quickly accepts the notion that other countries live in the Dark Ages is a kind of subconscious racism. Maybe that’s an unfortunate result of how little time we in the U.S. spend learning about the rest of the world in school.
In fact, Americans are so notorious for their cultural ignorance that the real government of Kazakhstan ran a full-color four-page advertisement in The New York Times before the movie came out, to combat the film’s ridiculous portrayal of Kazakhstan as a nation of racist idiots.
Shocked By the Bigotry
My laughter at Borat’s fictional bigotry was surpassed by my shock at the real-life bigotry he comes across in his travels through the U.S.
In one scene, a rodeo manager in Nebraska actually manages to outdo Borat when he starts talking about genocide. And three frat boys, who later ended up suing the makers of the film, go into a rant about minorities and women. One of the boys asks Borat if women are slaves to men where he comes from, and then wishes out loud that it were that way in America.
These scenes made me wonder: how many people enjoyed the film because they got to watch bigoted people being exposed, and how many enjoyed it because they shared the same prejudices themselves?
How many people laughed during the scene with the gun dealer who readily shows Borat the best gun for hunting Jews, not because he seems like such an idiot, but because they enjoyed the thought of shooting Jews?
While I consider myself a fair-minded, unprejudiced person, it was hard for me to keep track of what I was laughing at. Was I laughing at the fake Kazakhs during “The Running of the Jews” or was I laughing with them?
I have to confess, it was a little of both. While I was mainly laughing at the fake villagers for being ignorant enough to think Jews lay eggs, I was also laughing at the image of a Jew laying an egg. Part of me enjoyed watching groups of people that didn’t include me being ridiculed.
Imagine Naked Sumo Wrestling
What separates me from the bigots in the film, though, is my awareness. I know what those people said or did is wrong, no matter how funny it was. The three frat boys, the rodeo manager and the gun dealer, on the other hand, saw nothing wrong with what they were saying.
None of this prevents Borat from being hilarious, though. If satire isn’t your thing, then there’s the plain old slapstick and toilet humor. One extremely funny scene involves two men wrestling (hint: imagine naked sumo wrestling).
Scenes like those provide the belly laughs, but gross-outs alone can’t make a good movie, which is why Borat succeeds where so many other comedies fail. It doesn’t stoop to the lowest common denominator in the audience. Instead, it intentionally goes right over their heads, mocking people who might be sitting next to you in the movie theater.
Fooling the Audience
The best example of this is the most simple. The movie never tells the viewer what isn’t real. If I were gullible enough and hadn’t been clued in beforehand, I might have left the theater thinking I’d seen a real documentary. It’s a movie so witty it can even fool the people watching it.
I recommend this movie to anyone who isn’t easily offended and who doesn’t mind having a laugh at the expense of others. Because in Borat, the joke’s on everyone-maybe even you and me.
Borat: The Joke’s On Us
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.