It all started on the day I hate the most: February 14th, Valentine’s Day. With nothing to do, I got on the internet and went to a goth chat room. I had always wondered what exactly goth was and thought it was time for me to check it out.
I started asking questions like, “What does being goth mean? What do you have to do-is there an initiation process? Is it some kind of cult?” One of the girls in the chat room wrote back, “Forget what people tell you. You don’t have to drink blood or anything. Being in the goth scene doesn’t mean that you’re in a cult.”
She said goths wear black clothes, spiked jewelry and lots of tattoos and piercings. I was facinated by body art and piercings but asked her, “Do goths have to wear all black?” “You can wear some hot, bright colors like pink and lime green,” she wrote. I figured all black would lead to enough criticism.
She also told me that people will always judge you by what you wear and how you look, but that goths ignore the stereotypes society has about them.
‘Do You See What She Has On?’
That totally changed my outlook. At that time, I followed the mainstream, making sure I kept up with the latest fashions as they changed every 10 minutes. I had to have whatever had just come out, no matter the price, and I always looked down on and ridiculed what other people wore because my things were the real McCoy and cost more.
I’d see some lady on the street with an out of this world hairstyle and start making fun of her, or if my friends made comments about other people’s clothes, I’d be right there backing them up.
I had never thought about how ignorant I was to judge people on the littlest things. I thought to myself, “Damn, I can’t believe I’ve been so small minded.” For a moment, I hated myself. I remembered whispering to one of my friends, “Do you see what she has on? I think she shops at the flea market.” I had no right to be judging!
That Valentine’s Day, I decided to change myself. Suddenly, I no longer wanted to be classified with “The Mainstream,” which prides itself on having the “right” fashions. I wanted to go goth and find out how to look like a completely different person. From that day forward, I turned myself over to the scene.
Goth Heaven!
At first, I had no idea where to get the black clothes and wide pants that a lot of goths wear. Then, about a month later, I was staying with some friends for the weekend.
“Today we’re going to Hot Topic and Spencers,” they told me.
“Hot what? What is that place?” I asked. They said it’s a store that has almost every goth thing you could possibly think of. I was definitely going.
As we entered the mall, I was filled with anticipation. Stepping into Hot Topic was like entering goth heaven. The whole store was black and red, draped with the most beautiful things I had ever seen. I remained calm, not showing the exhilaration burning inside me. By the time we left the store, I had everything from UFO pants to spiked bracelets.
Rock Music: Quite Hard to Get Used To
That weekend, my friends were listening to a style of music that was new to me.
“Why are you listening to that?” I asked.
“Well, everybody knows that goths listen to rock and metal,” they said.
I found myself a new hobby: watching TV and checking the radio for the bands they told me about. When I did find them, I thought I was going to have a heart attack. That music was quite hard to get used to. Metal, especially, was nothing but loud drums and screamed obscenities. Emo and alternative were easier, with a slower melody and words. I was determined to keep listening. I didn’t want someone to ask me, “Hey, have you heard that new Green Day song?” and be left scratching my head. I guess part of me wanted to fit in, and part of me wanted to push myself to try new things. It took about a month or so, but I finally got used to the music. I even liked it.
‘Ah, It’s Just a Phase’
After my trip to Hot Topic, the time had come to face the place that I dreaded most: school. I worried about how my friends would react to my whole change of persona. I figured that some of them might turn their backs on me just because I had changed my clothes. My friends were and still are everything to me.
When I showed up in black, most of my friends were open minded, saying, “We don’t care how you dress. You’re still the same person and that’s all that matters.”
A few laughed and said, “Ah, it’s just a phase. You’ll get over it,” or, “You’re just finding yourself.”
That one kind of stuck with me. I played it back in my mind, asking myself, “Why am I doing this? Is this really who I want to be?” I knew I was changing my look for a reason. I just wasn’t sure what I was trying to prove.
‘Aren’t You Black?’
As the days passed, I got reactions from people in my class, some of whom I didn’t even know. One kid asked me, “Why do you dress like that, aren’t you black?” And, “If black people listen to hip hop and rap, why are you listening to rock?”
I was annoyed by those comments. To me, saying that races should stick to their own thing is cliche. Too many people believe that if you’re born one way, you shouldn’t try to change yourself into something you’re not. But I don’t think people are born to listen to rap music.
I simply told him, “Because I’m different, that’s why. I’m not like every other black kid that you see in this school. In case you haven’t noticed, I am my own person. Oh, and just for the record, I do listen to rap. And Eminem happens to be my favorite rapper.”
‘Do You Worship the Devil?’
Then, one day in English class, with five minutes until the bell, a boy got up and came over to where I was sitting. He asked me, “Do you worship the Devil?” Everyone must have heard it because everyone just stopped, even the teacher.
I did what I thought was right and gave him a straight up answer.
“No, I don’t worship the Devil,” I told him, “and I also don’t believe in God.”
He gave me a puzzled and unsure look. Then the teacher came over and started asking me all these questions, like, “Why don’t you believe in God? You know you’re going to Hell for that, right?” I’d hoped she would stop the situation!
Loudly, but not yelling, I said, “Can everyone shut the hell up?”
That seemed to shock everyone, but they did. I felt a bit nervous, but proud that I stood up for myself and let them know that I’m an individual with my own beliefs. If it wasn’t for that bell, though, I think I would have died during my interrogation.
Now I’m the Weird Girl
By wearing black, I quickly found out what my friends and others think about people who don’t conform to some of society’s rules. I hope that changing my clothes pointed out to other people what I realized by entering the goth chat room: Everyone is trying so hard to be popular that they don’t know who they are.
Deciding to change my persona not only changed me on the outside, but made me feel like a much better person inside. Once I looked like the freak, I stopped judging people from what I saw on the outside and began to get to know people who look different from me.
Unfortunately, I also found out that even goths can get caught up in making comments. One goth friend is always saying, “You see that kid? He’s such a poser. He’s just trying to fit in.” I guess he doesn’t realize that he sounds just like the people who criticize him.
I also realized I don’t have to look 100% goth. That look only shows some parts of me. This fall I went back to Hot Topic to buy a black trechcoat, but when I tried it on, and didn’t like it. I decided that I’m good with my Def Jam jacket.
Some days I come to school decked out in black, the next day I’m dressed like I only listen to rap. That feels right to me.
Sometimes I look back at the person I used to be and laugh because I see myself as a prime example of ignorance. I’m glad I’ve changed. I like being the weird girl who stands out, not the one who’s about to get jumped for being too conceited.
Black on Black
Going Goth Helped Me Be Less Judgmental
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.