Black on Black: Racism Begins at Home

“He’s so black…I mean, if you were walking down the street with James at night, you wouldn’t need a flashlight, you’d just have to ask him to smile and show you the way. He’s so dark!”
I overheard this statement in a school hallway. What stunned me was not its racist sting but the fact that it came out of the mouth of a Black person. A sista! I began to wonder whether we should use terms like “brotha” and “sista” anymore when referring to people like this girl who chewed like a cow on a piece of stale gum, thinking nothing of what she had just said. I started to realize that prejudice is not only a problem between Whites and Blacks but also within the Black community-between light-skinned Blacks and dark-skinned Blacks.
Not all Black people consider this a big problem. “There’s still some tension between light-skinned Blacks and dark-skinned Blacks, but it was worse before,” said Dwayne Gyre, 17, of Bronx Science HS. “I really don’t see it anymore.”
Brian Wiltshire,17, also of Bronx Science, agreed. “The tension between light-skinned Blacks and dark-skinned Blacks is not that important,” he said. “It’s underlying. It’s not outright. It hasn’t really flared up.”
Acting Superior
But not all the Black students I spoke to agreed. They see obvious examples of the tension, especially at their schools. “There are cliques of light-skinned Blacks and dark-skinned Blacks,” said Linden Harrigan, 21, of the State University of New York. “Some light-skinned Blacks feel superior. They feel they can’t associate with dark-skinned Blacks. They feel closer to the White man.”
Tyshawn Henry, 17, of Suffield Academy, who is dark-skinned, said she had a girl in her school who “acted” like she was “the queen” because she was lighter. “She had mostly White friends…and she was stand-offish towards the students of color.”
Others argue that dark-skinned people just assume that light-skinned people look down on them. “Dark-skinned people say, ‘You think you’re better than me ’cause you’re lighter, and you think you’re White,’ ” said Nathalie Rigaud, 17, of Mary Louis Academy. “But they just treat light-skinned people bad because they feel inferior.” Brian Wiltshire agrees. “The light-skinned Blacks are perceived as acting White,” he said.
White Is Beautiful
Girls I spoke to said that one thing that feeds this tension is the widely held belief that Black men prefer light-skinned girls. “There is a lot of tension between light-skinned Blacks and dark-skinned Blacks because White guys and Black guys go for light-skinned girls and not dark-skinned ones,” said Geraldine Baptiste(not her real name), 16, of Bronx Science HS. “So light-skinned girls get special treatment.” Tyshawn said the girl at her school who “acted” like she was “the queen” was told by a Black male that she was the prettiest of all the Black girls at their school.
Dwayne Gyre thinks that light-skinned people are considered more attractive because they more closely resemble this society’s image of beauty. “White society has created a picture of beauty contrary to the African features,” he said. “Being beautiful is having blue eyes and a straight nose. So Black men feel pressured to chose a person as close to that as possible. We must redefine what beauty is to include dark-skinned people.” Tyshawn agreed that even within the Black community, a lot of people seem to accept the idea that being White is preferable. “So people think that the lighter you are, the more successful, and the better,” she explained.
A friend of Linden Harrigan’s is a perfect example of this way of thinking. “I have a friend who is dark and wants to marry a light-skinned woman,” Linden said. “I ask him why and he says, ‘I want my children to have good hair.’ “
Dark = Pure
Sometimes dark-skinned people are the ones who seem to feel superior. Linden said, “In rap sessions that we have, I hear dark-skinned Blacks saying stuff to light-skinned Blacks like, ‘At least I wasn’t the product of a rape.’ ” The “pure breeds” exclude the light-skinned Blacks and dis them, which makes them feel inferior.
Dwayne feels that the tension between light-skinned and dark-skinned Blacks stems from the way Blacks have been treated by White society. He explained that during the slavery period, light-skinned Blacks were often “house” Negroes (slaves that worked inside the master’s house), while dark-skinned Blacks were usually the “field” Negroes (slaves that worked in the plantations). Working as a servant was considered much more prestigious than working in the fields. Throughout American history, light-skinned Blacks have continued to be treated better than dark-skinned Blacks, and tension has grown between them because of that, Dwane said.
If anything, this controversy proves that ignorance is a human birth defect that knows no color. As we fight amongst ourselves, we neglect our common struggle. As Brian said, “We have better things to worry about than something so trivial as the degree of skin color.”

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.