When I was a little girl I always dreamed my first love would be the perfect guy. My parents divorced one month after I was born, but I wanted to be married, have kids and have a family.
Sometimes when you have too many expectations of the person you love, you can end up being disappointed. My case wasn’t an exception.
I expected my first boyfriend to be honest at all times. I expected him to be with me and nobody else.
While everyone was saying that he was the worst, I wanted him to prove that he was the best. But I was expecting too much, because that wasn’t who he was.
Too Fast, Too Young
Sometimes I think I should never have gotten so seriously involved with him. If I had had more support from my family or if I’d had closer friends, I might not have gotten into this relationship. I was way too young to be so seriously involved.
Still, I did love him and I felt that he loved me too. But just because two people love each other doesn’t mean that they don’t make mistakes.
It was 1997. I was just in my first year of high school. My life was hard and sometimes I just felt like giving up. I didn’t have any close friends who I could count on, and my parents were too busy giving me rules to take a second to talk to me like friends.
I just wanted a friend. A friend who could be with me when I felt alone.
Nasty Jokes
In February of that same year he came from the Dominican Republic. He came to my house almost every day because he was really close to my family.
My stepmother knew him because his sister is my stepmother’s best friend.
The first time I met him I thought he was the worst person in the whole world. He made nasty jokes and when he spoke he cursed.
But over time I began to like little things about him. He was always smiling, and he said, “No matter how hard it goes, if you’re laughing and smiling, people never notice.”
He Could Say Things With His Eyes
And he could say things with his eyes. When he looked at me, it made me feel that he was hiding something that I wanted to know. Every time I looked at him he was looking at me.
I didn’t look at him too often, because it made me feel uncomfortable.
Instead, when he came to my house, we’d end up arguing about little things, such as which was the best team in baseball. And he’d tell my stepmother that I was conceited.
We Started to Talk
But after a month of arguing, we started to talk.
I told him that sometimes I felt like my stepmother hated me; she was always doing things to get me in trouble with my father.
But he told me, “She loves you more than anything in this world. You should hear the way she talks about you. You should talk to her and let her know that something is bothering you. That’s the best thing you could do.”
I felt good that I had found someone who could listen to me without yelling at me; I needed a friend so badly.
Over time, we became close friends. I didn’t feel attracted to him but I felt good when I was with him.
Our First Kiss
One day I was washing the dishes and he came to the kitchen, looking for something to eat. I gave him some soup.
We started talking about the DR because at that time I wanted to go visit my mom. I was telling him about my plans. Then he just looked at me and we kissed.
I was just 14 (almost 15) at the time, and he was 21. Still, I felt mature enough to build a good relationship, and we started going out.
We went out for a month. We kept it a secret but everyone was having suspicions, so finally we decided to tell everyone (except my father).
His family agreed, my stepmother loved the idea. But my father had warned me: “I don’t want to see you near that guy too much. I don’t even want you to talk to him.”
Two Kids Too Many
My father always told me that I was supposed to get a good man. But my boyfriend had two kids and a family to take care of. He wasn’t married to the children’s mother, but they had lived together for a long time. Still, at that time, they were separated, so I thought that I wasn’t making a mistake.
We were together for a year. In that year I discovered that I really loved him.
I always wanted to be with him, I talked to him every day and I was never bored. He told me about the customers where he worked, and about the people he met. I told him about school and about life at home.
Feeling alone wasn’t a daily routine anymore.
We went to the movies, the park, ice skating, Yankee Stadium, we went shopping. He took me to meet all of his family.
He told me: “Your parents should be proud because not all girls at your age are taking care of everything at home. Not all girls are as mature as you are. You are special and everyone should tell you that.”
Being With Him Changed Me
We spent more time talking about our problems and how to solve them than about anything else. We were more friends than a couple. I always chose the things that we did together, the places that we went. He made me feel important.
Being with him changed me. It made me realize that even though I didn’t consider myself important, I was important. He made me see things in me that I never saw before. He gave me confidence.
At home, things were not easy. Being with him made it easier. He helped me when I needed him the most.
But in May of 1998 something happened that changed everything. The mother of his children came from the DR. It was all right with me because she knew that we were together. I didn’t see it as a problem. But it was.
His family and my stepmother heard rumors about him being with his wife, and they didn’t want us to be together anymore.
Everyone Wanted Us to Break Up
They said things like: “He still loves his wife, they have two kids,” and many other things so we would break up. But he always told me that it wasn’t true. In our relationship we had a rule that we had to say the truth at all times, so I believed him more than other people.
But some of the things people said made me doubt him at times. I was never completely sure that things were the way he said. I think that I made myself believe him because there was nothing else I could do.
Until the day he called me and told me that his wife was pregnant. It was in July about three weeks after my birthday. I picked up the phone and it was him.
“Hi, baby,” he said
“Hi, how are you?” I answered.
“I’m not really good. I have something to tell you.”
“What’s wrong?” I asked.
“I want you to hear this from me, not from the world. I’m not expecting you to take it easy or to continue with the relationship. I also want you to know that I love you more than anything, and this wasn’t on purpose, I swear. I also want you to know that you are the best girl that I’ve been with and any guy would be more than happy to be with you.”
My Parting Words
I already knew what he was going to say so I didn’t even let him finish.
“She’s pregnant. That’s what you’re going to say, isn’t it?” I said
“Who told you?” he asked.
“Nobody. You think that I’m so stupid not to know. I knew that this was going to happen. But let me ask you a question: Now what do you want me to do?”
“Whatever you think is the best for you. I know I’m a piece of sh-t and I don’t deserve you, you’re too good for me.”
“Hell yeah, I’m too good for you, that’s why it’s over, because I trusted you. Even though I knew it was going to happen, I didn’t think it could be possible. But life goes on and there are hundreds of men that are better than you. Don’t you ever call me, I don’t want to see you. Thank you for that year. Because I was happy. Even if everything was a lie, I felt good. Thank you for being my friend.”
Those were the last words I spoke to him before I hung up the phone. He called like 10 times after that but I didn’t pick up.
At that time I hated him, I hated life, I hated myself. I thought that everything was over, that my life was over. I cried every night for weeks. I didn’t go anywhere.
He called every day and the only thing he said was, “I love you, it was a mistake.” It was so much that I got sick.
I Lost a Lot
I got a job in a supermarket and I tried to do many things so I wouldn’t think about him. Now, nine months after, I can say that I don’t need him, I can live without hearing his voice.
But to say that I’ve forgotten him would be a lie. When I have a problem I always wish I could have him near me. I feel so lonely and most of the time I’m depressed. It’s really bad to feel like this.
Since we broke up, every time guys try to get close to me, I make it hard for them. I’m afraid they will hurt me. I lost a lot in this experience, and now I give less and want more.
I Don’t Hate Him, I Still Love Him
Still, I don’t hate him anymore. In fact, I still love him and I thank him.
I thank him because when I was alone he was my only friend. Even though I have suffered a lot, I had many fun moments.
He taught me how to dream, how to be happy and see the world as the best place.
Dependency Is Good and Bad
When I was 14, I couldn’t make my own decisions. I needed his approval or opinion for everything. I trusted his decisions more than mine. I thought everything good in my life depended on him. In my next relationship, I don’t want that. But in some ways, I want my next boyfriend to be like my last.
Dependency is a necessary part of a relationship. People get involved so they have someone to depend on.
But I think there should be a limit. When one person depends too much, it becomes a problem. I’ve learned to be more independent, and it’s making me strong.
Right now he lives by himself. His wife lives in an apartment and he pays the rent and the bills. He still calls me and always tries to prove that he loves me. But I don’t believe him.
Every time I want to give him another chance I think of that woman. She is pregnant right now and that baby is his.
I believe that people can make mistakes because nobody is perfect. But I also think that a relationship should be based mostly in love and trust. And even though I love him, I can’t trust him anymore.
Better to Have Loved
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.