Bad News

I believe that being a journalist is one of the great public services that a person can do. Journalists have the responsibility to present the truth about what’s going on in our world, and so they play a crucial role in our society.
But journalists work for news organizations where editors, publishers and network owners have a powerful influence on what you-the viewer, listener or reader-will learn about the day’s current events. Editors assign stories and select which stories to emphasize, like putting them on the front page. Publishers and corporate owners of TV and radio networks and Internet sites care about making profits, and that influences how they treat the news they report.
From what I’ve observed, most American news sources tend to marginalize or ignore important international stories. Instead we get stories about Bush pardoning a Thanksgiving turkey, or a rumored “Teddy Bear Bomber,” or the endless O.J. Simpson trial, which was totally blown out of proportion.
This emphasis on fluffy or sensational stories is harmful to our democracy. In a democracy, the press has an obligation to present the truth and become the eyes and ears of a society.
Where’s the International News?
International news is important. What happens to people in Madagascar is just as important as what happens to people in California; we are all people. As citizens of our planet we have an obligation to know what’s happening in our world. And because the U.S. plays such a prominent role in world affairs, it’s important for us as Americans to know about situations in other countries and influence our government’s actions and actions of U.S. corporations.
But international events, other than what’s happening in the U.S. “war against terrorism” and the violence in Israel and Palestine, get too little overall coverage in many news publications. And international coverage is even sparser in broadcast news and cable news channels. What’s worse is that in those few pages or seconds of international news, there’s an imbalance, favoring European-mostly British-stories like Britains’ Princess Margaret dying or a robbery at Heathrow Airport, over stories about other continents, especially Africa.
This makes it hard for us to know what’s happening in our world. I believe the lack of media coverage of important international stories makes it easier for violent events to go on unstopped.
Risked His Life For Footage
For example, when the Revolutionary United Front of Sierra Leone entered the capital, Freetown, in January 1999, chopping off the hands and arms of civilians and raping and murdering thousands, the world was largely unaware of what was happening because there was so little media coverage.
Photojournalist Sorious Samura risked his own life to film these atrocities, some of which was aired on Britain’s BBC news in February 1999. He was able to turn his footage into a documentary, Cry Freetown, which aired in February 2000 in North America.
Samora explained that he risked his life to show the brutality because, “The UN, the West and the rest of the world needs to be well informed so as to be able to render the proper assistance, help or support required by the people of Sierra Leone.”
Motivated to Change
I was in 10th grade when I saw Cry Freetown on CNN. I just happened to be flipping channels and stopped at CNN at the right time. I was shocked by the images of women beaten and children shot with machine guns. I was so moved that I vowed to never again allow myself to be so ignorant of what’s happening in the world.
That documentary is partly responsible for motivating me to become a foreign or war correspondent when I grow up. I’ve also traveled outside this country to Madagascar, Costa Rica and parts of Europe, so I know that the world goes way beyond the events and issues of the U.S. America represents just 4% of the world’s population and I believe we should learn more about what’s happening to the other 96% of people on our planet.
Hiding the Holocaust
Major media ignoring or downplaying important international stories is not new. One of the most notorious examples is The New York Times’ undercoverage of the Holocaust in World War II.
According to the History Channel documentary “Holocaust: The Untold Story,” while The New York Times ran more than 1,100 articles on the slaughter of European Jews between 1939-1945, about once every other day, stories about the genocide made front page news only six times. For example, on the day the Times ran a front page article on New York Governor Herbert Lehman donating his tennis shoes for the war effort, a story about how Nazis had killed 700,000 Jews since the start of the war ran on page 6.
As it was, our government severely limited the number of Jews seeking safety in the U.S. and didn’t bomb the railroad tracks they knew led to the German death camps. Had the subject gotten the attention it deserved, perhaps there would have been enough public outrage and pressure on the U.S. government to act.
Ignoring Stories on Africa
Today, Africans are the new Jews. The corporate media no longer ignores stories about Jews, but they now ignore stories about Africans, in part, I believe, because of racism and discrimination against poor people.
Take the war in and around the Democratic Republic of the Congo. At least six central African countries are involved in this war, in which 2.5 million people have died in the last three years. That’s more than all other deaths from all the wars and political conflicts in the world combined. If there was a European war involving six countries – like the former Yugoslavia – does anybody believe that this would not be a top story every single day in the American media?
In addition to the central African war, and wars in Sudan and Angola, millions of people are dying of AIDS in Africa. Why is it that these massive events are not on the front pages of the newspapers, Internet outlets, and on TV screens every day?
Crisis in Madagascar
Turn on CNN, what you’ll see is not a story about another massacred town in Sudan or that thousands of people have died of AIDS in the last 24 hours. Turn on CNN, and you’ll see a breaking story about police finding a kidnapped girl who happens to be from a wealthy, White family in New Jersey.
The media consider Prince Charles being whacked with a flower by an anti-war protester an interesting story, but not the massive strike and protest that has gripped Madagascar since late January because the winner of the December 16 presidential election there is in dispute.
I don’t blame you if you know nothing about Madagascar because it’s received barely a peep of a mention in U.S. mainstream media. But I spent a summer in this island country of 16 million people known for its unique plant and animal species in 2000. Because I care about Madagascar, I stay informed by checking the BBC website for news. Looking through Lexis-Nexis, a database of thousands of current news stories, I discovered that the BBC did five times as many stories on the event as all the American media combined.
Coca-Cola in Colombia
I also believe that as Americans, we should be informed about what American corporations do abroad. Did you know about the murders of labor leaders at Coca-Cola plants in Colombia? A lawsuit brought last July by labor organizations contends that Coca-Cola allowed the assassinations of labor leaders organizing workers at a Coca-Cola factory.
The day after a union organizer was killed, members of a paramilitary squad told workers to resign from their union or be killed. Why isn’t that front-page news? Enron deserves the amount of attention it’s getting, but unlike Coca-Cola, Enron is not being accused of murder.
Just like we have an obligation to know what’s going on in our world, the media has an obligation to report important events and issues-including international stories. People put their trust and faith in a particular news program or print publication so that media organization has a tremendous responsibility.
Public Needs to Be Informed
I think the major news organizations need to remind themselves of the American Society of Newspaper Editors’ “Statement of Principles,” which was adopted in 1922 and revised in 1975.
The document states that: “The primary purpose of gathering and distributing news and opinion is to serve the general welfare by informing the people and enabling them to make judgments on the issues of the time.”
News organizations are not required to follow this code of ethics, but I think they have an obligation to keep the public informed of important-not just sensational-issues and events.
Following a summer in which the loudest news stories were shark attacks in Florida and the disappearance of Congressional intern Chandra Levy, the terrorist attacks of September 11 came as a surprise to most Americans.
Because there’d been little media coverage of it, we didn’t understand the intensity of the hatred towards our government in many parts of the world. We didn’t understand many Muslims’ resentment of the U.S. because of our support of Israel in its conflict with the Palestinians. And Americans had no idea that many people blamed the U.S.-led sanctions against Iraq for the deaths of thousands of Iraqi children from hunger.
After September 11, it should be clear that we can no longer allow profits to come at the expense of an educated public that understands what the rest of the world is like. We need to know about the world so that we can hold our government responsible for its actions and inactions that contribute to the conditions that make terrorism possible.
Fluffy stories and celebrity news consume the print pages and the broadcast minutes at a cost, taking away resources and attention from serious consequential news. People can’t change situations if they don’t know what’s going on.

SIDEBAR: Choosing a Cover at Newsweek
In my quest to find out how the media selects what is and is not news, I attended an editorial meeting at Newsweek. The meeting was confidential so I can’t discuss specifics. However, I got the sense that they were discussing news not for the sake of important information, but for the sake of business. Though there was some mention of major international events and issues, it seemed to me that they gave too much attention to sex and scandal. In an interview afterwards, Bruce Ramsay, director of covers, said that Newsweek’s covers had to be the loudest story that appeals to the American public. In deciding the cover, Newsweek tries to strike a balance between what best appeals to people who buy the magazine at newsstands and what appeals to Newsweek’s subscribers. Ramsay commented that American people don’t care about international news; they just care about “shocking news.” When I asked if Newsweek would consider doing a cover story on Liberian president Charles Taylor and the situation in that country (rebels are approaching the capital), Ramsay replied that the story is “a little dry for a cover” and “doesn’t have enough of a hook.”

Journalists’ Views on the News
I raised my concerns about the American media’s news coverage to two newspaper reporters, Lyndsey Layton, of The Washington Post, and Mohamad Bazzi, of Newsday. Bazzi was a writer at New Youth Connections from 1990-1994. I also contacted two organizations that are often critical about how the mainstream media covers the news: Fairness and Accuracy in Reporting (FAIR) and Accuracy in Media (AIM), although I didn’t hear back from AIM. “The role of the news organization is to filter out the flotsam from the jetsam,” said Layton, who has the transportation beat at The Washington Post. “By definition, they cover some things while not others. If you pick up a copy of The Washington Post, The L.A. Times, Wall Street Journal, or The New York Times, they do pretty decent jobs covering the big issues of the day and events of the day.” Layton said that editors have to make choices and that they have only a limited number of pages. “I feel like on the whole, if you pick up a copy of the paper, you get a good sense, a glimpse, of what’s happening in the world.” But, she said, “Traditionally most American newspapers-and media certainly in general-are much more oriented towards domestic news than international, and it’s a weakness.” That may have something to do with the audience, she added. “Traditionally there hasn’t been an appetite for foreign news [in the U.S.].”
Too Much Fuss Over Chandra?
“I think that other media in other countries [cover international news] a lot better, especially in Europe-the British media and the French media,” said Bazzi, who reports for Newsday as a foreign correspondent in the Middle East and Afghanistan, “And they see it as an obligation to cover ethnic conflict in Nigeria and other places.” In the U.S., he said, “the real news got whittled down to nothing; foreign news got decimated.” During my interview, I explained that one dramatic story I thought was blown out of proportion was that of Chandra Levy. She’s the Washington intern whose disappearance last summer consumed the American media with endless speculations that Congressman Gary Condit, with whom she had an affair, had something to do with her disappearance. “Chandra Levy, now there was an important story,” Bazzi said sarcastically. “That the story completely disappeared shows how important that story was in the first place.” Layton, though, said her paper’s coverage of the Chandra Levy story was appropriate because Levy lived in Washington, D.C. and the scandal involved a member of Congress.
Appetite for Juicy Stories
But, she said, “I think right now in 2002, there’s a real appetite for sensational [and] juicy stories,” and some major news organizations increasingly “cover those stories at the expense of important stories.” Bazzi agreed. “There’s a tendency in the mainstream media to highlight entertainment stories or stories about movie stars or celebrity scandals at the expense of national issues, political and foreign issues.” Layton suggested that competition with the relatively new 24-hour cable news programs puts “pressure on mainstream papers. You have to keep up. You don’t want to get beat by one of the cable news programs.” If the cable news channels are attracting viewers with sensational stories, newspapers and broadcast news programs may try to grab some of the same audience by reporting the same kinds of stories. “I think for a long time there was a driving principle that celebrity news and scandal and outrageous, fairly simple, easy-to-digest news sells newspapers or magazines, and that people were bored about important issues,” Bazzi said. “Part of this was driven in general by how people reacted in opinion polls.”
It’s All About the Benjamins
So if sex and scandal is what sells, and massacres in Rwanda do not, then newspapers will focus on the sex and scandal. The more people watching a news broadcast or reading a newspaper, the more people there are to see the ads. Then the news organization can attract more advertisers or charge them more money. Another money issue, said Layton, is the cost of covering international news. “It’s very expensive to have staff oversees and have bureaus abroad,” she said. Steve Rendall, senior media analyst at FAIR, points to another problem related to money: “Media is being concentrated into fewer and fewer corporate hands [so that] 11 or 12 corporations control the majority of news.” That’s a problem in part because corporations care about their profits, not the public interest; that puts more pressure on the news organizations to go after what sells rather than what’s important. News Has to Make a Profit Rendall used the example of ABC, which is owned by Disney. “An ABC reporter will think twice” before doing a story exposing factory sweatshops that produce Disney toys. That’s a problem, said Rendall, because “there’s a professional obligation to report the news without fear or favor.” Rendall talked about the late William Paley, who ran CBS in the 1950s and 1960s. “He knew that news on CBS would sometimes lose money, but he said ‘It doesn’t matter-we owe it to the public.'” If need be, CBS would pay for the news with the money the network got from entertainment programming. The problem now, said Rendall, is that no one even pretends “that the news should be exempt from the bottom line. [Even] news has got to make a profit these days.”

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.