(Some names have been changed.)
I rushed out of school, so excited to see my mom again. Sure, I hadn’t missed her complaining and criticisms, but over the six weeks she’d been away at a job training program, I’d definitely missed our long car rides and late night talks. Right then my phone started to vibrate and I picked up before it even had a chance to ring.
“Hey Amanda. I’m already here in front of your school. Where are you?” my mom said.
“I’m right here. I’m wearing that orange Nike sweater and matching shirt you bought me. can’t you see me? I’m with Mara too. Is it OK if she comes with us?” I said.
“Umm, yeah. OK, OK, I see you now. Bye,” she said, hanging up abruptly.
As I looked around I saw my mom’s cherry-red car come toward my best friend Mara and me. Mara and I put our things in the trunk, and my mom came around the back of the car and looked me up and down. I knew this wouldn’t be good.
“Oh my God, Amanda! You’ve gotten so fat. I’ve never seen you like this. You’re huge! My God, you need to get on a diet!” she said.
I couldn’t believe my ears. I was caught so off guard, expecting to give my mom a warm welcome. Now, I felt more like retorting instead, but I held my tongue. Embarrassed, I looked at Mara and then at my mom and said, “Thanks, Mami. That’s good to know.”
So Secure in Her Arms
My mom and I have always been close. All my childhood memories until 1st grade are about spending time with her and my grandmother. A day wouldn’t pass by without me asking, “Mami, do you love me?” She would always say, “Yes, Amanda. I love you a lot!”
I knew the answer, but hearing it again always made me feel so confident in our relationship. It was like looking at myself in the mirror a thousand times on a good hair day; you know you look good, but it still makes you feel just as beautiful as the last time you checked.
She also praised me for certain things, saying I was well mannered, sweet and really smart. I relished every second of it. Sometimes when we were in bed about to go to sleep, I’d ask her again if she loved me. She’d repeat the same answer she always gave and just for reassurance I’d ask, “How much a lot? Like as big as the sky?” I’d open my tiny arms, gesturing at the huge sky.
And my mother would say, “No, more. As much as the universe!” She’d open her big, adult arms and I’d look with amazement. I felt so secure in her arms at night, sure that my mom loved me more than anything in the world.
Critical of Friends
At the same time, she’s always been judgmental. When I was a child she’d nag me about my weight, eczema (a skin condition) and messiness. It hurt being reminded of things I had to improve, but I didn’t take it so seriously because there were so many things she praised me about.
Yet as I grew up and began to hang out with friends more, my mom’s criticisms became more constant and hurtful. In 7th grade, I became good friends with a 16-year-old girl from the neighborhood, Tanya. I felt like I could talk to Tanya about anything because we had a lot in common.
My mom became apprehensive about our friendship, saying Tanya was boy-crazy and too old to be hanging out with me. If I was still talking to Tanya on the phone when my mother got back from work, she’d reprimand me. She’d even tease me about it, calling Tanya my mother: “Oh, on the phone with your mother again?”
Although she still denies it, I think she felt somewhat jealous and abandoned when I made friends, because that meant less time for us to be together. She’d always encouraged me to be more outgoing, but it felt like whenever a friend and I became really close she’d find something-or a lot of things-that she didn’t like about her.
When I began high school I hardly knew anyone, and to make things worse, my mom had to go to Savannah, Georgia, for a couple of months for job training. Although we fought a lot, I still went to her for advice and support, and counted on her to keep me in check. Now I only had my grandmother (who lives with us) to watch me. At first, I believed I could have a lot of fun letting loose and doing whatever I wanted. Instead, I went on a downward spiral.
Wake-Up Call
I stopped doing my work in school and started failing almost every class, something I was definitely not used to. I began eating more; a huge order of Chinese food and a pint of Ben & Jerry’s cookie dough ice cream became a nightly tradition for me. And to top it off, I began to fool around with every cute boy who was remotely interested in me. My life was out of control and deep inside I knew it, but I told myself this was what I was missing out on under my mother’s tyranny and I should enjoy it while it lasted.
That’s when my mother picked me up from school her first day back from Georgia. In the car I tried to change the subject by complimenting her on her hair and outfit, but when she saw me scratching my eczema she said impatiently, “Nena, leave your mouth alone, stop scratching! My God, you look so terrible. And couldn’t you have put on some prettier clothes for today? I leave for a month and you’re a complete mess. What you look like is a bum.”
My eyes started tearing up and I said, “OK Mami, whatever! I don’t care!” I just looked out the window, watching cars pass by, wishing I were in one of them instead of here.
It was a real wake-up call when my mother reacted to me in that way. It hurt that she was quicker to point out my flaws than to embrace me and tell me how much she’d missed me. She made me feel like her affection was almost conditional: if I wasn’t exactly how she left me, then she wasn’t so happy to see me.
Numb to Her Words
After that, it seemed like a day could not pass by without my mom being annoyed at something I did or didn’t do or say. I wasn’t used to my mom being this discontented with who I was and I didn’t know how to deal with it. I became resentful that there was no winning with her; I found myself not wanting to be near her for fear of having another argument.
I continued my bad habits-cutting class, not doing my work, eating a lot of junk food and dating a lot of boys. When my mom went to parent-teacher conferences, most of my teachers said the same things: that I barely handed in my homework and had too many absences, but that I was a smart girl and had so much potential.
My mother made sure I knew just how mad she was, yelling at me the whole car ride home. “Great, another thing my mom is going to endlessly yell at me about,” I thought. I was so used to my mom’s anger by then that I was almost numb to her words.
One day as I was sitting in 5th period English, a school aid came into class and handed out a whole bunch of fire-engine-red papers with bold, black lettering. As he wound his way through the desks, I prayed I wouldn’t get one, but just when I thought I was safe he planted a single sheet of paper on my desk with my name on it. I was on academic probation. I had to go to a meeting with my assistant principal, who said I needed to get my act together or he would make sure I was out of the school.
It made me furious to feel I was being called stupid, so I decided to apply myself. When the new semester started, I tried to not miss any homework. I actually studied for tests, and made sure I was in class on time.
Happy With Myself
When I got my report card, my grades were awesome. I was so happy with myself and I finally made my mom proud for the first time that year. Everything else started falling into place then, too. I went on a diet and lost almost 30 pounds.
I continued to date one guy after another, but I hid that from my mom because things were going so well in other areas and I didn’t want to ruin it. Then, late one night at the end of sophomore year, I was chatting online to a cute college guy, Brad, when he said he was outside my building. I rushed downstairs and took him to my floor. We spent hours on the stairs talking about everything and anything. Sooner than I wanted, he had to leave.
Waiting for the elevator, he kept looking at me. “So, you’re not going to give me a hug or anything?” he said.
I walked over and gave him a hug and he pulled me in so close I could feel him breathe. Before I knew it, we started kissing passionately. Then he got out of hand, touching me all over and pulling at my shirt. I kind of liked it at first, but I soon realized that this was wrong. I kept trying to push him away, but he had such a tight grip on me that I just gave in.
Angrier Than Ever Before
Suddenly I heard a door creak, and I realized it was my mother. She got angrier than I have ever seen her before. Brad ran away like a coward and my mom dragged me into the kitchen while I begged to solve things outside, for fear of waking up my grandmother.
“Amanda, tell me! What were you doing? You’re disgusting. I can’t even look at you,” she said. She started punching my arms and legs and shaking me. I was crying so hard I couldn’t breathe.
“Mami, I’m sorrrryyyy. We were just kissing. I’ll never do it again. I promise.” Tears streamed down my face like a waterfall. There was sadness in my mom’s eyes, and disappointment. I knew I’d hurt her and there was no taking it back.
I’d never felt so little. So not right. I felt like I deserved to be disowned. My mom and I had always slept hugging each other no matter what, but that night I made sure not to touch her. I felt as if I’d dirty her if I even breathed near her.
My mom ignored me for a few days before deciding that it was time to discuss things. She wanted to know everything that had happened with Brad. I told her that I knew what I did was wrong and I was really sorry, but that she had such a short temper I felt like I had to sneak around so she wouldn’t hate me.
My mom said she was not that unreasonable and she thought I knew I could talk to her about everything, but never in her life did she think I was capable of doing something so disrespectful to her, my grandmother and myself. She said she’d been so happy and proud with the improvements I’d been making, but after this I’d have to work hard to regain her trust.
I wanted her trust back more than the world. To this day I regret that night ever happened. Things with my mom were going so well and I threw it all away to hang out with some stupid guy I barely knew.
No Privacy
I’m also regretful because since that night, I’ve lost all my privacy. My mom reads through my text messages as well as my call log, my IMs, my pictures and even my MySpace. Worst of all, she told me that for her to forgive and forget, I’d have to stop hanging out with Tanya. I made that sacrifice because family is forever, while friends come and go. But I didn’t agree with my mom that Tanya was the root of my problems, and it still hurts a lot to think about how she made me do this.
I do think the incident helped my mom begin to realize that I’m not the little girl I was. She’s come to accept that I date and am physical with guys, so it’s easier to open up to her. Although she keeps tabs on me, she does let me go out a little more, and she’s even talking about letting me go away to college, which she didn’t want to do before.
But I still struggle with her inconsistency. Sometimes she’s so appreciative that I’m more honest with her, and it feels great. At other times she gets mad at the things I tell her and it makes me not want to tell her anything. I never know what I’m going to get.
Pulled Two Ways
I want my mom to know that she’s the best mother a girl could have, and that I know she wants to make me the best I can be. But at the same time, I wish that in trying to get me to improve, she wouldn’t use such hurtful words to get a reaction out of me. Those words make me feel like there’s always something wrong with me, and they push me toward not doing anything at all about my problems.
I’ve tried to talk to her about it several times, but she firmly believes in her method. I love my mother and always will; we can be the best of friends and have a lot of fun, whether it’s going shopping or watching and criticizing reality TV. I always count on her for an honest opinion, and her advice is often helpful.
But I constantly strive to gain some independence and still have a close relationship with my mom. The two just don’t mix, in her eyes, while I’m living under her roof. I want to be able to do what I think is acceptable, even if it doesn’t coincide with her morals. But there’s still that little girl part of me that just wants her to be proud of me and satisfied. I still want to be certain that she loves me as much as the universe.
As Much as the Universe
Struggling for independence, I still crave my mom's approval
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.