Are Our Parents the Victims, Too?

To children in foster care, parents can seem like the worst people in the world, maybe because foster kids feel deserted by their parents. They have so many questions that it seems only their biological parents can answer, questions like: Why am I in foster care? What is my purpose? Don’t my parents love me? Growing up in foster care, I, too, have walked around with a lot of questions and mixed feelings about parents.
But this past summer, I finally had the chance to hear the parents’ point of view when a bunch of us writers from Foster Care Youth United met with a group of parents whose kids had been in foster care. We were going to the meeting to learn how it felt for parents to have lost their kids to foster care, and, especially, to see if anything could have been done to stop their kids from entering the system in the first place.
The meeting took place on the east side of Harlem in New York City. What was messed up about where the interview happened was first that we were in the hood, then we interviewed the parents in a nursery: straight ghetto, or what?
Meeting the Biological Parents
When I first saw the parents, I thought that this was going to be an in and out interview. Ask questions, get answers, then leave. But it took a lot longer than I expected, and by the time my FCYU colleagues and I left the meeting, we were feeling a lot of strong emotions. Some of us were even crying.
The meeting started with an introduction by a man named Mike. Mike talked about the history of foster care, and how a lot of times people believe the parents of kids in foster care are bad parents, without remembering that often those parents are struggling to raise kids under very tough circumstances, like poverty, violent neighborhoods and unemployment. He suggested that if more parents in those neighborhoods were given the help they needed-like housing, child care help or even family counseling-their kids might be able to stay at home and out of the system. But lately, Mike said, people have been putting kids in foster care pretty fast without really trying to get their families the help they might need to stay together.
I felt what Mike was saying. But when the parents started talking, the meeting took a turn I wasn’t expecting.
Whose to Blame for Foster Care?
I and the other teen writers at FCYU have been through a lot of pain and struggle growing up apart from our biological parents. Listening to the parents of kids in foster care talk, I could see that a lot of them had gone through pain and struggles, too, like Diana, a Puerto Rican mother who lost her child due to her boyfriend’s domestic abuse. Diana’s son went into foster care not because she was a bad parent, but because of her boyfriend. Her son was placed in seven different homes in three months. Diana said the social worker told her after her son left one home,”They didn’t want your son because he’s Black.”
Diana fought six long years to get him back. When he finally came home, he had a lot of pain and hurt because of the years he’d lived in foster care. Diana cried and poured her heart out as she talked about all the negativity she and her son had been through. To me, personally, she was one of the realest of the parents. I felt sympathy for her.
But in my opinion, some of the parents were just complaining about how the foster care system did this and did that to them, without owning up to their own flaws. I mean, it took some parents many years to get over their addictions and do what they had to do to get their kids back. A year in a kids’ life is a long time. And many of those parents kept on having kids even while they were addicted to drugs. How can a parent complain about the foster care system when they put themselves and their children in that situation?
Pain, Anger and Confusion
My colleagues and I were mad to think that these parents seemed to be thinking only about how they were wronged. We didn’t understand why these parents had their kids when they couldn’t raise them. But we also could see that their pain was real. My feelings of anger and sympathy overwhelmed me.
Before the meeting, I was already confused as to why I had been placed in foster care and who was to blame for it. I couldn’t tell if it was my mother’s fault for being weak, my father’s for not being around, or the hood’s fault for being such a violent, drug-filled place to live. After interviewing the parents for three hours, I left even more confused. I still felt that the parents had no excuse for their actions that led to them losing their children, but I also understood that the parents had problems raising their kids that were, at least partly, out of their control, and had to do something with the poverty and abuse they had grown up with themselves.
For a long time after the meeting, I felt more pain and anger than I’d had in over a year. Maybe the reason for it was because they weren’t my parents we were interviewing, so in a way I vented my anger toward my parents through and at them. At the end of the day I felt that was wrong. But I also got tired hearing the parents complain about the system. I wanted to ask, “What about the children?”
Unanswered Questions
Foster children have no choice when they’re placed in foster care. Then the system often tosses children from one home to another, like we’re some old groceries. Then people wonder why so many foster children act out, and have anger toward the system and our parents. It’s no mystery to me. We didn’t ask to be put in this place. And we have so many questions, like, “Why didn’t our parents protect us from this place?”
I thought the meeting with the parents would answer more of my questions, but now I have more than ever.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.