An Adult in the Eyes of God

My bat mitzvah made me feel closer to my faith

The tape player just played static. “How am I ever going to do this if I can’t even get a stupid tape to work?” I thought.
Petrified because I didn’t think I knew the prayers well enough yet, I called my dad into my bedroom to help me. He fixed the tape by fast-forwarding it from the beginning, and a woman’s lovely tranquil voice came out of the tape player, singing the Hebrew prayers I needed to memorize. I used to love those words, but I’d recently grown to hate them.
“Let’s hear,” Dad said. I tried to make a connection with the strangely formed Hebrew letters on the page. I told my mouth to chant the magical old words in time with the cantor singing on the tape. (A cantor is one of the leaders of a Jewish synagogue, who chants prayers and leads the congregation during the singing.)
In my mind, I sounded awful, like one of the bad contestants on American Idol or a kid in a talent show without a chance. It felt like a race against time that I was losing badly.
“Sounds good,” Dad said. I just laughed. He couldn’t see any fault in his child, and he didn’t know how unsure I felt.
Should I Do It?
By the time I’d turned 12, trying to decide whether or not I’d have a bat mitzvah occupied most of my time. A bat mitzvah is a coming of age ceremony that Jewish girls have when they are 13 (boys have bar mitzvahs). It’s a religious service where Jewish boys and girls confirm that they want to be Jewish adults. I’d get to read from the Torah during services, which is the Bible for Jews (also called the Old Testament). It would be a big honor but something that would require a lot of work.
It wasn’t an easy decision. Did I really want to make this kind of commitment, to be considered an adult member of a faith?
I had my reasons for feeling uncertain. My mom was Catholic and my dad was Jewish, and at first my family followed both traditions. Until I was about 6, I thought everyone celebrated Christmas, Hanukah, Passover and Easter.
When I was in 1st grade, we joined Temple Israel on Staten Island where I live so I could attend Sunday school at the synagogue.
In 4th grade, I went to the temple’s Hebrew school where I learned to read and speak Hebrew. At first I went to Sunday school to play and see my friends. But as I got older I thought about the services more, and I started to feel more Jewish.
On my mom’s side, I still went to her family’s church for weddings and other important services but I didn’t go to regular Sunday services. The Catholic religion didn’t speak to me.
Choosing My Own Faith
Even though I was raised mostly Jewish, my parents let me choose what faith I wanted to practice at a young age. I chose Judaism because it spoke to me the most. I liked the way I could question things in the religion. The rabbi and members of the congregation discussed issues and practices, and I didn’t have to accept things just as the rabbi saw them. And Reform Judaism, which is my sect, is very open. For example, women can become rabbis and God isn’t seen as male.
But I wondered if I’d have time to study for a bat mitzvah, which would require weekly meetings with the rabbi, memorizing prayers in Hebrew and writing a speech on a section of the Torah.
Would it be a huge bat mitzvah monster that would take over my life, leaving no time for school, studying and hanging out with my friends? My friend Jenna said it took a lot of time and that she didn’t like the portion of the Torah she had to study.
On the other hand, if I did it I could look back on it with a sense of accomplishment and pride, the first girl in my family to go through the ceremony. I thought about how unhappy I might be if I decided not to have a bat mitzvah. I decided to jump on the “bat mitzvah boat.”
My Fears Got Worse
But my doubts and fears didn’t go away. I actually started to feel worse. Again, I asked myself, “Do I really want to make this kind of commitment to Judaism and to God?”
I didn’t feel like an adult in other ways. I still had to go to school. I wasn’t old enough to drive. And I certainly couldn’t stay out all night. I still viewed myself as a kid with a lot to learn. Was I ready for this?
Once I started my weekly bat mitzvah classes with Rabbi David Katz at the temple, I thought about calling the whole thing off. I had a recurring nightmare where I messed up the service. I’d either drop the Torah-forcing everyone in the congregation to fast for 40 days-or totally forget my speech.
Finally, after learning and translating my portion of the Torah into old English (which was hard to understand), I got to work with the modern translation about three months before my bat mitzvah. The words “God spoke unto Moses speak unto the children of Israel” became “God told Moses to speak to the Jewish people.”
A Light Bulb Goes Off
Seeing it written in modern English made a light bulb go off in my head. I could understand what I was saying about my portion of the Torah, which was about the sabbatical year and slavery.
When I discussed my Torah portion with Rabbi Katz, I had serious questions about the sabbatical year (every seventh year when everyone was freed from debt, slaves were let go and no work was to be done) and the jubilee year (every 40th year, where similar things happened). I thought the part about Jews having slaves was strange. Jews were slaves in Egypt-as recalled in the Passover story-so I never thought about Jewish people having slaves. I told him it didn’t seem fair that Jews would have slaves.
“It wasn’t slaves but servants who had to work the house or land for a certain amount of time and at the end of that time they got paid,” said Rabbi Katz.
This was my first one-on-one meeting with the rabbi, with whom I’d never discussed anything. Before I started bat mitzvah classes, I’d only seen him during services and other events at the temple. Having him listen to me made me feel like I had an important voice and opinions to give. And I had fun arguing about important topics with an authority figure.
When the rabbi had to take a phone call one day during our meeting, I started thinking about all the experiences I’d had at my temple. This was the place where I’d once wondered what was in our temple’s ark (a sacred cabinet). When I was little, I thought it was filled with dead bodies from Indiana Jones, but I learned it was where the temple kept different copies of the Torah.
Where I Thought About God
More importantly, this was the place where I’d thought about God for the first time. I saw how much I had grown up in this place. I’d gone from a little child who came to make crafts and eat cookies at Sunday school to a young teenager who could question things about Judaism and my spiritual life.
I saw at that moment what I’d known in my mind and heart all along. This was the faith I believed in, and I wanted the world to know that I wanted to be a Jewish adult. My synagogue was where I first thought of God, formed every image I have of God, and where I felt at peace.
“I believe in this,” I thought. “The Jewish faith and the way it portrays God is a practice I see fitting in my life. It’s who I am. This is what I have to do for myself.”
Even though I had made the commitment to myself, it still wasn’t all smooth sailing. About a month before my bat mitzvah, Rabbi Katz told me that my mother wouldn’t be allowed to pass the Torah down to me because she wasn’t Jewish.
But she was one of the key people in my Jewish upbringing. I thought it was unfair, and I began to have doubts again. But Mom said to go through with it anyway. She said she’d support me from the seats, and she later converted to Judaism.
On May 17th 2003, the big day finally arrived. Seated in a chair on the bima (like an altar in a church), I was petrified. As the service started, I couldn’t think about anything except how scared I felt.
I recall looking out on the crowd of about 100 people and thinking, “Who are all these people? Do I even know them?” But as I started to get into the service, I saw it was my mom, dad and other people I knew and loved. Everyone looked so happy, and seeing them calmed me down.
Leading the Prayers
Rabbi Katz said a blessing I can’t remember, explained what a bat mitzvah was and smiled at me as he left the podium. My legs shook and I don’t know how I got up there. I was shocked at how confident my voice sounded in the thin microphone.
“Please rise and turn to page 101,” I said.
Wait, was that me? My eyes looked up from the book of prayers, which were already engraved in my mind from every Saturday service since before I could read. I saw how happy my parents looked in the front row.
My Uncle Danny, Aunt Gloria and cousin Adam smiled at me. And my Christian relatives Aunt Cathy and Uncle Bill from California looked happy to be there, too.
What My Heart Wanted
After my speech, when the Torah was being put back in the ark, I thought about what I was doing. I was overjoyed I’d gone through with it. Having a bat mitzvah felt like what my heart wanted me to do.
The service flew by so fast, even though I was the one leading most of the prayers. I gave my speech on my Torah portion about freedom and the jubilee year. I even remembered to look at the four corners of the room, like the rabbi said I should, to make eye contact with everyone. After my speech in English, I read from the Torah in Hebrew. OK, I messed up one line, but who really knew, and I did so much stuff right.
“Wait! After all of my work and preparation-that’s it?” I thought. Although the service took over an hour, it felt like it was only 15 minutes long. My mom said it was like a wedding, where you plan a lot for it and then it’s over.
My parents made their speeches standing next to me on the bima, and those were so touching. They said I’d done great but that they were not the least bit shocked. Everything just seemed to come together at the end.
Worth the Sweat and Tears
After the service my friend Isabel said, “You were great. I didn’t understand one word but it was still great.” I agreed!
Was it worth all the sweat and tears I put into it? Yes. I’d do it all over again. It gave my self-confidence a 100% boost. Now I feel more confident about things that used to scare me, like public speaking.
From a questioning and scared 12-year-old wondering how a service would impact my life, I’d grown into an young adult who did something difficult and time-consuming on my own and developed confidence speaking in front of crowds. I’d blossomed from a bud into a flower.
I also feel more like an adult in the Jewish community now. I am more connected at services as an adult member of the congregation. I can carry the Torah into Saturday services and say certain blessings. My relationship to God has become stronger, something I feel especially when I’m attending services.
Most importantly, it was only after my bat mitzvah that I realized I had already committed to Judaism before the ceremony. My bat mitzvah just made the commitment I’d had my whole life official.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.