Am I Really a Catholic?

I’m proud to be a Catholic. I believe in Jesus, in heaven and hell, in the Saints, and in God. The reason I continue to hold onto the Catholic religion is so I always have something to believe in.
But as I grow older, sometimes I’m not sure how proud I really am. In fact, I consider myself to be a “Cafeteria Catholic,” a nickname for a person who picks and chooses among the Church’s teachings.
I believe in and follow most of the teachings of the Church. But some of the Church’s teachings bother me, especially those that condemn homosexuality, sex before marriage, and the use of contraception. The fact that I disagree doesn’t affect my faith in God, but it does affect my faith in the beliefs of the Catholic Church.
Teens and Sex
Since I started Catholic school in the first grade, I have been taught to believe in God, Jesus, the Saints, and the Bible. But I didn’t find out until junior high that there were parts of my religion that would be hard for me to agree with.
One day in seventh grade, the science teacher came into the room to teach us sex education. The boys went into another room with the male principal while the girls stayed with our female science teacher. The teacher explained the anatomies of men and women, sexual intercourse, and how babies are born. She also told us the Church says that we must wait to have sex until we’re married.
I was okay with that because I was young and free of any cares. But even though I wasn’t worried about having sex, I soon discovered in high school that many teens were no longer waiting. Despite the teachings of their parents and the Church, teens today have sex.
Personally, sex is not an important factor in my life. I have been tempted with sex before, but my beliefs are so strong that I will continue to postpone those urges. Waiting for that special person to come into my life before I give him something I cherish as my own is okay for me. I’ll wait until I get married because I hope to marry a man I will always love. For me, love comes before sex.
But what if you are Catholic and decide to have sex before marriage? Can you do that and still be a good Catholic? I believe your decision depends on what you feel and what you believe is right for you.
Condemning Gays
When I entered high school, I learned that the Catholic Church believes that homosexuality is a sin. I felt angry and confused because the Bible says not to judge, but here the Catholic Church is judging and condemning gay people.
This one hit me hard. I had just met a guy named Jason (not his real name). We had so much in common. We both liked to go shopping and the boy could dress better than me. We listened to all kinds of music, from Red Hot Chili Peppers to House II Boyz to Men. We talked about what happened at the Limelight and the Tunnel. I liked the way Jason was carefree most of the time, and through our likenesses we became best friends and still are to this day.
Jason happens to be a gay teen. I really didn’t care because I knew this before we became friends and I had no problems with it. I got to know the person before I judged.
My friendship with Jason began my days of converting to a “Cafeteria Catholic.” I choose to be friends with Jason despite the beliefs of the Catholic Church. That’s what a Cafeteria Catholic does-picks and chooses what to believe-and that’s what I did.
I didn’t worry about it too much until one day when I was talking to a woman who I taught Sunday school with. I had respected her for a long time. While we were talking, she said things like, “Those fags had their little queer parade yesterday and they made me sick.”
I didn’t say anything because I was afraid I would have burst into tears. What she said hurt my feelings, my heart, and diminished my respect for her.
Abortion is a Right
The Catholic Church thinks that gay people are evil because of their sexual orientation, but my friend Jason is not “evil.” The Bible may say that homosexuality is wrong, but it also says not to judge another. Jason’s my friend; the Church cannot change that fact.
As time passed, I learned that the Church views abortion as an evil act. Personally, if I got pregnant I would choose not to have an abortion. I don’t agree with the killing of an unborn human being, and it bothers me when I hear of young girls who have abortions every time they get pregnant. But I still believe that women have the right to choose what they want to do with their bodies. By law, women have this right.
I believe that only an individual can make the decision of whether or not to have an abortion. I am against the violence committed by anti-abortion fanatics. I don’t believe the Church should tell me or anyone else how to make this decision.
A Different World
The last Church belief I disagree with is that no contraception of any kind (birth control pills, condoms, etc.) should be used. Such a belief is unfair and unrealistic. With many STDs going around and AIDS a major concern, protection is essential. There is no way that any sexually active person should not protect herself.
The only other method of protecting yourself from disease or pregnancy is abstinence (not having sex). But since many are unwilling to abstain, it is necessary for people to use contraception. I believe the Church is denying people the right to a safer life by condemning the use of protection.
Certain beliefs of the Church don’t relate to teens today. Our attitudes and individual beliefs have turned completely around compared to past generations. But just because I do not believe or practice everything the Church preaches, it doesn’t make me any less of a Catholic.
Being a true Catholic means having faith in God, yourself, and those you trust; it means to forgive and to love. There is more to life than worrying if you’re a good or bad Catholic. As the song by Joan Osborne asks, “What if God was one of Us?” Would She/He understand what it really is like living in this screwed up world with diseases, and pressures, and anything that goes? I can’t believe the things we go through every day, especially living in New York.
It’s for you and only you to make up your mind when you are ready to have sex, if you’re gay or want to be friends with gay people, if you need to protect yourself using condoms or birth control, or if your last resort in becoming pregnant is to have an abortion. The Church should be our guide and our mentor, not a dictator.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.