Adventures in Prep School: The Making of a Misfit

When I was 12 years old, I went to a party at a rich classmate’s apartment. She lived in a duplex three times the size of my apartment, with picture windows overlooking Central Park.
The living room was so neat that it reminded me of a hospital-white couches, white carpets, white walls. It was all so clean it almost glowed.
I couldn’t believe my eyes. I didn’t know apartments like that even existed!
I had to make a private phone call, so I headed up the spiral staircase to my friend’s room.
Hundreds of CDs were carelessly scattered on her floor. Her closet door was open, and inside I could see all the clothes I had ever wanted.
She had about 20 pairs of shoes, all lined up in rows.
I looked down at my battered Pumas and felt ashamed. I wished I was her.
Feeling Poor and Out Of Place
That was during 7th grade, my first year at The Brearley School, a small, prestigious girls’ school on the Upper East Side.
I started going there because the school offered me a full scholarship. That was an offer too good to pass up.
But sometimes, I wish it had been an offer I had ignored. Most of the other students were really rich, and I never felt comfortable around them.
In some ways I am glad I went to Brearley because it was the most intellectually stimulating environment I have ever been in.
While I was there I learned many things-like how to speak Latin and interpret operas-that I probably never would have learned in public school.
But I also learned that education in such an unhappy environment is practically pointless.
Don’t get me wrong-education is very important.
But because I didn’t like Brearley, it was wasted. I was so unhappy most of the time that I spent more energy focusing on ways to get out of school than on studying and learning.
Expensive Clothes and Skinny Thighs
Being at Brearley made me feel so out of place. The majority of the girls who weren’t on scholarship lived incredibly pampered lives. I wanted everything they had: their houses, their looks and their clothes.
Most of them had huge apartments. One girl lived in a five-floor brownstone, and each floor had a balcony with a garden.
No one there ever had break-outs, and all but about four or five girls had perfectly skinny bodies. Their little toothpick legs made it easy to follow the middle school trend of shortening your uniform skirt to about a foot above the knee.
I was never brave enough to try that-just the thought of exposing my thighs to the world made me quiver.
Their looks were helped along by dermatologists, plastic surgeons and expensive makeup. My facial regimen consisted of a jar of Noxzema!
Their clothes were all from the trendiest places in the city.
Sometimes I would run into them at Urban Outfitters and they’d be buying everything in sight. If I was lucky, maybe I could get one sweater.
They Took Money For Granted
The girls at Brearley seemed to take the things they had for granted, which made the scholarship kids feel like crap.
Before vacations, they’d moan things like “Oh no! Not Europe/Nantucket/the private family island again!”
Me and my friends were stuck in New York.
Most of them tried really hard to be nice, but it was hopeless.
They had been raised by parents who kept them very sheltered. One girl wasn’t even allowed to take the subway!
And how could they know what a regular apartment was like? All of their friends lived like them, and I wouldn’t even allow school friends in my house-a one-bedroom apartment in Midtown. I was always afraid they’d laugh.
Green With Envy
I began to consider all of their riches normal, which made me feel inferior. I thought of myself as dirt poor. In reality, I was just your average, middle class girl.
I was really jealous, and I started to hate those girls. I thought they were snobby b-tches. Some of them were.
One girl had the audacity to say that the quality of the school had gone down since all the “scholarship kids” had arrived. I ended up being prejudiced against all rich people, which in a way, made me a snob.
Not only did the students make me feel like I didn’t fit in, but sometimes I suspected that Brearley was going out of its way to make me feel unwelcome.
Ashamed Of My Parents
The administration threw “mother/ daughter teas” in the middle of the day when they knew that some of our moms had to work.
Not that I was so thrilled about going to a tea, but it would have been nice to know that I could’ve gone if I had wanted to.
The worst Brearley events were those during which our parents had to meet. The room would be full of perfectly coiffed, well-dressed moms and successful fathers in suits and ties.
Then I would arrive with my mom. She dressed like a normal mom, but in that crowd of Chanel suits, she stuck out. Not that it was her fault; she worked too hard to have time for lengthy hair dressers appointments or shopping sprees.
My father never came to school functions, but if he had, he would have been dressed in some ratty t-shirt, a pair of jeans and some beaten up shoes.
I became ashamed of my parents. Why weren’t they that successful? Why couldn’t they be so well-dressed?
Finding Friends: the ‘Scholarship Kids’
Feeling that jealous all the time was hard. I began to think that my bitter feelings made me a horrible person. Now I think anyone in her right mind would feel that way. I felt so ashamed of everything in my life. It was awful.
Being on scholarship made me feel separated from the rich girls. And at first, I also felt isolated from the other “scholarship kids.”
Most of them were from a program called “Prep for Prep,” which helps minorities get financial aid from private schools.
They had less money than me, they were all minorities and they came from other boroughs. To them, I was a little White girl from Manhattan. But as time went on, we became more comfortable with each other.
Worse For Minorities
I spent all my time with this group of about 12 girls, and I grew to really love them. It was nice to get to know people of different races; before Brearley, almost all my friends had been White. While I was there, most were Black or Hispanic.
As bad as things at Brearley got for me, I knew they were having a harder time. Being a minority at Brearley wasn’t easy.
Once, the administration broke up a table of minority girls and told them to stop being so exclusive. All they were trying to do was have lunch with their friends.
Even though I made friends, I was still pretty depressed about not fitting in. But once I realized I was never going to fit in at Brearley, I figured I might as well take it all the way.
Drinking, Smoking and Wearing Black
I got my nose pierced (which was considered shocking), and started dressing weird (by Brearley standards, that is). All I really did was wear cheesy band t-shirts and lots of black.
I was so depressed that I started to drink and smoke weed a lot. I don’t think I would have started those things if I had been in a happier environment.
After just a few years at Brearley, I went from a preppy, studious girl to a highly depressed, freaky looking kid who tried to avoid school as much as humanly possible.
I used to fake being sick a lot so I could stay home. When my mom stopped believing me, I’d hide out in the nurse’s office, which had comfy bunk beds and stuffed animals.
The whole objective of my life became hating Brearley, hating my classmates and trying to alienate people. If I wasn’t going to fit in, I wanted people to think that I liked it that way.
But I didn’t, so after a lot of begging, I convinced my mom to let me transfer.
I went to Bronx Science for two years, but I didn’t like that much better. Finally, I switched to City-as-School, an alternative public school.
Finally, a School Where I Fit In
Sometimes, when I feel depressed, I think that leaving Brearley was a bad move. Maybe if I had stayed I’d be applying to better colleges. But I probably would have been miserable.
Now that I’m at CAS, I feel so much better about myself. Financially, there isn’t much different between me and other students, so I don’t get envious all of the time.
I’m not surrounded by people in the latest fashions from Saks Fifth Avenue anymore, which makes me feel a lot better about my clothes.
For the first time in my life I feel like I’m capable of doing things just as well as anyone else, even if I can’t afford Latin tutors or expensive courses.
It might seem strange that I threw away a wonderful education over things as insignificant as expensive clothes and skinny thighs. But when you’re 12 years old, fitting in seems like the most important thing in the world. And in some ways, it is.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.