It all started one night at a party. After my peeps and I had finished politicking, my boy asked me to get him a chick he saw. I went to the chick’s table, and that’s when I first saw Toya (not her real name). She had a grill on that you could feel across the room. Any guy would have been scared of the look on her face.
I chilled with the girls for like five, got the shorty and took her to my man. Then I decided to choose a bird. Back at their table, shorty was still looking vexed, but I decided I wanted a challenge.
Inside My Walls
After Toya and I started to talk, we moved to our own table and started to build on anything to everything. We talked about our lives, past relationships, future plans, Giuliani, you name it. She had this balance of hood and class that’s so attractive. I won’t lie, after I started to see who she was, I was blown.
Now before I go on with my story of love and loss, let me take a second to explain my past mentality. Plain and simple, I was at the party just ta get a nut off. I’m not going to go into my whole life story-let’s just say I started building up my walls as a child, even as young as 3 or 4.
I saw my father controlling my mother by beating her. And at times, I became a target of their anger at each other. I was just a little kid who couldn’t quite understand why they tried to use me against each other or why they took their anger out on me. I was scared at times, and felt powerless.
I didn’t want anyone else to have power over me, so I tried to protect my emotions.
Playing Mind Games
Instead, I developed different ways to break chicks mentally, telling them that I loved them when I didn’t, and playing other mind games. I’d never hit a woman, because then I’d be like my pops. But f-cking with chick’s emotions and testing their points of breaking was my way to release my anger.
I figured if they were dumb enough to believe a n-gga when he says he loves you, they must be dumb. If my defenses couldn’t be broken down easily, then neither should theirs.
But the truth is, I always dreamed of meeting someone who could break down my walls and make me feel secure when I was totally vulnerable to her, someone who could just look me in the eye and I’d know everything would be all right.
I guess I thought Toya could make my dreams come true. Even on that first night, Toya had a defiance about her. At the end of the evening, she gave me a kiss on the cheek, not on the lips; she made it clear sex wasn’t something three words could get you.
Toya showed me she wasn’t an easy one to deceive, and after talking to her, I didn’t want to. Before Toya, I never knew a girl who could make me feel like that.
No More Dark Clouds
I went back to the house after the party ranting about how I thought I finally found someone to make wifey. Everybody just took it as words, but with Toya I was serious.
In the months that we went out, Toya and I never really had big important conversations on politics or world hunger (although we felt what we said was important). We were just glad to be with each other.
Toya ain’t complain if I chilled wit my peeps all weekend. She did the same. But on days when we had planned to see each other, I’d wake up and have a smile on my face the whole day. Before Toya, relationships felt empty. But now even when I was mad, I would be around her and my dark clouds just weren’t there.
One time on our lunch break, we met at a park by the river and talked about our bosses and co-workers, then got real philosophical and talked about life. Then she held me and said, “I love you.” Those are the kind of times I most remember.
I won’t lie, though, it was scary giving someone my heart. My friends said I was a fool for passing up chicks with whips and dimes. I thought maybe I was a fool, too. Even though Toya usually made me feel it was all alright, part of me never truly felt on solid ground. I mean, everything sweet I’d ever done or said with other girls was said or done without meaning, just to manipulate. So how could I be so sure it wasn’t being done to me?
Too Much Too Handle
And sometimes my fears led me to cheat. Toya would do something that I resented. She’d make me feel like an -ss, or not be somewhere when I wanted her to be.
Like one time I was calling her to get her dress size ’cause I had some paper and wanted to get her something nice. But every time I called she wasn’t there. So after a while I started to feel like a jerk, and just said f-ck it. And that’s exactly what I did, with another girl.
But after a couple of months, I hardly gave other girls any time. If I got a number, I’d throw it away before I got on the train home. If my friends tried to hook me up, in the end I’d always end up hearing the song “What Kind of Man Would I Be?” by Mint Condition playing over and over in my head, and I’d just bounce.
Then things began to go bad.
Things first fell apart after we had been going out for three and a half months. I found out Toya had lied to me-saying she was 16 when she was really only 14-and my trust and some of my heart just crumbled. Maybe it doesn’t seem like a big deal. After all, I had cheated and lied, too. But it hurt that the one person I thought I could trust had deceived me.
We broke up. But I really missed Toya, and after a couple of months we got back together. After that, we were good together for about nine months. I was faithful and romantic. Roses and surprise picnics in the park were not unusual. I told her almost all of my secrets ’cause I trusted and loved her. Even if it didn’t work out, I believed she’d never betray me.
But then my feelings got so strong it was starting to scare me. I started to see her face everywhere. Anytime I used the phone I had to dial the number twice, because no matter what the number, I would instinctively dial hers. Every day all day among all my other thoughts at any time she was on my mind.
Running Scared
I had let her have power over me when I’d said I never would. But now it felt like she had too much power. I felt scared, suffocated, like I had to get away. So I started talking to one of her best friends in hopes that Toya would find out and get mad. (She didn’t.) Then I took chicks to places I knew her or her friends would be.
We fought. She said that if I broke up with her and we ever got back together, she wasn’t going to be faithful. I had known for a long time that she was bisexual. Now she said that if I broke up with her, she was going to start dating chicks.
Still, I broke up with her. But then I missed her too bad all over again, and we got back together. After that last time, though, she just wasn’t going to trust me anymore, and she wouldn’t break up with this chick she had started seeing. I was really mad, but I also thought that it was partially my fault.
The Player Got Played
Everything felt unsure. Toya just wanted to wild out. It seemed like she couldn’t be monogamous for more than 24 hours. She wouldn’t call me for days, even weeks. Then she would give me all types of excuses that I knew she knew I wouldn’t believe.
I knew she was playing with my head the way I’d played with other girls’ heads. But I didn’t want this to end. I felt like I was one of those chicks I had f-cked over. Which is probably one of the reasons I stayed so long. Even though I knew it, I didn’t want to accept that I was being played.
A Fool Too Long
Finally, one day after a couple of months of this, I heard about yet another chick she had been with, and I knew I just had to call things off. I just looked myself in the mirror and told myself I had been playing fool for too long. I was fed up and ashamed.
I loved and still love this girl to the fullest, and the pain of losing her is strong. I would do anything to have what we had. But now that I’ve had it all blow up in my face, I’m not sure it’s something I’ll try to start with another girl or let happen again.
Broken-Hearted
I’ve tried to tell myself that I’d never go back to my old ways, using girls while pretending to care about them. But after having my heart broken, sometimes I’m tempted to. I’m not saying I’m gonna just run out there and cause 10 broken hearts because mine is broke. But I know I’d rather be in Toya’s position-being the user-than mine. It’s just safer that way.
Still, when I look back over the past two years, I see that I’ve changed. My relationship with Toya helped me to free myself, and not just with her, either. Now I let myself feel my emotions more, and I don’t worry about what others think as much-and those are good things that stay with me.
Love was one of the most painful, but also one of the happiest experiences I’ve ever had. Toya got me good. But she also showed me something I’d always looked for, even if just for a brief period.
A Player Gets Played
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.