A Letter to `Ma’

Dear Ma,
Ma, first off, I want you to know that I love you with all my heart. I appreciate all that you have done for me, as well as tried to do for me, over the years. But I have questions that I would like to ask you that have been bothering me for a number of years. They have been bottled up inside of me for so long. I feel I have to ask them to be at peace with myself.
2. You will get to see this letter. Writing it hurt me. I would never want to hurt you, but it’s time that the truth comes out about my feelings. That is why this letter was written, from me to you.
3. I would like to know why you held the truth from me. I think I could have handled it. I understand that the loss of your arm in the train accident had to have had a devastating affect on you. I’ve gotten so many different accounts of the story. All I know is you were going to nursing school and you were waiting in the subway and someone wanted your pocketbook and pushed you onto the train tracks.
4. Why did you let it get to you so badly that you had to be institutionalized most of my childhood? Every couple of weeks I would see you. Many times I wouldn’t because you were in the hospital. I want to know why you were repeatedly in and out of the hospital.
When you were out, you came to see me after school. But I was told not to let you in the house until grandma came home, because grandma was worried about how you’d act. Because of grandma saying those things about you, I feel we never got along. When we argued, all grandma would say is I’d end up “like my parents.”
5. I have explained some things to you, but there are so many more things that I want to tell you. Maybe there will be a time when I will tell you. Or maybe I’ll take them to my grave.
6. Do you know what effect your being away had on me? I understand you weren’t emotionally ready to care for a child, but was it so bad that you couldn’t push your problems aside and take care of me? I remember every couple of months I would see you, but for long periods of time you weren’t there. When I asked, “Grandma, where is my mommy?”, all she used to tell me was, “Your mommy is sick in her head and has to stay in the hospital.”
7. As a result, I vied for any woman’s attention. When I went to church, there was a lady I liked. She always used to talk to me and give me candy and presents. I used to call her “MA.” Since then I called any woman I liked, and who I considered a motherly figure, “MA.”
I was at a friend’s house recently. She has two kids, is 26 years old, and is living in her own apartment. She was speaking to her mother, and I heard her say, “Yes, Mommy.” I couldn’t believe it. I don’t even call my own mother “Mommy” because you were never there.
8. Over the years I’ve seen the difference in my friends’ mommies. I’ve learned to resent your difference. When I was younger, I thought it was normal for you to have an arm missing. But then I started to dislike it to the point where I didn’t want to be around you. On the weekends you’d come to see me. I’d fake that I was sleeping so I didn’t have to be with you.
Grandma didn’t help either, by saying to me when we would argue, “You’re gonna be just like your parents. Your mother is crazy, your father is crazy, so you’re gonna be crazy.”
Now I realize that you aren’t crazy. You just have a different way of dealing with your problem than someone else does.
9. Being in foster care leaves a lot to be desired. I often wondered if you were “normal,” would I be where I am today? Would I have gone through all these changes? I wonder now what “normal” really is.
10. Whatever we had together when I was a child is unfortunately, gone. It’ll never be the same between us, like other mother-and-daughter relationships. It took too many years for our relationship to get where it is today.
Since I’ve been separated from my son, I’ve realized how you might have felt being separated from me. How useless you might have felt. I’m in the process of closing the gap that has kept me away from you for so long.
Love,
Jessie

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.