A Father-Shaped Hole

I wish my father could have been more like my husband

I don’t have many early childhood memories of my father. When I try to recall being with him, I mostly see a hole instead. He split from my mother when I was very little. I went into foster care when I was a baby. I spent most of my childhood going back and forth between care and my mom’s, and I only saw my dad occasionally.
Often I would spend weekends with him. But those weekend visits were more like grandparents’ time than father-and-daughter time because most of the time, his parents took care of me. He always had to work overtime. He took me shopping to buy things and that was our only time together. At the time I thought that was normal.
Being married to a good husband and father (see husband Michael’s story on p. 20) has brought up a lot of delayed anger at my father. Being a mother to my daughters and seeing how happy they get when they’re around their father makes me think that if I could have had more time with my father, then maybe I would have been happy growing up, instead of the depressed girl I was.
The anger first hit me when I was giving birth to my first daughter Emma in July 2007. My mother told me that I was lucky to have Michael in my life because when she was giving birth to me, my father was away at work. I wanted to cry at the thought of my mother giving birth to me without the support of my father.
My father was usually gone during my childhood, either at work or living somewhere else. He thought that sending letters and money to replace his absence was enough, and at the time I thought it was too. The young Erica felt her father was perfect-what more could a father do than to treat his daughter with lots of toys and goodies? We did fun things together like shopping at the mall and renting movies and video games at Blockbuster.
Not too many kids around my’hood had their fathers around. My father, on the other hand, would drop by and spend money on not only me, but my friends as well. My friends looked up to me because of that. It didn’t bother me then: As a child, that was love and affection to me.
Seeing Me in Emma
But as I became older, I felt lonely. I started to realize that I was buying my friends, and in some way my father was trying to buy my love. But I loved my father whether he brought me stuff or not. I realize now that what I needed was for him to spend some time with me. Even now, with my wonderful husband and daughters, thinking about my father makes me feel abandoned and unloved.
I get surprised by these feelings all the time as my daughters grow. One day when Michael had to work overtime, Emma just stood at the door calling, “Daddy!” She picked up one of his shoes and started to hug the shoe like it was Michael. I cried tears of joy about how much she loves him, but also tears of pain. I saw how important her father is to her.
Michael is a wonderful father and husband. He checks to make sure we’re OK and cares about us and is always there to support the family.
Being with a man who’s a good father brings up so many strange feelings. For example, because my father was a workaholic, I worry that Michael will develop the same obsession for working as my father and it wouldn’t only affect me, it would affect our girls as well. When Michael first began working I went all mental. I started to whine like a scared 10-year-old; I was confused and felt like Michael was my father. I have also caught myself being jealous of the attention Michael gives our daughters.
Money but No Time
I didn’t think of my relationship with my father as financial when I was little. Only after I was diagnosed with bipolar and then borderline personality disorder, when I was 12, did I start to think he should be around more. I went into a state hospital and stayed there for a little over a year. I needed special attention and I figured my father would come rescue me, but he was nowhere to be found.
Right after that, at age 13, I went into foster care for good. He didn’t even try to take me in. He just let the system place me into some stranger’s home. Many times after that, I acted out and made suicide attempts. The hospital became my safe haven.
When I finally did get back in touch, he kept promising that he was going to visit and try his best to get me out of foster care. I was being bounced around from foster home to hospitals, from residential treatment centers to group homes, and I felt abandoned by him.
Yet I still confided in him when I was a teenager. I hugged him whenever I saw him and always said, “I love you” at the end of our calls. We talked very little, but I enjoyed talking about the TV shows, movies, and video games he liked. We did a lot of boyish things together like watching wrestling and NBA games or playing video games and renting movies.
Always Rushing
My father finally got me out of the system when I was 15, to live with him for a trial discharge. I was hopeful. I thought we were finally going to have a good daughter-father relationship. I hoped for more quality time, but my father was like the White Rabbit from Alice in Wonderland, always running late, always rushing to get somewhere.
Living with him was not what I’d hoped for. He would buy me everything I wanted but basically kept me locked in the house. I believe it was his way of protecting me from the world. He did let me go to school and he let me go out shopping with him, but I wanted friends to hang out with. I had to sneak out to make friends.
He was like two different people sometimes. He would go from completely ignoring me to trying to control me and take away my freedom. It made me feel like a prisoner.
As a person he is usually kind, caring, and sharing. He tries to be nice to everyone, share if he has it, and help out whenever he can. But when he thinks someone has double-crossed him he gets angry, sometimes at the wrong people. Instead of letting loose on the people who took advantage of his kindness, he explodes at innocent people. I wasn’t scared of him, exactly, but I sure didn’t want him ever thinking I’d tried to double-cross him!
Separated Again, Forever
When I realized that we weren’t going to have the relationship I hoped for, I started misbehaving in school. I was put on probation for snapping on a pregnant girl. I was kicked out of school.
My father and I were living in New Jersey with my grandfather when suddenly my grandfather passed away. I took his loss hard. What made it even harder is that my father yelled at me that I had caused my grandfather’s death. (He never explained how; till this day I still don’t know how or why my grandfather died.) I left my father’s to stay with my aunt here in New York, which violated my probation. But I was going through a lot of pain and I needed to get away from home.
For violating probation, I was placed back into my residential treatment center, and I never lived with my father again. He went back to working long hours and sending me packages in the mail with “I love you” letters. Even though I was disappointed, I still liked getting the letters. It showed he cared enough to at least drop a letter in the mail to me.
Bottled Up
In some ways, our father-and-daughter relationship is the same now as when I was a child and teenager-except for my new feelings of anger. He continues to miss out on important events such as holidays, birthdays, and, I must not forget, my wedding. It would have been nice for him to give me away, but I didn’t even invite him to the ceremony because I knew he’d say he was too busy.
It’s always painful to see him because it’s never for long, and I never know when he is going to visit again. I start to feel neglected all over again.
Yet I have never tried to tell him about this anger that I’ve felt since I gave birth to Emma. When he calls to check in on me I talk to him like everything is all peaches and cream. I’m not pretending with him, it’s just that I am usually not angry at the moment we talk.
When I know I am going to be seeing my father, I tend to suppress the anger. I usually feel my anger at him around people or places from the past, or when I see Michael with Emma. It starts bringing flashbacks when I am by myself thinking about my life. It’s like I forget Emma is my daughter and start seeing her as a rebirth of me.
On a deeper level, I may also suppress my anger when I’m with my father for fear of lashing out and losing him forever. When I am angry, I can lose control and get loose with the mouth. I start doing and saying things out of the ordinary and I may bring up past problems. I do this with people I trust: Michael, my mother, and close friends. I do not feel secure enough with my father to say, “Hey, I don’t like this about our relationship.”
Three Wishes
I question why my father couldn’t spend time with me when it seems so easy for Michael to be there-emotionally, mentally, and physically-for our daughters. I wonder sometimes if my father ever loved me or am I just a mistake that he decides to brush off with money. My mother says he never wanted a girl; if I was a boy maybe he would have been around more.
Maybe he hasn’t tried to see his grandchildren because they are girls. He may have been by to visit if I had given birth to boys. He’s only seen Emma, who’s 1½, once, and he’s never seen baby Michel. Every time he sends money to buy the babies things, it seems that he will never learn that there is so much more to being a father (or grandfather) than sending child support money.
If I had three wishes, I would want him to (1) put some insight on why he skipped out on me; (2) apologize for his absence; and (3) start picking up the pieces by being there as a grandfather, since he couldn’t be there for me as a father.
It’s very hard to imagine asking him for those things or telling him about my hurt. Calling him up specifically to tell him how I feel wouldn’t work because I would just be at a loss for words. I would get all choked up and he would not fully understand how I feel. You need both the happy and angry emotions to come out to fully understand how I became angry at my father in the first place and why I do still love him after all.
To You, Dad
It’s easier to imagine him reading this story. He would have no choice but to put up with my true feelings because it is written and can’t be erased. If he loves me he would read it and respond. And our relationship could go on from there. I would hope for his insight and apology and for him to make more effort. But whether the outcome is good or bad, the main point is that he knows my true feelings.
I can’t control the outcome, but I have (mostly) healed by different kinds of treatments. Now I am dealing with these new emotions about him not only with a therapist, but with friends and with Michael.
Writing this story has also helped with the hurt and anger I feel toward my father. I am slowly coming to accept our differences and hope to form a connection somehow, someday. I think that if I keep hope alive, we could find a common ground.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.