A Family Rape: Approved by Law

Twelve years ago my mother, Ms. Ionie Reid, worked as a practical nurse. These days it’s a whole different story. She gave up her profession-but not voluntarily.
A crippling disease called phlebitis (a blood clot in the veins) took root in her foot while she was on the job pregnant with my sister.
Unable to continue her work in a field that was physically demanding, our bills were paid by union dues until she could apply for a Social Security income. But she never got this income.
My mother was told by the bureaucracy of SSI that although employed for almost a decade, she wasn’t “eligible” to receive the benefit of Social Security, and the best thing for her to do was apply for public assistance, better known as welfare.
I’ve told you all this because it led to all sorts of troubles for my family-specifically, three incidents with the Child Welfare Administration (CWA), formerly the city’s Bureau of Child Welfare.
Accused of Abuse
In August 1986, on a beautiful afternoon, my mother was frying mounds of whiting fish fillet. Life was a party.
But it was interrupted. Rudely interrupted when a CWA worker showed up with the police.
I asked the caseworker what was going on.
She churned out some interesting “facts” about our family history: accusing my mother of starving us, of beating me so bad that I had to go to Montefiore Hospital, and accusing me of attempting suicide. God, they didn’t even get my name and age right!
Starving us! My little sister had to be watched at the table every time to make sure she cleaned half her plate.
The caseworker said she couldn’t say where she obtained her “facts.”
The right to know your accuser we did not have. I guess another set of laws must cover “Welfare People.”
Witness protection? What about slander protection?
One late afternoon two months later, in October, 1986, several Child Welfare Administration workers, accompanied by peace officers, again knocked at our door. We were told that our mother was in the hospital. Concerned about my mother, I opened the door.
They said our mother had a nervous breakdown and had checked into Bellevue Hospital earlier in the day. And they were there to take us to the CWA building on the Grand Concourse because we couldn’t be left alone.
“Get dressed.” We did. One of my sisters did not want to go and took off through a window.
We all understood why she didn’t want to go with them-we didn’t want to either But all of us couldn’t jump out the window without opposition from our “guests.”
Placed In Foster Care
The CWA workers let us stay home under the care of a neighbor. But her care proved inadequate, so the CWA said, according to my mother, that they’d arrange for a homeworker. The homeworker never showed so our two younger sisters and younger brother were placed in the foster care network. We weren’t happy about them being put into some stranger’s care, but we were grateful they would at least be together.
As soon as we got the chance, my best friend, my two sisters and I visited mom in Bellevue.
Thrown Back Together
We were kept apart for some months. But things got even more confusing when my family, ripped apart, was then, like the rag dolls of some child, thrown back in a jumbled pile. And what was the CWA’s explanation? They told my mother they had made a mistake. When we were back together my littlest sister said that she had been beaten by her foster mother. Why? Apparently because she wet her bed-a strange bed, in a strange place, full of strangers. This episode did nothing for my health. My daily life, the taste of food, school, etc., suddenly didn’t exist. It was all played out, a big waste of time, like some movie I’ve watched 100 times. In this state of mind my only recreation came through entertaining thoughts of death, and wondering what new world awaited me. It was the only thing it seemed that I could bank on-the only “sure thing” in town.
A long absence from Brooklyn Tech HS didn’t help my academic life. I was in a worlda sh-t. And I brooded a long time before a dear family friend helped me take action to end my daze.
I came back for my senior, year in September, but then, decided to drop out after a few weeks.
Lucky for me my guidance counselor, Mr. Curulli, helped me to see that I could be transferred to another high school, an alternative high school, where I would be able to do more than sit on my butt all day.
Things were nowhere near perfect, but I was recovering. My family was back together (with the exception of my oldest sister) and I was needed.
A Third Visit
But in March 1989, on a Friday afternoon, I arrived home from my internship at New Youth Connections, feelin’ everything was right in the world, and found a note on my door. Addressed to my mother, it said that if she wanted her children back, she would have to go to court.
I unlocked the door and opened it. The house was quiet, empty, still as the dead. No one was home!
Why was this nightmare starting again?
Well, since the summer of ’88 we had not been on welfare. We were assigned a new caseworker and for some reason we were cut off from public assistance. Mom had to apply all over again.
So since that time we were left hangin’ with hungry bellies. Mom made it her business to not see us hungry. This meant walking back and forth, on her diseased foot, dragging a shopping cart full of food supplied by charitable services, such as the local Catholic church.
She did practically all this on her own. Depressed as I was, I hardly lifted a finger to help her at all.
Although my mother was successfully maintaining our family, CWA saw fit to take away her children, deeming her unable to care for us without their aid (even though we survived the welfare cutoff for months since the summer of 1988.)
I read the note a few times more, hoping it was a lie. But it wasn’t. For the next three weeks, I retreated to Limbo (TV-land to you people.)
The Child Welfare Administration was back again. Reopening wounds, wounds that never really closed.
Thrown back into the fostercare system, my little brother and sister were not given the luxury of each other’s company. My brother was deprived of an education for over two months.
My oldest sister left home before this. She said she didn’t like being toyed with, and was not going stay and wait for it to happen again (as it had). Instead, it seems she might start her own family. A family that won’t take shorts from anyone. She’s pregnant.
The CWA allowed my second and third oldest sisters to stay with my aunt. Besides them, I have no idea at this moment where, the two little ones are.
When my mother went to court to stop this madness her caseworker didn’t even show up for the first hearing.
Was It a Dream?
Three weeks ago I had a dream, a nightmare rather. It was real. Or it sounded real. Somebody needed help, my help.
It happened early one morning before sunrise. I was more asleep than awake. I heard faint sounds not far from my window. As the sounds grew louder, my ears strained to make sense of them.
It was a girl’s voice. She was crying for help. It wasn’t loud, but it was intense. I then heard another voice, a male voice.
I awakened, surprised and confused.
I don’t know if it happened for real or if I dreamed it. But I remembered the cry for help. Was it a dream or was it my conscience?
I was very much awake. I pressed my hands against my ears, but I quickly came to realize that guilt was torturing my mind.
I wanted to do something, but I froze. All I could do was listen.
I was a prisoner in my own mind, condemned to helplessly stand by dumb. Then, it hit me. I had been witness to a rape-a systematic, approved-by-law rape of my own family.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.