NYC Rating: ***
In the opening scene of “A Dry White Season,” two boys are playing ball. One boy is Black, the other is White, but this seems to make no difference to the boys who are playing like the best of friends.
Unfortunately their difference in skin color does make a difference in racially divided South Africa, where the movie is set.
The plot is centered around events that take place after the death of Gordon Ngubene, a Black South African gardener who died while in police custody. Gordon worked for Ben du Toit, a comfortably middle class White South African schoolteacher.
The du Toits live in an affluent section of Johannesburg which contrasts with the Ngubene family’s humble home in Soweto, a Black township a few miles away.
Gordon’s wife, Emily, seeks Ben’s help to investigate the circumstances of her husband’s death. And as Ben du Toit learns about the real treatment of Blacks in South Africa, the audience also gets an education.
Ben’s wife, Susan du Toit, did not share her husband’s growing sympathy for the plight of Black South Africans. In fact, she resented it. Defending the treatment of Blacksby the South African police, she commented: “The only language they [Blacks] understand is force.”
The Special Branch, a police task force set up to deter “terrorists and communists,” seems to believe in this philosophy as they use extreme force on the Kaffirs (a derogatory term for Black South Africans).
Graphic Portrayal
“A Dry White Season” graphically portrays the abuses that Black South Africans must go through at the hands of the police. In one violent scene, hundreds of Black schoolchildren holding a peaceful demonstration against the educational system are shot down as they run from the police.
Donald Sutherland, as Ben du Toit, gives a fine performance as he slowly comes to realize how brutally Black South Africans are treated.
In the beginning of the movie he brushes off the whipping of Gordon’s son, Jonathan: “Such a minor matter, let it go.”
But later, when Jonathan is reported dead after being sent to jail for participating in the demonstration, Ben du Toit realizes that what’s happening to Black South Africans isn’t minor after all.
The performance by Marlon Brando as Barrister McKenzie brought a bright spot to a dark movie. In the court scenes, he makes a serious matter seem humorous as he pokes holes in the police’s defense and makes them look foolish.
When Ben first approached McKenzie to ask him to take the case, he told the civil rights lawyer that he wanted “justice” for his gardener’s death. McKenzie’s dry reply was, “In South Africa justice and the law are hardly on speaking terms.” This is especially true for Black South Africans.
Zakes Mokae, as Stanley, also puts in a good performance as a close family friend of Gordon, who later bans together with Ben du Toit to bring Gordon’s killers to justice.
One surprisingly interesting and pivotal performance was by the young actor Rowan Elmes, who played Johan, Ben’s son. He was the only member of the du Toit family whose support for Ben never wavered.
The movie may lead some to believe that one reason that Blacks are kept oppressed in South Africa is due to White’s fear of them. As a member of Ben’s family explained, “Blacks lead a double life…they’ll smile at you one moment and knife you the next.”
“A Dry White Season” is very well made. It portrays the plight of the Black people in South Africa so well that the movie is disturbing. The violence was so graphic that some scenes were hard to watch.
It made me wonder if there’s ever going to be justice for Black South Africans.
A Dry White Season’: A Graphic Portrayal of Apartheid
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.