A Better Way to Discipline: Stop With the Fines!

Kids do need discipline-but some methods just don’t work!
For example, in my agency, the first thing they do the minute you do something wrong is write you up and fine you. Lucky for me I have another source of income, but for the people who don’t, their weekends have just been shot! The allowance they give isn’t going to do much for you with today’s prices, and getting fined makes it even harder to buy things!
The way they hand out fines in my agency is weird! Knowing that we barely get enough allowance to go to the movies (including carfare and refreshments), the fines go as follows: getting an incident report or going AWOL will cost you $5, cutting school $2, refusing to do chores or clean your room is $1, failure to sign in/out $1.50, and, lastly, coming in after curfew will run you $2 for the first hour after the appointed time and $.50 for every half hour thereafter.
Fines Don’t Help
In my agency, residents receive a weekly $20 allowance. Residents are given $12, while $8 of it goes into a savings account, and this account can only be used after leaving the agency. The messed up thing about the agency’s rules is that a resident can lose his entire $12 in the course of a day without any way of earning it back.
Instead of the counselors talking with the residents, they just write them up, fine them, and go about their business. They constantly do this and it does nothing to better the situation.
In many of the instances when residents have been fined, they went right back and did the same thing again to get back at the counselors. For example, if a resident is playing his music loud and gets in trouble, he’ll end up playing the music even louder just to spite the counselor.
Feel free to correct me if I’m wrong, but we all know that if a counselor or any type of guardian does something to us that we dislike, we’re gonna do something to get back at them! I apologize to all those readers out there who are reading this and saying, “Ungh-ungh, I’m not like that,” but I’m sure there’s a reasonable number of you out there who agree with me.
Breaking Curfew
I myself have done things to get back at a counselor for the way he/she handled a certain situation and all that got me was another fine. My guess is that it was a lack of communication on both our parts.
One disciplinary alternative that I’ve mentioned to staff is to take away certain privileges from residents instead of fining them. Like taking away a resident’s TV, stereo, or video games. There’s no doubt that the resident will be mad, but I’m quite sure he wouldn’t mind a couple of boring nights compared with being broke for the weekend (although, in some cases, I could be wrong).
Personally, I’d rather be bored a night or two than have a “dead” weekend with no money. Besides, it’s not like you can actually hang out during a school night anyway. Instead of fining residents, counselors could also assign extra chores around the apartment.
An incident that happened to me where I think better methods of discipline could have been used involved curfew. There was a young woman I was talking to, whom I only got to see on very select occasions because we both had to go to work and school, and those occasions most often happened to be late at night. I broke curfew at least three nights a week to see her.
I tried talking to staff about why I kept breaking curfew to see her, but they stuck to their position, saying that my seeing her would interfere with my school and agency responsibilities, like meetings and chores. Let’s just say that I wasn’t getting carfare from the agency anytime soon to go and see her!
Anyway, over the course of our friendship, the counselors kept fining me and putting me on restriction, but that didn’t hinder me. I continued to see her regardless of their efforts, but after a while we just decided it was best to not see each other anymore, because, after all, neither of us really had the time.
Assign an Extra Chore
So that’s how that problem got solved. It had nothing to do with the counselors fining me or anything, believe me. Because if we hadn’t stopped seeing each other, I would have continued to break curfew, and anything the counselors said or did would have been irrelevant.
Since I usually get all my responsibilities taken care of, I think that the counselors could have cut me just a little bit of slack. The apartment supervisor did show some lenience by letting me off the hook for not checking in a few times. Even though she did this, she could have taken my situation into deeper consideration by at least letting me have a couple of late nights out during the week. It wasn’t like I was breaking curfew on a daily basis. Instead of fining me, staff could have assigned me an extra chore to make up for it.
Bedtime Is 11 p.m.
I’m in what is known as ILP (Independent Living Program) and I’m in One South, the supposedly “privileged” apartment. To get into this apartment you have to have been in the ILP program for no less than six months. Only residents the counselors deem worthy are allowed in, meaning you have to be attending school on a regular basis and all that other stuff that falls under the “good kid” category. And me, well…I guess they considered me One South material.
All the ILP apartments have basically the same privileges. We all have the same curfew, we all have to get counselors’ permission to use the phone (it wasn’t like that before), and we all have to sign in and out of the apartment.
However, as residents in One South, the so-called “privileged apartment,” we have a key both to our bedrooms and to get into the apartment, better phone accommodations, and the food isn’t locked away from us. Overall, we’re supposed to be the apartment that all the others look up to. What I don’t understand is that they still treat us as if we’re one of the “non-privileged” apartments.
One night near bedtime, which is 11 p.m., my counselor made us turn the TV off and get ready for bed. At the time we were in the middle of a movie I really wanted to see, so I yelled out “Privileged my a$$” and walked away. (I realize that I was in the wrong, but come on, if we’re supposed to be in the privileged apartment, how come we don’t get treated like it?)
The counselor got all bent out of shape saying that I yelled at him. I refused to go to bed, and “BAM,” just like that, three incident reports that cost me $5 apiece!
Even though this incident happened about five or six months ago, I still feel the counselor involved could have handled the situation differently. Yes, I do admit the counselor tried to talk to me calmly, stating that it was bedtime. But I was angry over the fact that if we were so privileged, why did we have the same 11 p.m. bedtime as everyone else?
One thing that really got me was that he could’ve thought more about where my argument was coming from. He could have shown a little leniency, seeing that it was a movie we all wanted to see. Instead, it seems that the only difference between my apartment and the others is that we have keys to the apartment!
Resident Feedback
I sometimes try to give staff better disciplinary methods regarding fines, late check-ins, and other disciplinary measures (mainly when I’m being disciplined, of course), which won’t end up with the resident retaliating with anger or something else bad, but they just won’t listen. They say things like, “We’ll think about it” or “We’ll take it into consideration,” but most of the time they never follow through.
I think staff should have a meeting with a group of resident representatives to let them have a say in any new rules and procedures that are made up. I must admit that staff did establish some sort of group with a few residents a while ago, but the residents who were involved are no longer in the agency and no one has cared to pick up where they left off.
If anyone reads this article and decides that he would like to be a member of a new group to meet with the staff, I’ll be right there to back you up.

SIDEBAR: Residents and Staff Speak Out: Discipline in the Group Home
I recently interviewed some of the residents and staff at St. John’s Home for Boys in Queens to see how they feel about the agency’s discipline policies. Residents thought there should be new methods tried, while staff felt that the current methods are adequate. When asked if residents deserve very strict discipline, Arthur Fisher, 17, said, “Most residents deserve harsh treatment because of their behaviors,” but he also feels that the staff sometimes goes overboard and treats residents as if they are criminals. One of my counselors, Margaret Strassburg, disagreed with what Arthur said, stating, “The rules are fair for the most part because they have to address the needs of the group as opposed to the individual population.” She added, “At this time, I don’t see any immediate changes in the rules due to the troubled times of our world today.”
Levels of Discipline
I then asked Arthur how he thought arguments and fights should be handled, and he said that there should be different levels of discipline, according to the severity of the fight: “Fights should be handled accordingly, depending on the degree of it.” Dirjon Waldron, 19, who has been at St. John’s Home for Boys almost two years, added, “Instead of the residents being fined and written up, they should be talked to, to help settle their differences.” Dirjon and Arthur both were opposed to fines. Dirjon said, “There shouldn’t be any fines because they [residents] don’t learn anything from it. Who cares about a dollar?” Arthur came back with, “They shouldn’t have fines. They should only have them if we were receiving a bigger allowance.”
No to Restriction
But one thing that Arthur and Dirjon totally agreed on was that they’d rather be fined than be put on restriction. Dirjon said, “Fines are better than restriction because I’d rather have company and use the phone. Fines are more short term than restriction.” Arthur added, “I’d rather be fined than put on restriction because there are ways to work around it [not having any money].” Arthur agreed with me on the subject of curfew, where I feel staff should show leniency if people are fulfilling their responsibilities: “Yes, depending on their age, curfew should be much later for older residents.” Arthur also agreed with me on alternative disciplinary measures by saying: “Take away their [residents’] source of entertainment for that day or two, take away keys, something like that.”
Extra Chores
Dirjon’s suggestion for an alternative disciplinary measure was to give the residents “extra chores to do or work dorms.” Dirjon also said “residents should get reimbursed” when something is stolen from a resident. I asked Dirjon whether or not all residents should be punished for the actions of one, which is what commonly happens in many group homes. “No, they shouldn’t hold everyone accountable for the actions of one person,” said Dirjon. “He did the deed by himself, then he should suffer the consequences by himself.” Ms. Strassburg and Timothy Caldwell, another counselor, disagreed, saying that the group should be punished for the actions of one because peer pressure does work in some situations.
Need for Strict Rules
Although Dirjon wanted changes in the rules, he wasn’t saying there should be leniency at St. John’s. “There is a rowdy crowd at St. John’s,” he said, “and they deserve strict rules.” Mr. Caldwell’s reply was similar: “Yes, some of the rules, I think they should make them more strict.” I asked Arthur if residents should have a say in any decisions or changes in the rules regarding them, and he said, “Yes, residents should be involved in everything concerning them….Freedom of speech and expression comes to mind.” Mr. Caldwell also felt that residents should have a say, “especially if the resident has shown in the past to make good decisions and can deal with the outcome, good or bad.” After doing these interviews, I still stick to my opinion that some disciplinary measures just don’t work, especially when others have to pay for one individual’s actions. I’m hoping this article will open some eyes pertaining to the disciplinary policies at St. John’s, and shed some light on the word “CHANGE.”

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.