The issue of abortion is a highly controversial one throughout the country. In recent years, the debate over a woman’s legal right to an abortion has fired up many emotions. This debate should concern teenagers-every year more than a million teenage girls in the United States get pregnant and almost half of them (42%) choose to have an abortion.
In 1973, the Supreme Court legalized abortion, ruling that the decision to have an abortion during the first trimester of pregnancy (first three months) must be left completely to a woman and her physician. In this landmark ruling of Roe v. Wade, the Supreme Court protected a woman’s basic constitutional right to privacy.
Last year, in Webster v. Reproductive Health Services, the Supreme Court upheld sharp restrictions on abortion in the state of Missouri. This decision is making it very difficult to obtain an abortion in Missouri. The Webster decision also set a precedent for other states to limit a woman’s access to abortion by passing their own laws.
Keep Abortion Safe and Legal
“It’s not the government’s position to determine when to have or not have a child,” said Rebecca Saybolt, field organizer for the New York State affiliate of NARAL (National Abortion RightsAction League). “NARAL’s mission is to keep abortion safe, legal, and accessible.”
One of 44 affiliates nationwide, New York State NARAL advocates the pro-choice position to “make abortion less necessary, not less accessible.” NARAL stresses the right of women to choose and have available reproductive options.
Barbara Meara, secretary of the New York State Right To Life Committee and vice-president of the Metropolitan Right To Life Foundation, a pro-life organization, sees it differently. “It is not the place of government to decide [that abortion is all right.] Our right to life is inalienable. It is contained within each one of us, not something that is given to us. It must be respected.” Meara is also chairman of the Bronx Right To Life Committee.
“We also believe,” Meara continued, “that the government should stop using tax dollars for abortion.”
“Teens are going to have sex just like adults are going to have sex,” Saybolt said. It is NARAL’s mission to insure “adequate services to provide teens and low-income women the opportunity to either have the child…or abort it. It is the right of women to make this decision on their own.”
The Fetus Has Rights Too
But Meara felt that the rights of the unborn child (the fetus) should be protected. “It wasn’t known years ago,” Meara asserted, “but now we know that we are living human beings from the beginning. We now know the facts of fetal development. From the very moment of conception there is a unique human being. When the chromosomes of the mother and the father unite, what now exists will never exist again.”
“The idea that life begins at conception is a religious view,” claimed Merry Weitzman, administrative assistant at NARAL.
“The fetus is not alive or functioning out of the womb,” Weitzman continued. “It’s not a citizen. It is completely dependent on the woman and physically attached…”
But Meara disagreed: “I believe in the right to [to life of] each individual human being. The child already came into existence, if not, there would be no need to even [contemplate] abortion. It’s taking a life.”
Abortion For Convenience or Birth Control
Members of the pro-life movement would like to see Roe v. Wade overturned. Many feel that the easy availability of abortion makes some women abuse it for convenience, or as a method of birth control.
“So many abortions are because the pregnancy came at a bad time for the woman. I believe that making abortion illegal will make young women think about responsible sexuality,” claimed Meara.
“It’s not going to teach birth control and it won’t change the outcome,” Weitzman said. “[Women] will just resort to back alley [illegal] abortions. Illegalizing abortion won’t teach them; it will just punish them.”
In cases of rape and incest, the pro-choice view is that having a baby conceived under these circumstances would be extremely traumatizing and a constant reminder of the horrible nightmare. Therefore, women should have the option of having an abortion.
Cases of Rape and Incest
On the other hand, Meara believed that while rape is a difficult thing, it may not justify killing an innocent human being. “They don’t kill the rapist. He just gets a few years in jail, but they’re willing to kill the innocent baby.”
Another significant issue surrounding the abortion debate is that of parental consent. In June 1990, the Supreme Court upheld a Minnesota law requiring teenagers to notify both parents before an abortion. The Court also upheld Ohio’s requirement that one parent be notified before a minor has an abortion and, in addition, provided for judicial bypass (seeking permission from a judge rather than a parent).
Saybolt agreed that the Ohio and Minnesota parental consent bills “are dangerous because they set precedents for other states.”
According to a NARAL publication, “Parental consent and notice laws endanger the health and lives of young women. These laws have increased the number of illegal abortions and more dangerous second trimester abortions.” Faced with the option of telling unsupportive parents or a judge, many pregnant teens dangerously delay their decision to get a legal abortion and some end up getting an illegal abortion, or having the baby by default.
Parental Consent Laws
In a recent case, an Indiana teenager died from an illegal abortion because she was ashamed to tell her parents or a judge that she was pregnant. Indiana is one of 32 states that have parental consent laws.
Said Saybolt: “NARAL supports communication between families.[Teens] need someone to help them make intelligent decisions, not threaten their lives. They shouldn’t mandate parental consent.”
Meara expressed the right to life view: “It’s important for teens to have parental input in a serious decision especially for medical reasons. You can’t get your ears pierced or dental work done without parental consent. Yet abortion-I’m in support of the parental consent bill.”
Rosita Arrastia, coordinator of volunteers for Planned Parenthood, said that there’s no parental consent necessary for teens in New York State. She said teenagers in New York don’t have to worry about this changing.
Both Sides See Obstacles
Both pro-choice and pro-life supporters perceive different obstacles in their fight to promote their cause. Meara stated, “I would say the major obstacle is apathy of the people…a great deal of the public is split and undecided. She said another obstacle was that the opposition has a lot of money. “They get more federal funding than we do. We don’t have access to those funds.”
Saybolt, on the other hand said “the Catholic Church is an obstacle.” The Church is completely against abortion for any reason and even denounces the use of birth control.
But not all religious groups are opposed to abortion. The Religious Coalition For Abortion Rights is an organization with representatives from 34 different religious groups who support a woman’s right to choose an abortion.
“We don’t view abortion as murder. Especially in cases of rape and incest, it is inhumane to expect a woman to have that baby. We feel very strongly about the feelings of women. That’s where we differ from the Cardinal [O’Connor],” said Patricia Stevens, executive director.
Another obstacle Saybolt acknowledged is harassment. “There is so much anti-woman harassment outside of clinics.”
Teens Take Action
With the recent restrictions that the Supreme Court has placed on a young woman’s right to an abortion, Saybolt said, “It’s important for teens to be active in this movement because they are the ones that will be affected by this legislation.”
Right-to-life supporters believe that abortion doesn’t solve one’s problems and that there are always alternatives. Pro-choice supporters feel that women are capable of choosing their own reproductive destiny and if abortion is a woman’s choice, this option should be available to her.
The facts have been presented as fairly as possible. If you have strong views on either side of the issue, take a stand, because this controversy will continue for several years.
SIDEBAR: Not Just Birth Control and Abortion- Profile of Planned Parenthood
When most people think of Planned Parenthood, they think of abortion services for women. However, there is a much broader picture that is often overlooked. Planned Parenthood of New York City (PPNYC) offers a range of services and programs that benefit both teenage girls and boys, as well as adults. They offer educational, vocational, and recreational programs. They offer abortions, but they also have pre-natal programs and programs to help mothers after they have given birth. And they have many services for teens. The Planned Parenthood Center in Brooklyn has a Parent Education Program. The Brooklyn Branch also offers birth control, counseling, pregnancy testing, treatment for sexually transmitted diseases, AIDS education, and gynecology services as well as a clinic for abortion services. The Manhattan Branch is where the main office is located, and it also has a clinic. The Queens Branch of Planned Parenthood has a Parent Education Program. The Bronx Branch, called the HUB, has the most services for teens. “There is a close teen/staff relationship,” said Judy Epstein, associate director of Media Relations and Marketing at Planned Parenthood. At Planned Parenthood, “[Teens] get to see alternatives for themselves,” said Epstein. Planned Parenthood keeps strict confidentiality. “If teens haven’t shared their situation with a parent themselves, we won’t. Parents have come to us and said, ‘what was my daughter doing in here?’ but we don’t give out that information.” At the HUB, which is the Bronx Center of Planned Parenthood, there are several programs, including a graffiti project to reach out to boys. “The HUB is a place for [teen] recreation and growth,” said Jeannine Michael, MSW, clinic director at the HUB. “In the graffiti program, the kids do work inside instead of outside to channel their talents. “Young, macho men find a [role] model in Gilbert Serrano, the man who runs the graffiti program. He provides an antidote to the need to be tough and macho by saying ‘I can be that way too but there are other ways to express yourself and still be a man.”‘ Michael continued, “We also offer African dance, cooking, karate…positive recreation programs.” “The HUB is set up in such a way,” said Michael, “that all patients that come in, before they see a medical provider, are first seen by a counselor. A lot of individual counseling goes on here.” The HUB provides services for women who choose to have their babies. The pre-natal program serves young, pregnant women who wish to continue their pregnancy. The well-baby care program is designed to follow these women after the birth of their child and make sure they receive the services they need. “The HUB’s recreational, vocational, and educational programs are free. In Brooklyn and the Bronx there is a sliding fee scale,” Epstein explained. [That means the less money you or your family earns, the less money you have to pay.] “However, if a teen comes in and has neither [insurance or Medicaid] they can show evidence of being in school. Services are free for teens under these circumstances,” said Michael, of the HUB. Abortions are available on a sliding scale. Teens can get Medicaid, which in New York State, helps fund abortions. The HUB’s education programs include birth control counseling, SET (Sex Education for Teens), peer tutoring, and PEP (Parent Education Program). They also have a GED program. Teens can receive pre-job training and explore career options. In addition to education, the HUB provides basic family planning services, such as birth control, gynecological services, annual exams, and STD testing and treatment, according to Michael. The clinic provides abortion, but that decision is up to the teen. “Too many teens are forced to have abortions [because of their parents] and didn’t want one. Too many teens are forced to have the baby and didn’t want it. Teens should choose, like any other woman, their reproductive health..,” said Michael. “We must stop blaming teens when they do get pregnant. We have to deal with where the adolescent is at that point and take it from there. In society, teens are surrounded by sex in movies, music, and television. Not enough role models are [advocating] sexual responsibility,” said Michael. Other major programs Michael mentioned were the Outreach Program and the HIV program. “Our Outreach Program reaches the community and goes into the schools in a three member team.” This team provides community education, workshops and training. “The HIV program,” Michael explained, “sees people who wish to test for AIDS. Anybody can come in for this. [There’s] a counselor, social worker, providing education, risk assessment, pre and post test counseling. It’s a growing program.” Another project of Planned Parenthood is Street Beat, a medical van whose “focus is on homeless kids, prostitutes, and all of those at highest risk,” Epstein said. It provides primary services, information, condoms, clothing and food for needy teens in the South Bronx area. Planned Parenthood is dedicated to help people make the right choices for themselves “and then we support you in your decision,” Epstein added. “It’s important to show [teens] that they should still have children but at a time when they can better cope with parenthood. We must provide them with options so that they can grow into adulthood first,” Michael said. When asked what message Planned Parenthood would give to teens, Epstein said, “Being sexual takes responsibility. By no means rush it. We believe in abstinence [for teens.] For those who decide to be sexually active, take precautions, against STDs and AIDS as well as unwanted pregnancy. You should talk to either a counselor or your family. There’s no reason to rush it.”
A Brief History of Planned Parenthood
Planned Parenthood was founded on the principle that a woman should have the right to choose her own reproductive health. But these rights were not easily won. It wasn’t until 1965 that the Supreme Court ruled that Americans had the right to use contraceptives. And the Court didn’t recognize the right of women to choose an abortion until 1973, in the Roe v. Wade decision. Rosita Arrastia, coordinator of volunteers of Planned Parenthood of New York, said that Margaret Sanger, a public health nurse and a pioneer in the fight for birth control, provided the inspiration for starting Planned Parenthood. According to Arrastia, Sanger refused to “stand by and watch women die because the government said birth control was illegal.” So she defied the government, helping poor families gain knowledge about birth control. Sanger was arrested several times. First Birth Control Clinic In 1916, Sanger opened the first birth control clinic in the United States in Brooklyn’s Brownsville section. In 1918, the New York State Court of Appeals ruled that physicians could give contraceptive advice only to protect a woman’s health and to prevent disease. Sanger formed the American Birth Control League in 1921. Two years later, the first legal birth control clinic opened to eventually become the Margaret Sanger Research Bureau. Planned Parenthood Federation of America grew out of Sanger’s efforts. Today, Planned Parenthood of New York City (PPNYC), is the largest of the 175 affiliates across the country. Funding for this non-profit organization comes from foundations, corporations, government aid, voluntary contributions, and fees at the clinics. PPNYC has given thousands of individuals and families the chance to take control of their lives.
