My Gender Identity: It’s Complicated

Since I was 5 years old I wanted to be a boy. I felt that God had screwed up my genes while I was in my mother’s womb because I hated wearing dresses. It pissed me off when my mother would try to doll me up. I wanted to stay home in my boxers and play video games, and when I went to school, I would wear my brother’s clothes.
When I played house with other kids, I always wanted to be daddy-bring home the bacon, be independent. Playing the father role made me feel like I had power and control. My father went to work at night, and my mother took care of me and my siblings. They lived together but I felt like because my father was a man he had power; he had the last word in the house.
I have an aunt who’s bisexual. When I was 10 years old she brought the woman she was dating to my mother’s house. My aunt’s girlfriend dressed like a man. That’s when I started saying to myself, “Hmmm, maybe this could be normal.” Soon after that, I pulled my aunt aside and said, “Titi, I like girls.”
She responded, “There is nothing wrong with that if it makes you happy. You are what you are. I love you either way.”
When I was 11, I started telling people who asked if I had a boyfriend that I was a lesbian. Some of my family accepts me, and some don’t. My mother doesn’t, and she still puts her negative two cents in about my lifestyle. Some others feel that 18 is too young to know if I want to spend my life with a man or with a woman. I don’t think it’s their
business.
I came out to my father recently, which was scary because my father and I are close and I was afraid it would change our relationship. But I was wrong. My father said that he would love me regardless because I was his first born and the only one of his children that he was close to.
How Does It Happen?
I’ve heard different theories as to why people are LGBTQ. One is that girls who were abused by men become lesbians. I believe that I was born the way I am, but maybe part of it has to do with being molested by a man when I was little. But mostly I feel like I’ve become exactly what I am supposed to be: a lesbian. I feel comfortable with guys but only as friends. If I am attracted to a man, it’s just physical. I like a masculine man with a tight body and abs.
But if I’m attracted to a girl, I’m attracted to more things about her-the way she walks, talks, moves, even the way she complains. When a female complains, she is telling you how she feels. The men I know won’t tell a female how they are feeling.
I have had sex with men, but the sex with women is different. It pleases me more. I also trust women more than I trust men, and with females I have more patience because they’re more sensitive. Men are more like my flavor of the week; while my relationships with females are more long-term.
As I’ve gotten older, I’m figuring out how to fold my feeling of being male into my adult identity. I got introduced to the term PGP (preferred gender pronoun) when I recently stayed in an LGBTQ youth shelter. For example, men who are transgendered feminine, meaning they think of themselves as female and dress in women’s clothes, most likely want you to call them “she,” not “he.” My PGP is “he.” Even though most straight people don’t, I prefer people to address me as a male.
Even though I consider myself a man and in the LGBTQ community I am addressed as a man, at professional places like the Represent office or anywhere else, I go by what it says on my birth certificate.
People look at me weird when I am dressed like a female but say I’m a man. I have gotten into arguments with straight people. Most straight people want people to stay in the gender they were born into.
Not One Thing
I consider myself a femagress: a tomboy who is feminine. For example, I dress like a boy from time to time but I love getting my nails done, I love being spoiled by my girl and I love shoe shopping. I also love taking money from my girl to buy my stilettos. When I’m feeling feminine, I feel a little ADHD; I run around figuring out what to wear and I worry about all the details-nails, hair, clothes, bag.
But even in those clothes, I can start to relax and slump when I sit; that’s the more masculine me coming out. I say less and speak softer. Another thing that moves me from feminine to masculine is anger. If you piss me off, I will fight you, and that feels masculine. If I’m dating a femme (a feminine lesbian), I would never hit her, but I would fight another masculine girl.
I am engaged to Izzy, who is a stud (a masculine lesbian). Izzy is very consistently masculine: I admire that and it also helps shape our life. Because she is more masculine than I am, my clothing has to be feminine. Izzy refuses to go outside with me if I am dressed like her, so when we’re together I wear girly clothes. She doesn’t approve of me wearing sweats unless they look girly. Izzy and I agree with the other LGBTQ youths we know that two studs shouldn’t be together.
It was different when I dated a femme. I could look like her-wearing skirts, heels, dresses, nails done-or like a stud. I change my style depending on who I am dating because it’s all in my comfort zone. My dress codes do not make me feel less of a man.
I do still feel like a “he,” even when I wear a dress (which I don’t do that often anymore). I don’t want to get surgery to become a man because I am pretty comfortable in my own skin and I get a lot out of being a femagress. I can change who I date and I am fine with that. Being a he makes me feel more powerful and boosts my ego.
I like being showed off as well as showing other girls off because it boosts up my ego. If a guy hits on me when I’m on a date with Izzy, I feel good about myself. If a guy tries to hit on a femme girl I’m dating, I feel good, too, because I’m the one she’s with. I know it makes Izzy feel good when I am all dolled up and we go on our dates and I get attention. That makes me feel sexy too.
Her Wife
At the end of the day, love is more important to me than a pronoun. I fall for personality more than looks, and so I can love feminine women and masculine women.
I’m glad that I can move between worlds because it feels comforting. I like having the ability to choose what I want to dress like depending on who I date. It’s comforting, plus it lets me be with Izzy. It’s OK that Izzy refers to me as “she”-I accept it because I am her wife and not a stud. The people who are in our world do refer to Izzy as a “he” because she gets mad when people call her a she. Sometimes I call her “she” to tease her. She doesn’t get mad because she knows that I know she runs the relationship.
I believe that many men nowadays disrespect and debase women, but Izzy doesn’t, and so I like being her obedient wife. I don’t think there’s anything wrong with being obedient and submissive as long as the other person treats you well. Izzy respects me; she doesn’t use the word “b-tch” unless it’s called for; she’s honest and loyal and patient with me. I check with her before I do things. For example, if I’m over at Izzy’s, and one of her neighbors needs a cigarette and asks me for one, I look at Izzy to see if she approves. If she doesn’t, I won’t give the guy the cigarette. I believe that’s how a female should act with her man. It’s part of my job as Izzy’s wife to make her feel like a real man. So I try not to put his pride down as much.
When I do get a full-time job, I will be out at work. I’m openly gay now and have no problem telling people that. I love going back and forth between my masculine and feminine identities.

Transgender 101
By Kelli Dunham
The terms that people use to discuss gender identity and sexual orientation can be confusing. People within the LGBTQ community don’t always agree on terminology, and the mainstream media sometimes gets facts about LGBTQ people wrong. Here’s a simple guide:
Sexual orientation is about what gender you are attracted to: physically or emotionally or both. One common word used for a woman who is attracted to other women is lesbian, for a man who is attracted to other men, it’s gay, and people attracted to both genders are usually called bisexual. But many people in the LGBTQ community believe that sexual orientation labels are limiting because they reinforce the idea that there are only two genders (the “gender binary”) and that people can’t be a mixture or something else entirely.
Gender Identity is how a person feels deep inside about what gender they are. This might not be the same as what their body or their birth certificate says (“assigned gender”). People who feel that their gender matches their body parts and their birth certificate are called cis-gender , and folks who have the feeling that their assigned gender and the gender they feel deep inside are different usually (but not always) refer to themselves as transgender .
Transgender: Trans women are male to female (MTF); trans men are female to male (FTM). In other words, you should call people the gender they feel like. (Some folks who are transgender don’t feel like they are either gender, and might have other words to describe themselves.) Gender identity is separate from sexual orientation. Some trans men and trans women are gay, some are straight, and some are bisexual.
Surgery and Hormones: There is no one surgery for transgender people to complete their transition. Some transgender people take estrogen or testosterone or have different types of surgery to change their body in a way to more closely resemble their gender identity, but not everyone makes that choice. Hormones and surgery are expensive and mostly not covered by any insurance. What makes a person transgender is that they say they are . Transgender is self-identity and not necessarily about hormones or surgery.
Kelli Dunham is a nurse and author who frequently speaks to high school and college students about LGBTQ issues and health.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.