Book Review: This Is How You Lose Her

Weak female characters? This is how you lose my interest

On September 6, I had the opportunity to attend a reading by Junot Diaz, my favorite author. He was reading from his latest book, a collection of short stories called This is How You Lose Her . The stories are all about the trials of Yunior, a player at heart, as he searches for love. For almost five months I had been awaiting the publication of this book after falling in love with Diaz’s The Brief Wondrous Life of Oscar Wao , which won a Pulitzer Prize. When my 8th grade English teacher gave it to me, I was surprised to find out that Diaz was Dominican. I had never read a novel by a Dominican author. Soon after, I went back to read his first book, a short story collection called Drown .
Reading Diaz’s books makes me proud to be Dominican because he shines a light on my culture. It also motivates me to pursue my dream of becoming a professional writer. I remember telling my dad, “Look Pa, here’s a Dominican writer writing about us. If he can do it, so can I.”
Both Oscar Wao and Drown are mostly about males. But I still identified strongly with the books. I like how honest and raw Diaz is. He doesn’t seem to censor himself and often uses profanity which I imagine is just how he talks. His footnotes also help me understand the story better. Diaz brings life to the slang, the injustices, poverty, and determination I feel are all a part of the Dominican’s background. Diaz’s writing flows, making it easy to read, and his employment of Spanish in his books spices them up.
Fun for the Whole Family
Diaz uses a lot of slang I don’t know so I ask my parents. For instance, sin verguenza means a person who doesn’t have shame. It’s especially fun because my mom and dad are immigrants and usually I’m teaching them English words or answering their questions about American culture-so to have them teach me about Dominican culture makes them feel good.
My mother particularly loves answering my questions. She is so surprised that a fellow Dominican is writing down the slang she speaks in her everyday life.
I was so intrigued by Diaz’s talent of perfectly portraying Dominican culture that the way he portrays Dominican women in This Is How You Lose Her didn’t occur to me until I spoke with my editors at YCteen about comments Diaz made at the reading. The women also receive worse treatment than the women in Oscar Wao and Drown .
It’s something others have picked up on and criticized Diaz for. At the reading, Diaz was asked how he goes about writing women characters. He said, “I grew up in a society that doesn’t encourage you to imagine women as fully human. They’re like sex, they’re like company, they’re like for you to have kids but fully human? I wasn’t encouraged (to view women that way).”
His Portayal of Dominican Women Embarrasses Me
This caught me by surprise because I admire Diaz and to think that he might not see me as a full human being is disheartening. Not only that, he hit so close to home. I see the subservient roles Dominican women play in my house, in my friend’s house, in my cousin’s house all the time-but to have a Dominican man admit it and acknowledge it shocked and embarrassed me. He was speaking about the one thing we’re taught to ignore and not talk about: that Dominican women aren’t viewed as equal to men.
In This is How You Lose Her , Yunior’s mother is the only woman character we get to know. Perhaps because Diaz doesn’t view her as a sex object, he is better able to develop her as a person with real emotions and worries. Unlike all the other girls, the mother has a personality with ideas, dreams, and opinions of her own. Diaz writes “She wrote letter after letter home, begging her sisters to come as soon as possible. This neighborhood is empty and friendless. And she begged my father to bring his friends over. She wanted to talk about unimportant matters, to speak to someone who wasn’t her child or her spouse.”
A Cultural’Deficiency’
My mother is a lot like the one in the book. She’s close with me, and she’s involved. She’s not some soft-spoken girl like so many Dominican women are portrayed. Like Diaz’s mother, mine also speaks her mind when she has something to say.
But I couldn’t find any other female characters to relate to. For instance, here’s what we know about Nilda, a recurring character. She’s loud during sex, she has greasy hair, big breasts, “a moon face,” and “big stupid lips.” She barely speaks to anyone and she ran away from home a bunch of times because her mother is the neighborhood drunk. She’s also described as being “one of those quiet, semi-retarded girls.”
I don’t know what that means and Diaz doesn’t explain it. Nilda’s story is all about what happens to her and how men treat her and nothing about who she is internally. In this book, Diaz doesn’t give his female characters any dimension so it’s hard to care about them.
At the reading, Diaz said, “My culture produced hyper-masculine men so it’s implanted in me, as deeply as anyone else.” (Hyper-masculinity is a psychological term for the overemphasis of male stereotypical behavior like displaying physical strength and assertiveness.) That may be his justification for his disregard toward the women characters in his latest book. He goes on to say, “This culture guaranteed me a deficiency.” But to be fair, in other interviews Diaz refers to himself as a “feminist ally,” and says he doesn’t approve of the way Dominican men treat women. In fact, he sees it as a problem.
Diaz blames his culture for deeming women as less than fully human. To me, that excuse just doesn’t cut it. I feel like we all face different obstacles but what you grow up to be is up to you. Of course, we’re influenced by our culture and those around us but how you choose to behave and what you believe, and the world you create if you’re a writer is for you to determine.
Yunior is also dismissive of women’s feelings, as if they don’t matter as much as his. After “cheating on her with this chick who had tons of eighties freestyle hair,” Yunior doesn’t think his girlfriend Magda deserves decent answers when she asks if he ever planned to
tell her and why he did it. “My favorite answers were’Yes’ and’It was a stupid mistake.'”
That’s it?
While I still love Diaz’s books, I’m disappointed by his attitude toward women. Diaz is in his 40s now. He has a ton of talent, but I think by now he should have grown out of this deficiency he blames on his upbringing and have developed a more multi-dimensional view of women. If I can overcome the deficiency this culture guaranteed us, then he can too.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.