Keeping It Real Online
Discussion: 45 minutes
Ask the group to share what sort of social media they use (Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, etc.). Ask them to say what they like about communicating through these media. This should start a lively discussion, which may well include what they don’t like.
Then ask them, “Do you think you are genuine or your real self when you communicate online?” Go around and ask them all to answer and to elaborate on why or why not (possible answers: The “conversations” they have online are in public; they often only write very short messages while doing other things on the computer).
When they’re done, ask if what they just did, thoughtfully answering a question face-to-face with their peers, feels different from an online discussion. If so, how? Ask: What’s the difference between hanging out with a group of friends and “hanging out” (status updating, commenting) with your Facebook friends. How about one-on-one communication on Facebook versus over the phone or in person?
Read the Story: 45 minutes
Have them read “Catfish: Tricking People to Feel Alive” by Maria Alashola. Ask them if they agree with Maria’s point toward the end of her story that “we all catfish” when we post flattering pictures or put up status updates that suggest we feel better than we really do. Ask: Is that catfishing? Is there a real-life equivalent to this? (acting happier than we feel; exaggerating when we tell a story to make ourselves look better).
Ask if they can relate to Maria’s enjoyment of her creativity when creating “Ayden.” Ask if any of them have ever created a fake profile and if so, why. Do they assume that people often lie online? If so, how does that change their experience of social media?
To Unplug or Not to Unplug
Discussion: 30 minutes
Ask the group if their experience of social media has been good, bad, or mixed. If they say, “bad,” ask what were the problems or bad feelings that arose from Facebook, etc.?
Ask if any of them have ever taken themselves off social media. If so, what did they find? Were there any differences in their life and if so, what?
Read the Story: 30 minutes
Have them read “Quitting Social Media” by Jorge Cruz. Ask them to detail Jorge’s criticisms of being online (bullying and gossip; people acting the same as each other and not being individuals; shy people don’t get any practice speaking up in person; more time for sports and music; Facebook makes people image-obsessed; stifles creativity and deep thoughts).
If, as a group, they had not come up with Jorge’s criticisms, ask if they agree. Ask those who never have gone off social media what they imagine the effects on their lives might be.
Writing Activity: 30 minutes to read aloud
A possible follow-up activity is a “tech fast,” where the group has to unplug for a day and write about how they spent that day. See examples here: http://bit.ly/techfast . You can ask them to read what they wrote at the group’s next meeting.
Therapists and Social Workers: Lessons You Can Use With Teens
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.