Online Tracking

What terms and conditions allow websites to do

Do you remember making your Facebook account? If you do, you probably remember typing in your name, your birthday, maybe adding a profile picture. But do you remember the small print above the signup button that stated, “By clicking signup, you agree to our Terms and that you have read our Data Use Policy, including our Cookie Use”?
This statement is easy to breeze by. Most people probably don’t even see it, let alone click on the three separate links that are hyperlinked. If you click on the first link, “Terms,” you are brought to a long list of rules and guidelines in a font and size that’s easy to read. One of the first things on this list is the statement, “Your privacy is very important to us.”
At this point you can go back to the shiny login screen and finish making your account, right? Facebook’s got your back. They just told you they value your privacy. So you proceed to enter your full name, your email address, your telephone number, and then a multitude of “likes” and interests. You add friends, make posts on your timeline, send thousands of messages. But did you know all of this data is saved on a hard drive?
The Small Print
Have you ever considered anyone outside your group of friends reading your profile? If not, maybe you should go back to the terms and conditions that you skipped over, and click on the other two links. The problem, you’ll see, is that the other links bring you to even longer lists, in smaller font. You don’t want to read all this and companies know that! In fact, when I saw the documentary Terms and Conditions May Apply, I found out it would take approximately 180 hours to read all the online contracts the average person agrees to annually.
On most, if not all, social media websites, the small print reserves the right to track your behavior on and offline. Through the use of small files called “cookies” that you unknowingly download whenever you visit a website, Facebook and other sites gather information about you.
“They can pretty much see every website you go to, and build a profile of you based on the things you buy and the sites you spend the most time on,” says Jude Biersdorfer, a technology writer for The New York Times. “From this data they try to determine what you might be willing to buy so they can pitch you ads.”
Big Brother is Watching
You might be thinking: So what? I don’t have anything to hide. And I don’t mind getting ads for stuff I like.
“Let’s say your parents told you to stop spending so much time playing video games but you recently went to go buy one you absolutely had to have. All of a sudden you start getting mail for video games and your parents figure out that you’re playing more, not less. More and more stores are selling your information, whether they are online or off,” said Adi Kamdar, an activist at the Electronic Frontier Foundation, an Internet rights advocacy organization based in San Francisco. “Or for example, if you’re looking at websites or searching for things that may reveal that you’re gay, you may not want your parents to know this information, and yet advertisements aimed at gays might appear on a webpage other people might see.”
Facebook Knows Me
I can attest to this. I see ads for LGBT magazines and groups on my Facebook page quite frequently, and have never known why this happened. It turns out that Facebook’s information is more accurate than my own memory. I probably do read articles and websites concerning LGBT issues more than a straight person would.
I attempted to find out more from Instagram, Facebook, and Tumblr, but Facebook and Tumblr didn’t respond to my interview request and Instagram declined.
A Pew Research Center study published in May, 2013 surveyed 802 teens and found that 60% adjust privacy settings to keep their personal information from the eyes of strangers. For example, many teenagers make it so that their social media profiles are only visible to their acquaintances and friends. However, the same survey found only 9% are “very concerned” about their information falling into the hands of third parties. These third parties can be advertisers or other groups called data brokers who gather your information and then sell it to advertisers.
Dodging the Trackers
Maybe only 9% of teenagers are concerned because they don’t know what third parties are, or that they even exist. It’s interesting to me that as teenagers, we know to be wary of individual strangers online yet we trust social media websites to protect our privacy and keep our personal data safe from corporations and advertisers. We need to be wary of these websites too.
There are several steps you can take to, as Jude Biersdorfer put it, “make your footprints around the web as shallow as possible,” or dramatically reduce the amount of information these social media websites and advertisers have on you.
None of the following can completely foil the efforts of data collection. Many browsers like Firefox, Google Chrome, and Internet Explorer now have a “Do Not Track” option in their privacy settings. If you check this off, your browser will send a signal to every website you visit saying you do not want to be tracked. There is also a website, donottrack.us, that will add this signal to any browser. However, websites do not have to abide by your request. As more people become concerned with privacy, one can expect this option to become more strictly enforced.
Also there are various cookie options on your browser. You can choose not to download cookies at all, but this will often keep you from logging into or staying logged on to various websites. You may have the option to be notified every time a website is trying to give you a cookie, which I recommend as a way of seeing just how much tracking is going on. But it’s not very practical as anything other than a learning exercise considering how many cookies you download on a daily basis. You can periodically dump all your cookies, and find a middle ground in your privacy settings to block a substantial number of them.
Checking Cookies
Consider keeping multiple e-mail addresses, one for social media and one for private matters. If you don’t want your Facebook connected with the video game you just bought in the store, don’t enter your social media e-mail into any forms or computers that the store offers you.
I have begun to periodically check the cookies in my computer and block cookies on websites that I don’t log on to. I will be careful when I am asked to enter a phone number or e-mail address on or offline, because I know that these are ways to identify me. I’m not comfortable with my information being stored on data brokers’ servers; how long before a hacker manages to steal this information?
You may not be bothered by advertisers buying information about you to send you more relevant ads. (You can expect more of that since Facebook now allows teens to post status updates, videos, and images that can be seen by anyone, not just friends or friends of friends.) But it’s unclear what other purposes your data may be gathered for in the future, particularly in light of recent news that the National Security Agency (NSA) is using our profile information from Facebook and GPS data for surveillance purposes.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.