Details have been changed.
The door opened slowly, and I could hear my heart pounding in my ears. The person auditioning before me, a fellow 8th grader, rushed out. I stepped inside and took a deep breath.
The music teacher sat calmly at a piano in the middle of the room, smiling widely. She played a chord, and I somehow coughed up enough of a voice to do a few warm-ups. “Soprano,” she scribbled on a piece of paper I was standing close enough to see. Then she shooed me a few steps back, which caused my heart to race.
“You’ve got this,” I told myself. I cleared my throat and picked a spot on the opposite wall to stare at. Using my trusty falsetto, I sang “Amazing Grace,” slowly and softly-a bit too softly, but still in tune. When the song came to an end, I couldn’t help smiling from ear to ear. It was over.
But the teacher’s smile had faded, causing mine to disappear as well. “Thank you,” she said, in a forced happy tone. I nodded and rushed out the door.
Dream School
From the time I was 10 years old, I knew that I wanted to go to Edward R. Murrow High School. Specializing in music and art, with colorful walls, elaborate theatrical programs, and no sports teams whatsoever, Murrow was different from other high schools and perfect for me.
I was ecstatic when I was accepted. But my vocal audition didn’t go as I had hoped, and after several months, I learned that I hadn’t made it into the school’s famous music program. I was upset. I have been singing for as long as I can remember, and Murrow is an excellent place for musicians to perfect their art, improve their skills, and broaden their horizons.
Still, I didn’t give up. Each student in the vocal program was scheduled into one chorus class and one technical class a year, and I knew there was sometimes space in the choruses for the rest of us. I was particularly fascinated with the school’s gospel chorus, and tried to convince my new guidance counselor to put me in that class.
It wasn’t that simple.
Just a’Regular’ Student
“You can’t take gospel,” my counselor told me breezily, clicking away on her computer as she formulated my freshman schedule. “That’s for the music majors.”
I sighed. “This isn’t fair,” I thought. “You bomb one audition and you pay for it the rest of your high school career? I just wanna sing!”
“What about next semester?” I asked.
She didn’t look up from her computer. “It’s not for freshmen, and the music majors get priority anyway. That’s what they’re in this school for. You’re in the regular program.” The regular program. Those words stung like a bee. What did “regular” mean-the program for students who weren’t talented enough to get into the school through an art?
But I didn’t know what I could say. There were plenty of people who didn’t get into the music program but weren’t complaining about being “regular” students. After sitting in silence for a few minutes, my guidance counselor handed me my schedule, chock full of introductory freshman classes. The first class on the list was called “The Spirit of Music.”
A Way In
“The Spirit of Music” turned out to be one of the most boring classes of my high school career, but I also consider it one of the best things to happen to me. That’s because the teacher, Ms. Marshall, was also the director of the school’s gospel chorus.
She mentioned this on the first day of class, and the rest of the period was a blur; I spent it daydreaming about singing with the gospel chorus, led by Ms. Marshall. After class, I ran up to her in a frenzy and expressed my interest in participating.
“Great,” she said, eyes wide. She explained that non-music majors who couldn’t get into the gospel chorus class still had the option of attending after-school rehearsals. “We meet here on Wednesdays,” she said.
I pictured myself singing in an oversized robe, eyes closed, arms raised, face pointed upward. “OK. I’ll be there!” I thanked her and walked out of the classroom, smiling my way down the halls.
Working Twice as Hard
Singing with the gospel chorus only once a week freshman year, when most of its members sang four times a week, was extremely difficult. I had to work twice as hard to learn our songs and harmonies for holiday concerts, charity benefits, and national competitions. It was grueling to stay at school until dark, catching up on the work I missed, and I often had an immense urge to skip Wednesday rehearsal.
But I stayed with it, enjoying the ecstatic feeling I got from singing with my soul week after week. The concerts were especially rewarding: Standing onstage, knowing that my voice was contributing to the amazing sound of each harmonious note, made me feel important to the chorus.
Luckily, I was accepted into the gospel chorus class for the next three years of high school, which meant I no longer had to cram everything into one weekly after-school session. Even in the class, however, there were many instances when I didn’t think that the time and effort I put in was being acknowledged.
The Only Worthy Reason
Though the majority of my classmates were music majors, I did more for the chorus than many of them. During my junior year, all of the approximately 75 students in the chorus were told to come to weekly rehearsals for our performance of Handel’s “Messiah.” Yet only about seven of us attended regularly, and I was one of them.
The Messiah rehearsals were just one example. I frequently attended “mandatory” benefits or rehearsals with only a few other students, and was frustrated by both the lack of student effort and the lack of teacher appreciation.
As I thought about how hard I’d fought to be in the chorus, I felt annoyed that my fellow members didn’t understand how lucky they were. I also thought I deserved credit for going the extra mile, yet I didn’t feel anyone noticed. My frustration turned to anger, and it wasn’t long before I found myself resenting the chorus and my own decision to remain a member.
But as I thought more seriously about whether to stay or quit, I gradually began to realize something. When I pictured my life-or just a normal school day-without gospel chorus, I saw that what I would be giving up meant more to me than a simple pat on the back. Singing gospel was my daily therapy session, a cathartic experience (a way of releasing my emotions) that I was lucky enough to earn school credit for.
All the frustrations aside, the actual act of standing up and singing made me genuinely happy. It dawned on me then that doing something because you love it is the only worthy reason there is.
Cruel Joke?
After four frustrating, rewarding, completely unforgettable years of singing with the gospel chorus, I received a letter inviting me to my school’s Senior Awards Night. I brought my family and sat in the auditorium on the edge of my seat, waiting to be called up for what I thought would be an academic award. I’d done well in Spanish and English, and thought I’d won something for one of those subjects.
The awards were presented by subject, and when both the foreign language and the communications awards had been distributed and I hadn’t been called up yet, I started feeling anxious. Did they just invite me as a cruel joke?
Not once did it cross my mind that I would be receiving an award for any other subject. But as the night came to a close, the last awards category, music, was announced. Medals for instrumental music were distributed, followed by medals for vocal music. Gold and silver medalists were called to the stage to receive their recognition, and the chair of the music department began to announce the recipients of the bronze medal in alphabetical order. “Suzanne Abbas-Berkowitz,” he read out. A bronze medal in vocal music? I got chills.
Walk of Victory
That walk up to the stage to receive my award was one of the most glorious walks I have ever taken. The moment reminded me that hard work does pay off, even if it may seem otherwise. Joining the gospel chorus freshman year as a “regular” student, I never would have predicted that four years later I’d find myself onstage receiving a medal of recognition with the best of the music majors.
Regardless of the obstacles and frustrations I faced, I stuck with gospel because I loved it. Singing gospel music filled me with amazement. Being part of a group that came together from different cultures and races to make marvelous music gave me a feeling that was addictive. That’s why I never stopped, despite having to work hard without much positive reinforcement from anyone else.
Though I realized on Senior Awards Night that my four years of time and effort had been recognized all along, my medal was really just the icing on the cake. I learned halfway through high school that singing is its own reward, one that neither gold nor silver nor bronze could ever equal.
Glee is the Goal
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.