The New Teen Novels-Mean Girls Win?

Imagine a book featuring a 7th grade clique at an all-girls private school, and back-stabbing drama galore. doesn’t that sound like a tasty treat to read? Well, maybe if I were still in 7th grade, it would have been.
When I began to read The Clique, the first of six books (and counting) in the Clique series by Lisi Harrison, it reminded me of being in 7th grade again, in my old private school-but only a little. I remember cliques, but not like this one. I’d never seen such shallow characters with such mean intentions. At my school, there were always the popular people and those who aspired to be like them, but there were also many who were smart enough to be proud to be themselves.
Why you might ask, did I read the book in the first place? Last spring I read an article by feminist author Naomi Wolf in the New York Times arguing that some of today’s young adult novels offer girls terrible values.
Sex at the Movies
The language and content that Wolf described surprised me. She talked about characters in the books having sex at the movies during the boring parts and recommending “semi-sex” because oral sex “Is so over.”
Wolf was disappointed that instead of rebelling against the most corrupt and shallow aspects of the adult world like young adult novels traditionally do, the characters in these books embrace them.
At first, I strongly disagreed with Wolf. She seemed to suggest that the books would have a negative influence on girls. I felt that as a teen, I knew better than Wolf what teens are doing these days, and that she shouldn’t assume we’re all jumping into bed with each other just because we read about it in a book. I’d seen these books at Barnes and Noble. The covers showed pretty girls smiling, laughing and wearing beautiful clothes. I figured the books were just little cute reads.
Then I read a few of them and I was shocked.
The Pretty Committee Wins
In The Clique, a spoiled foursome in Westchester, New York attend a private school called Octavian Country Day School. They’re the “It” girls of the school. They own the halls, the new “It” jewelry from Tiffany & Co. and most importantly, the new Burberry scarves their parents bought them. They are the “Pretty Committee.”
Enter new girl, Claire Lyons from Florida, who dons anything but name brands and wears handmade plastic beaded jewelry from her best friends at her old school. Claire and her family move in with the alpha it-girl, Massie Block, while they look for a place to live.
Claire attempts to be friends with Massie and her crew, but they do anything and everything to make Claire go away, including putting red paint on the back of Claire’s white pants. Claire fights back, but fails. In the end, the “Pretty Committee” wins again, and Claire is left a loner.
I couldn’t believe how cruel, sexually driven and immoral some of the characters were. I can only thank God I have yet to meet a person like the people in these books.
I was disturbed that 7th graders might be reading these stories, where the moral seems to be that mean girls win and everyone else can just go wither away and hide under their bed. I suddenly feared for the 12-year-olds who read these books to sleep every night. I worried that the future might be filled with real-life Massie Blocks and “Pretty Committees.”
Pathetic But Enticing
But I must admit, I found myself getting sucked into these little dramas. I read the first three books in the Clique series and I can understand why they’re popular.
They’re an easy read, with catchy phrases that kids use today, and they provide entertaining stories of back-stabbing friends and troubles in the romance department that are somewhat realistic (minus the millionaire parents and lavish parties for 12-year-olds). I found it so enticing and pathetic that I just had to keep reading.
I also tried to read another book that Wolf mentioned, from the Gossip Girls series by Cecily von Ziegesar. The series features a bunch of senior girls at an elite Manhattan private high school. I couldn’t finish the first book. Although the 12th grade drama was more real to me, I preferred reading about spoiled 12-year-olds than about 18-year-olds obsessed with who’s sleeping with who. I read approximately four chapters and threw the book aside, utterly astounded that an entire series of such fiction would be published.
Not What Teens Are Like
And yet, the Clique and Gossip Girls novels are best-selling young adult fiction right now. I think girls buy these books either because they find the stories as enticing as I did or because the books are what the popular kids are reading.
And why are they being written? I’m afraid to think that the authors believe this is what preteens and teens are really like today. The books make us look like materialistic sex maniacs. Some things in the books are accurate, like wanting to fit in and liking someone who likes someone else, but many of the details are unrealistic.
It’s a shame that girls are reading these books rather than the Judy Blume and Sweet Valley High series that I grew up on. Those books dealt with real issues that teens go through and offered some lessons to be learned.
It’s No Sweet Valley High
Books like the Clique and Gossip Girls series, on the other hand, only deal with “the beautiful people.” They suggest to readers that it’s alright to be mean to other people and that having sex with boys in an elevator is cool.
Parents who believe their preteens and teens are reading the same Judy Blume books that they did are seriously mistaken. My fellow teens, watch out for the deceivingly cute covers of girls smiling and having fun. They’re only smiling because they just humiliated some poor innocent girl.
If you come across one of these books, pick it up and judge for yourself. On second thought, don’t waste your time. If you’re craving teen fiction, pick up a Judy Blume book like Are you There God? It’s Me, Margaret instead.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.