Stuck in a Rut

I don't know how to forgive my mom.

When I was almost 18 and living in a group home, staff told me I was being sent back to my mother’s because I did not go to school. I had been placed in several schools all around New York City, and after a few days at each school, I was outta there.
That I cut school was the reason my mother gave for getting rid of me in the first place! I wished someone would have helped me get to the root of my problem, instead of tossing me back and forth and not resolving anything.
Then again, I am not sure I would have been able to express my fears even if asked. I felt a mixture of abandonment, anger, depression and anxiety. How in the world could I concentrate on math?
I Felt Lost
Going back home to my mother ended up being a bad move. I fell into a deep depression. For months I rarely left the apartment unless it was pitch black outside, so no one would see me, and then I went only to get a pack of ciggies and go straight back to bed.
My mother pretty much ignored me. Once I was going on and on, yelling and screaming about being ignored, but guess what? My mother ignored that, too.
I felt lost. I was back to where I started. I knew I couldn’t stay but had no idea what to do next.
Living with my mom as a child, I felt unwanted. My mother rarely gave compliments, just criticism and correction. I don’t remember being able to say, “Look what I did today!” or feeling she was proud of me at all.
My mother acted like I was an annoyance, or never good enough. The last time I remember trying to include her in something I enjoyed was when I noticed she was not particularly busy and I asked her if she would like to color with me in my Precious Moments coloring book. I’m not even sure why I asked her. I was used to being rejected. But when she did not want to color with me, it still hurt.
In contrast, she outright babied my brother. That made me feel much worse.
Fighting Over School
Education seemed to be the one and only subject my mother discussed with me, and I felt like if I wasn’t living up to her expectations, then I was worthless.
My mother and I really began to fight when I started playing hooky. I stopped going to school in high school because I was painfully shy and awkward. I felt like everyone was looking at me, judging me, talking about me. I thought I looked funny, talked funny and didn’t know much about much, while everyone else dressed well and knew what movies and music was “dope.”
Everyone assumed that I was just being stubborn (or stupid) about not going to school. In fact there was more to it. Recently I was diagnosed with severe social phobia, an intense anxiety about being around people.
At times I just hung out in the park behind my high school. It wasn’t like I was drinking or smoking or anything wild. I was just avoiding school!
I don’t feel I was as out of control as my mother made it seem, but eventually she filed a PINS petition, and the court placed me in foster care temporarily.
Total Sentence: 2 Years
I didn’t really understand what was happening. One day I was in a courthouse being interrogated about my home life. I was so nervous. I have no idea what I said.
Soon after, a car came to take me to a group home. I couldn’t believe I was going to be part of “that world” where I’d heard only bad things happen or only bad kids are sent. I wasn’t bad!
That day felt like a blur. Rarely, if ever, had I been out of the Bronx, but this car kept driving and driving. I was in the backseat, scared. I might as well have been blindfolded because I had no idea where I was or where I was going to end up. Trees were going by. I didn’t know if they were moving, or I was.
We stopped somewhere to process me. I was weighed and my charts were read again. Then I arrived at the Euphrasian Residence. My “sentence” was just for a few weeks. But soon the PINS petition was changed to a neglect charge against my parents because they never visited me and my father never showed up in court.
Eventually I was turned over to St. Helena’s Residence. Total sentence: about two years. Felt more like 20 to me.
Terrified and Abandoned
At first I was so angry. I felt completely abandoned, like my mother had dropped me off on a stranger’s doorstep. I didn’t unpack for a very, very long time. I was hoping it was all a big mistake and I would be able to go home.
I was pretty terrified. But nothing terrible happened. I made a lot of good friends, learned new things, some of them negative-like drinking and smoking-and some of them desperately needed, like getting to know the city and learning what freedom and independence felt like.
In care, I built a wall against my parents. I hated them for getting rid of me like some stray dog. There was no way I could ever tell them how much that hurt, and I doubted they’d care if I did. I took their phone calls less often, and eventually took no calls from my father at all.
I didn’t want to hear their reasons. There was nothing anyone could say to help me understand why I was unwanted. I carried that grudge forever. In fact, I still have it.
After a few months living back home again, I knew I had to do something to take control of my life. I felt like I was rotting away. I had no job, no friends, nothing that kept me going. Then I visited an old friend in Pennsylvania. While I was there, I found out about an apartment vacancy. So I jumped on it and said to my mother, “I want to move to PA”. She spent the next several hours running down the list of reasons I couldn’t.
A Strange Land
I am not sure if she didn’t want me to move, or if she thought I couldn’t handle it. Coming from me, it almost sounded silly. I rarely left the apartment, and here I was talking about relocating to another state!
But I was determined, so I moved, and it was a good idea. In my studio apartment not much larger than a cardboard box, I often looked around and thought, “All this is mine!”
It felt so good not having to answer to anyone. I quickly got a job and was able to go to work, pay my bills, go shopping, do laundry-all things I had never done on my own before. It was like being in strange land!
My Mother’s Voice
It’s been 10 years since then. (I hate saying that out loud! It feels like yesterday.) I’ve become an adult-I’ve had several jobs, been in a relationship for eight years, and have a daughter of my own. I’ve moved into a bigger apartment, battled with my landlord. Day by day I feel I am accepting myself more. But it is slow.
I haven’t changed as much as I wish to. I’m still a homebody with few friends, and although I’ve been in and out of therapy for years, I feel anxious, depressed and inadequate much of the time. My mother is still a big voice in my head telling me I am not making the right decisions, or that I am not smart enough because I didn’t finish my education.
Trying to Go Forward
Each time I find myself trying to make a decision, I can hear my mother’s voice. Let’s say I need a couch. Sounds easy. Go into the store, look around, see something you like, pay for it, take it home. Sit down and relax.
Not me! I am looking around thinking “What will my mother say about my choice? Am I spending too much? Will she think I am being frivolous?”
I try to stop imagining my mother’s voice and opinions and just go forward with decision making, but it’s hard. Sometimes I buy something just to have it and say silently to myself, “Take that, Mother!”
I am not surprised that I am still strongly stuck in the past, but I am upset that I can’t let it go. I feel that time has passed and I want to move on. I don’t need to carry this with me forever. It is not helping in any way. But I don’t know how to do that.
Empathy and Anger
I have tried to talk with my mother, and I’ve started to understand more about why she wasn’t able to be there for me the way I wanted her to. My mother’s parents didn’t deal with feelings and she never learned how. And when I was growing up, my mother was in an unhappy marriage. I think my parents tolerated each other at best, but there was plenty of arguing and few moments of happiness.
Maybe because her marriage felt out of control, my mother wanted things with me to go her way.
Looking back, I see that my mom was sad or depressed. But she’d never admit to it, and understanding it myself doesn’t relieve my anger.
It Seemed Right at the Time
The past recently came up between us when we were talking online.
Her: “When I was your age I was social, went dancing, traveled, etc.”
Me: “Well, we are not the same. Your parents didn’t get rid of you.” (I now see that I attack her any chance I get.)
Her: “I did what I thought was right at the time.”
Me: “don’t you see now that it might not have been right? Can you admit you made some mistakes that are directly related to how I am now?”
Silence.
I feel she will never understand or accept my point of view.
It’s even harder for me to understand my mother’s attitude because, now that I have my own daughter, I show her my love. I kiss her, hug her and can’t stand being away from her. I praise her and let her laugh and play, let her make mistakes, and try not to show my anger toward life.
I Am Not Worthless
For so long I’ve believed that if my own mother didn’t want me, then I am worthless. I didn’t feel loved, so I thought I must not be worth loving. Even though maturity has hit and I “know” better, I don’t feel better yet.
The logical side of me knows I have to be the bigger person and forgive my mother, or at least not let my anger toward her control me. It is not helping me at all. The emotional side feels unable to rest until I get revenge-until my mother understands the pain I feel.
Until very recently I didn’t want to believe that my mother couldn’t accept what I am saying or apologize. But the truth is, she is protecting herself, and what I am feeling will never matter more than that.
In Limbo
Sometimes I wonder why I keep up a relationship with my mother at all. I play with the idea of never speaking to her again, because I know my mother won’t change, and I’m not sure I can accept who she is. But I haven’t been able to give up, maybe because I have no one else to really talk to, and I feel that she’s the only person who might be able to lift me up.
So I keep my hopes up. Each time we speak, I think, “OK, this time she will respond the way I want her to.” And each time I’m rejected, it hurts. I know I can’t keep going like this.
So I’m in limbo. Sad to find myself stuck here, dying to move on. Not sure how.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.