To find out just why Miguel had so much trouble finding housing, we went to the experts. A staff at the Center for Urban Community Services (CUCS) said that 18-25 year olds have a harder time getting housing for two reasons: There are very few housing programs in New York City specifically for people under age 25, and few housing programs want to mix younger residents and older residents. “Someone who is 18-25 is facing life issues very different from someone older,” the CUCS staff told us.
Both Not Ill Enough and Too “High-Risk”
On housing interviews, Miguel often heard that his mental health issues were either too severe or not severe enough. While this confused Miguel and those of us at Represent, the CUCS staff broke it down for us.
Most housing for people living with a mental illness is for folks who have what’s known as an “Axis 1” illness, or a very severe disorder. Because many mental illnesses set in later in life, most young adults, like Miguel, are diagnosed with less severe mental illnesses, known as “Axis 2.” Many housing programs do not receive money to accept people who are labeled Axis 2, like Miguel. As one social worker at Miguel’s final shelter bluntly put it, “The crazier you are the easier it is for you to get housing.”
The few programs that could accept clients without severe mental illnesses often rejected Miguel saying he needed more support than they could offer. This is because Miguel had a thick case file indicating what is known as “high-risk behavior,” or a record of repeated hospitalizations and suicide attempts.
If any person has a lot of suicide attempts, or even an attempt in the last six months, providers get nervous, explained the CUCS staff. “They’re concerned about whether they can keep that person safe, and concerned that the person would commit suicide in the building. If someone does commit suicide, it has a whole horrible, difficult impact on the other residents. It’s one of the worst things that could happen in a housing program.”
Few Affordable Places to Live
All of these issues-that Miguel was too young, that he was not diagnosed with a serious mental illness and yet he exhibited “high risk” behavior that required the kind of support typically available only to folks with serious illnesses-got complicated by another very real problem: the lack of affordable housing in New York City.
The more expensive it is to live in a city, the harder it is for people living in supportive housing to eventually become independent and move into their own homes. As a result, even people who might be capable of living on their own stay put, stuck in supportive housing, taking the space of someone new, like Miguel.
The result? Too often, the people who most need housing remain homeless, living in shelters, bouncing around from one friend’s couch to another, not getting the help they need.
Saved By His Drug Problem?
Miguel finally got housing because he developed a drug problem. At the time Miguel was homeless, there was more supportive housing available for people with substance abuse issues than for those who were mentally ill. After he was hospitalized for over-the-counter drug overdoses, the city diagnosed Miguel as having a substance abuse problem. That made Miguel eligible for housing for people with substance abuse issues. Two weeks after his hospitalization, a space opened up in a home for adults with substance abuse issues. After nearly a year of homelessness, Miguel finally found a home.
-K. Hurley
Diagnosis: Homeless
Why Miguel Couldn't Find a Place to Live
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.