(Names have been changed.)
I’m not a punk, goth, prep, or freak. I’m too innocent to be any of those things. Sometimes I feel like everybody is better and cooler than I am.
I wonder what it would be like to hang out after 10 o’clock, drink vodka and smoke, but I only have about five friends and we don’t do that stuff. Other times I wonder what it would be like to be in a rock band. But I’m just into pop and sappy love songs.
I became who I am by staying home a lot and watching heart-warming movies and TV shows about the meaning of life. I shut myself off and grew comfortable being shy.
When I hit my teenage years, I discovered I didn’t feel comfortable doing normal teenage things, like being loud and rebellious. Maybe the way I am wouldn’t bother me so much if I hadn’t lost my best friend Kaylie because of it. Now I’m not sure whether I want to be a different type of person so I can experience new things, or just because I miss Kaylie.
She Began to Rebel
Kaylie was my best friend when I was 12. She still lives across the street from me. When I first met her in 3rd grade, she was like me. We would roller blade to Bedford Park and hold hands in case I fell. We’d ride scooters and go to the supermarket to buy junk food and eat it in our secret spot.
We’d put on shows on my porch where she’d sing and I’d tell jokes. At her apartment, we’d watch movies and give each other makeovers. We were inseparable. We needed only each other.
But when we were 13, she found a boyfriend named Joshua. He was into rock music and guitar, and Kaylie started to enjoy rock music too. At first she was still the same person, just listening to a different kind of music, and I hung out with her and Joshua all the time. But by the time she entered high school, she had changed. She began to drift from me.
In high school, she started making new friends and began to rebel against her parents, who were always on her case for not studying enough. She was depressed, trying to fit her parents’ description of a perfect daughter. But she was also happy about her life, because she had so many friends she could depend on.
But I wasn’t one of them anymore. I felt like I had lost seven years of friendship. What was it for? I had thought we’d be friends forever.
Before we went to high school, we’d spend five hours together every day. Now we don’t do anything. She’s always too busy. But I don’t want to lose her completely so I call her once in a while.
‘You’re Not like Us’
One day, out of the blue, Kaylie invited me out. I thought it would be like old times, where we’d talk about school, who she liked, and our annoying parents. But when I got to the park to meet her, she was with some of her new friends.
There were two girls and a couple of boys. They were all wearing black, with spike bracelets and collars around their necks and baggy pants.
They started talking about a rock band called Dead Station. They were talking about when to rehearse, how the guitar and drums should be played, and who should do the vocals.
I was thinking, “How the hell do they know a rock band?” But when I asked Kaylie about it, she laughed at me and said, “You see my friend over there, and you see me, yeah, we’re the band-duh.”
That was surprising, finding out Kaylie was in a band and hadn’t told me. She said, “Well, that’s because you’re not like us, you’re not a punk. You don’t listen to rock. You’re into pop and you wouldn’t be interested.”
I thought to myself, “Well, OK, whatever. I just would like to know.” I was angry. I felt like she was choosing her new friends over me.
Why can’t I Go Wild?
After that we walked to the huge Stop & Shop supermarket to cool down for a while because we were sweating like we had jogged for miles. It’s where Kaylie and I had hung out in the summer, eating samples, trying on makeup and reading magazines.
This time when we were heading up the aisles, I was by myself. I could almost see all the memories of us together in that supermarket, our hang-out place, slowly disappearing.
I kept looking over my shoulder to get a glimpse at Kaylie and her friends, who were laughing and talking about how their band was going to make it big. They were gossiping about their cool friends and saying who’s going out with whom, who’s cutting themselves, and who’s stealing.
I heard them say they were going to meet up with this “Michael” guy and head to his house to get high and drink vodka. I thought, “Wow, Kaylie and her friends are so cool! They’re a band. They’re getting high and drinking. I bet it’s going to be off the hook.”
I pictured the six of them in the house. “Everyone’s going to share a cup of vodka and get high and make out,” I thought. I was so jealous.
I wanted to enjoy life and go wild and scream at the top of my lungs. But I knew I probably wouldn’t, because I’m too comfortable being good and nice. And because of that I had lost my best friend.
They Laughed at Me
Suddenly I wanted to show them that I could be a bad ass. I didn’t like who I was anymore. I felt boring, and I wanted to be like Kaylie. She was the one person I admired, because of her crazy personality and fearless way of exploring life. I decided to do something I had never done before.
I opened a box filled with pens and stuffed them up my sleeve. We left the supermarket and went across the street to the park. I pulled out the pens from my sleeve and showed them to Kaylie and her friends. I thought they were going to tell me how cool I was.
Instead they laughed hysterically. Kaylie said, “Lily, you can’t be like us, OK? Just accept it. You can never be. No matter what you do. You’re just yourself. Your own little self. I bet there isn’t anyone like you in the world because you shut yourself up and don’t go out.”
She looked me in the eyes and said it in a snotty voice like she was better than I was. I felt like she wanted to make a big impression on her other friends to show them that she had an edgy side. Kaylie made it sound like it’s a bad thing to be who I am, and I felt ashamed.
Learning to Accept Myself
What Kaylie said hurt me. Sometimes I’m not happy with who I am. Sometimes I wish I could change. But to have Kaylie say it to my face felt like betrayal.
She only said those things to impress her new friends. Seven years of friendship and she chose her new friends over me, the person who had always been there for her.
When Kaylie humiliated me, though, it was also a turning point for me. Maybe I wasn’t meant to be like Kaylie. In a way she was right. I’m not like them.
True, sometimes I daydream about what it would be like to be different. Sometimes I hate myself for not being a confident, outgoing type. But I realized that I don’t want to be like Kaylie because it’s not comfortable to me.
I began to think that just because Kaylie doesn’t accept me doesn’t mean I can’t try to accept myself. I usually put myself down thinking of what I’m not and what I want to be. Yet I seldom think about who I am.
we’re Just Different
I’m quiet, good and innocent. Those aren’t things I ever hoped to be, but they’re already in me, and maybe that’s OK. I’m not a wanna-be or a fake.
And there are other unique things about me. I like to read books and watch movies about deep feelings. Sometimes I think I’m able to appreciate life more because I look at it quietly and deeply.
Kaylie isn’t better or worse than me. we’re just different. There are things about her that I don’t like and that make me worry. I think she’s too caught up with partying and drinking and living a dangerous lifestyle. She cuts class and she cuts herself. It’s depressing because she used to be a bright girl with a future.
But there are good things about her, too. She has a lot of friends and I like that she goes out with a lot of guys, because she’s experiencing life. She’s wild and adventurous and not afraid to explore new things. I respect that.
Friends Again Someday?
I hope as Kaylie gets older, all her wild ways turn into something good. I hope my quiet ways grow into something good too.
I think for that to happen, I’ll need to open up a little. Part of me will probably always be quiet, shy and lonely. But too often now, I feel like no one understands me or wants to hang out with me. That makes me feel like I’m boring.
Maybe if I accept myself more, I’ll feel confident enough to open up without feeling like I have to change.
I’ve made many other friends who are more like me-friends who are “goody goody” and have a great sense of humor. When I talk about not being happy with who I am, they tell me to just be myself. I know I’m better off with them. But I still miss Kaylie sometimes.
I still try to have some kind of relationship with Kaylie. If I see her online, I’ll chat with her. I pretend the day she hurt me never happened. We still talk on the phone sometimes about school, movies and our families.
But we never talk about hanging out or our friendship. It’s sad to me. I know our relationship won’t ever be the way it was when we were 12, but I hope when we’re both older and more comfortable with who we are, we’ll be more comfortable being friends again too.
Losing My Best Friend to the Rebels
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.