Sitting right across from me as I plopped down in a #3 train at Atlantic Avenue in Brooklyn was one of the most amazing, sad men I have ever encountered. He was a black man, about 6′, bald, with a salt-and-pepper beard. He looked lean but well fed in his bright orange hooded sweatshirt and old black khakis.
He was pouring out a story to a white cop standing by the nearby doors. The cop was listening but in a half-assed way, looking out the doors at each stop like cops on subway trains tend to do.
Was This Guy Nuts?
The man’s now sobbing voice distracted me from the Jim Morrison biography I was trying to read. I heard the story he was telling-a story about growing up with his best friend in South Carolina, a friend who apparently called him “Pop,” a friend who got shot and died in his arms.
I kept attempting to read about Morrison’s last days in the States. “Pop” was clearly nuts. Why was he crying-to a stranger-about something that happened years ago?
“Are you gonna be OK?” asked the cop four stops later, trying to leave.
“Yeah, yeah, man. I just gotta get over this.” Pop was now doubled over, sobbing.
Enter the Gospel Trio
The cop seemed concerned but got off at Clark Street. A team of about three black panhandlers then came along through the car-to-car door.
At this point I realized that I was witnessing an interesting New York subway scene that wasn’t about to mellow out. So, I took out my trusty blue pad to take notes.
As Pop continued his tale, the trio sang their gospel hymn about Jesus Christ. After some “be strong and God bless” swaps with Pop, they went to the next car. Then the stockiest one of the three came back to give Pop some advice: At least he was alive and well. He made it through the ordeal and should be thankful. Pop mournfully agreed and the guy parted.
‘we’re Always Together’
Alone now, Pop was telling the shiny aluminum wall to his right about his best friend’s murder. About 20 seconds later, he spotted me attentively writing across from him, and I became his designated biographer. It felt like both an honor and an obligation.
Constantly jumping around in his story, he mentioned that he’d had his friend’s dog tag, and then the dreaded words “Vietnam War” jumped out. Everything instantly clicked together. Pop must have fought in the war and was having some kind of flashback.
Pop was now preaching to me, telling how he and his friend would do everything together. “We’d fight together, sleep together.” Then he exclaimed, “we’re always together!”
“Hmmm,” I thought. “Present tense.” It was like half of himself was still in that moment in time.
Pop started blubbering again and told me how he’d be ready to quit and go home but his friend would keep him going. Until one day, one battle-
“don’t go!” Pop recalled yelling to his friend.
But he kept running down the field anyway, until Pop saw him get shot.
“Excuse me sir, you put your ass in my face!” Pop, jolted back into reality for a moment, screamed at a fat white man moving through the train.
Then he continued his story, yelling for my attention, “Hippie!” But he’d never lost it. My head was back down, but only because I was feverishly taking notes.
He Held His Dying Friend
Teary eyed, Pop asked me if I knew what that was like, to have a friend like his. And to have him die right in front of you. I was startled by the question and by the sudden request for a dialogue. I didn’t know how to answer him.
I gave him a look of sympathy and he continued. Pop ran across to where his friend was lying “In the hole” where he had fallen. Pop was “being fired at, being shot at,” but he made it to where his friend was lying-there in the ditch.
“I risked my life to get to my friend.”
In the ditch, he picked up his friend in his arms and held him.
“I’m gonna get ready to leave, Pop,” he said.
Pop tried to protest, but that was it. His friend died right there in his arms.
Later Pop, dressed in full uniform, brought the dog tag he had taken to his friend’s mom at her house. She asked where her son was but then, realizing his fate, started crying. As did Pop, once again, before me.
I’d reached my stop, and silently got off at 34th Street.
Sounded Like a Movie
Initially, I couldn’t decide what to make of my encounter with Pop. What started off as a morning with your average “subway screwball” turned out to be a rare, in-depth look into the tragedy that many Vietnam War soldiers suffered. Pop must have been in his late teens or early 20s, just a little older than me, when he witnessed his friend’s death.
I was amazed by just how much of a cliche Pop’s story was, though. It was the kind of thing that you’d expect to see only in a movie. While I was speed-writing Pop’s story in my pad, the little screenwriters and producers in the back of my mind were shouting, “Been there, done that!”
But I still believed Pop, and not only because he didn’t seem like that good of an actor. I know that these things really did happen.
First Vietnam, Now Iraq
The war in Vietnam started in 1962, with the goal of keeping Vietnam’s communist north out of the noncommunist south. For that we spent nearly 13 years fighting and lost more than 58,000 Americans-mostly young men-with more than three times as many physically wounded. (Plus more than 3 million Vietnamese civilians were killed, wounded or made homeless.)
Now, in the war in Iraq, more than 10,000 Iraqis and 750 American military personnel have been killed. But it’s not just those people lost. An untold number of Iraqis and nearly 4,400 Americans have been wounded so far, many coming home without arms, legs or eyesight. Not to mention the growing number of “Pops,” with lifelong psychological and emotional damage.
Was Pop Drafted?
I wondered how Pop ended up in Vietnam. Did he enlist with his friend, not knowing what he was getting himself into? That could explain why the two of them ended up together in combat. Or was he drafted, like the thousands of other randomly selected 18-26 year olds who didn’t choose to go but were forced to?
Back in the days of the Vietnam War, the only way that you could be a straight male and not get drafted was if you had a medical condition or were in college (or were simply lucky that Selective Service didn’t pick you).
The draft ended in 1973. Our troops returned two years later and we haven’t had a draft since.
So far, all those who have lost their lives in Iraq signed up for the military of their own accord. Maybe they didn’t think they’d be sent to a war zone-or that there’d be a war zone to be sent to-but they knew that if something did happen, they’d be the first to go.
So Far, No Draft for Us
Of course, since the military now pays for a chunk of its soldiers’ college education, it’s no wonder that so many people voluntarily sign up. As college tuition rises, this offer becomes ever more sweet. The military is particularly tempting for poor or working-class teens seeking training and a steady career.
Just in case there aren’t enough volunteers, though, the country can always rely on Selective Service for draftees. While there is no draft right now, men are supposed to sign up for Selective Service when they turn 18.
As recently as April, U.S. Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld said that there would be no draft. According to him, we have more than enough reserve troops at the moment.
Still, I’ll feel better when I hear official talk about withdrawing our troops from Iraq or at least offering a new approach to the situation. Unfortunately, even though a new Iraqi government is supposed to be in place by June 30, 2004, it looks like we’re going to be in this mess for years to come.
I worry that history is repeating itself. I imagine my teenage son in the year 2034, sitting across from a hysterical man of my generation who’s sobbing and having flashbacks about the terrible war in Iraq. The war where he lost a friend-and a part of himself.
Train Ride Back in Time
A soldier's tale
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.