Teens Go on TV to Find the Perfect Family

Deana went up in front of the group. Deana had been on a show on CBS called Wednesday’s Child. Every Wednesday a child goes on the show, hoping that a viewer will call to adopt them, but Deana hadn’t found a family yet.
Deana was one of several foster youth speaking at an event held every few months in New York City in an attempt to get teens in care adopted. The event, held in Harlem, was broadcast on a channel called BCAT, which airs in Brooklyn. On screen with the teens was a number that parents could call if they wanted to adopt the teens on the show.
It was a small production. Only about 50 people were there. We were told that it was the biggest crowd they’d ever had, though. That made us wonder how eager people were to adopt.
Everyone Wanted One Girl
Deana wanted to be a model or an actor, and she was the probably the most charismatic person. She spoke clearly and vividly, and seemed to have everyone hanging on her every word. Deana knew exactly what she wanted in a family. She’d been in a lot of foster homes and wanted a family to love her. She said she didn’t care who she lived with as long as they respected her, and that if they didn’t, she’d talk back to them. She also preferred to live in the neighborhoods Brooklyn or Harlem because she felt most comfortable in those areas.
The audience was really interested in Deana. A lot of people were asking her questions: “Would you be comfortable living with a single father who’d help you pursue all your dreams?”
“Would you be comfortable living with a white family?”
“Would you be comfortable having a sister?”
One guy kept asking, “Would you be comfortable in Queens?”
It was obvious that they all wanted her.
Could Adoption Be a Cure-All?
Marisol, 12, also went in front of the group. Marisol wanted badly to be adopted. Her real mother had left her with a friend and then she ended up in foster care. She felt abandoned. But she was very hopeful. Marisol thought adoption would be her cure-all, and that by telling her story on television she’d find a family that would take her home.
But when she got in front of the cameras she was shy and didn’t talk much. When the show’s host asked what kind of family she wanted, Marisol said only that she wanted one that would appreciate and love her. None of the potential adoptive parents in the audience asked Marisol questions. The audience seemed indifferent to her plea.
We were relieved then that Marisol didn’t see how the audience was acting toward Deana, because if she had, she’d have felt pretty bad. I guess that the people in the audience didn’t realize that everybody-including Deana-has their own problems or issues. They seemed to like Deana because she seemed focused and independent and charming.
Acting Like the Perfect Child
That made us think that the program was bad for the kids who wanted to be adopted. They were exposing themselves, but not even themselves; they were just trying to be a person that a family can accept. But even if they were to get adopted, that family may not accept them-because they can’t be the poster child that the family was interested in. Later we thought those kids might self-hate. They’ll think, “If no one accepts me for who I am, then who I am is not good enough.”
Marisol was interviewed with two other teens, Pamela and Jose. They got some outrageous comments. We were shocked when a woman asked Pamela, “How tall are you?” We thought, “Wow, why would you ask that question?” It was like she was looking for fruit or something, or picking out an animal.
Later we asked that woman why she wanted to know Pamela’s height. She said she was shorter than the other kids she’d adopted. “I don’t want anyone taller than me,” she said, jokingly. But she seemed to mean it.
Telling All
The interviewing also seemed invasive. They were asked questions that we would have been uncomfortable answering. But the teens answered anyway, telling all in the hope of finding a family that would love them.
Finally, we had a chance to talk to the man in charge, Pat O’Brien. He said the goal of the show wasn’t to get the kids adopted, but that it was a “consultation” for people thinking about adopting. For the teens, it was just “for the experience” he said, which must have been a pretty good experience-like being on an infomercial, where the product is taken apart and observed.
But of course, we knew that if the kids do get adopted, it’s probably worth it.
So we asked O’Brien, “So how successful is your program? How many kids are really adopted through this program?” O’Brien told us the teens got paid a $25 stipend, but that they were not there to be adopted. We wondered, “Did the kids really understand that?” Probably not, considering the look of disgust that came over Deana’s face when he said that. Some of the kids had even told us earlier, “My caseworker told me I was going to get adopted today.” We thought, “Wow, is this a joke?”
‘I’ll Get Adopted If I Behave’
These kids we interviewed were really sure they needed adoption to fix their lives. Marisol shook her head every time we brought up, “What if it doesn’t happen?” She refused to believe the possibility of not getting adopted. She said, “I’ll get adopted if I behave.”
So we got angry when O’brien said they didn’t expect teens to get adopted. The event seemed rude and misleading. Teenagers are people, not objects, and they don’t need the false promise of adoption to mess with their minds. The program seemed to needlessly expose teenagers’ private lives to people who weren’t even planning to adopt them.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.