Anthony: Girlhood is a documentary about two girls-Shanae and Megan-who were in a juvenile facility in Maryland. It is about their difficult times trying to go from bad directions into good directions. Girlhood is their true story. To make the movie, the filmmaker followed the two girls for three years.
After being raped, Shanae was locked up because she stabbed a friend of hers to death when she was 12 years old. In the movie, she says that she did not mean to kill the girl, it was an accident.
Megan was locked up for assault. Megan’s life story was nothing like Shanae’s. Shanae had a good family that loved her even though she was always getting into trouble. Shanae was getting home visits every weekend. But Megan’s home situation seemed very bad. She has a grandmother who is an alcoholic and her mother was a dope fiend who was off and on in Megan’s life. Three Represent writers went to see it. Here’s how we related:
‘One Mistake Can Change Everything’
Marissa: To me, the movie was about how your one mistake or the mistake of your loved one can turn your life inside out and upside down. In a weird way, I could relate to Shanae, not because I stabbed another girl to death in a fight, but in the sense that one mistake in life can change everything.
We sometimes do things without thinking first, like how I run away from home. Once I am gone I realize the consequences not only for me, but for all of my loved ones. The truth that smacks me in the face every time I get in trouble is that my family really does love me.
Eric: I could relate to Shanae because I used to do so many bad things, like not listening to my mother, coming home whenever I felt like it, hanging out with the wrong crew and doing bad in school. It got me in much trouble. Shanae had the strength to turn her life around, she graduated fourth in her class, just as I have been learning from mistakes I made.
What I did not like about the movie was Megan’s mother, Vanessa. Although she had a drug problem, I thought Vanessa should have been a responsible mother and taken care of Megan. Maybe if she had done the right thing, Megan would not have gone to a lock up facility and wouldn’t have been so upset.
Setting a Bad Example
Anthony: Vanessa was in and out of jail because of her drug habit. She and Megan were released at the same time and at first they were both trying to do right. Vanessa seemed worried about her daughter. Megan was smoking marijuana, and when her mother found out, her mother was telling her that it was not good for her to smoke it. But Vanessa was setting a bad example for her daughter, because she was addicted to drugs herself, and Megan’s prediction turned out to be right-at the end of the movie, her mother went back to jail.
Megan was very upset with her mother, especially because Megan had to grow up in the foster care system because of her mother’s drug habit. Vanessa probably does not think that what she is doing has an effect on her daughter, but it does.
‘Why Let Your Past Hold You Back?’
Marissa: Vanessa was mad at her own mother, because her mother had a drinking problem and Vanessa never got the love she wanted. Megan was mad at Vanessa for the same thing. But I wanted to ask Megan: Why do the same thing to yourself? Why not just go to a program and get yourself some counseling? Why let the past hold you back? Slowly, your mother may follow and things might work out.
Anthony: Shanae was doing good for herself, so she got released from the lock up into a group home. At the group home, she told the social worker she was raped at 10 years old by a group of older guys. A lot of people are scared to talk about what they’vebeen through, but I liked that Shanae is not a shy person. She told the social worker what happened, and how she expressed the anger she was feeling when she hurt her friend soon after.
Releasing Anger
I can truly understand why Shanae stabbed her friend. After she was raped, she didn’t tell anybody what happened. She had so much anger built up inside her, and that anger came out when she stabbed her friend. I had much anger built up inside me, too, because my mother abandoned me to foster care. Then I ended up getting arrested because I released my anger by robbing someone.
Shanae was away for four years, but finally she got sent home. Just a week after that, her mother died from a heart attack. This hurt her so much because when she was in jail she missed being with her mother.
Happy and Proud
Eric: At that moment, I was feeling close to Shanae because my mother passed away a couple years ago. When my foster mother told me my mother died, I was shocked. I used to visit my mother every year at Christmas, and I just wanted my mother to stay alive. When she was gone, I was hurt and angry. I’d hoped that I might be able to live with her again, kind of like how Shanae was looking forward to going home all that time.
I was impressed that, even though she was hurting, Shanae was able to finish her school year. At the end of the movie, Shanae goes to her prom. We saw her outside her house, surrounded by her neighbors and her aunt, wearing a fancy dress, and riding off in a limousine. She looked happy and proud of herself. I hope I can do the same thing.
Family Support Helps
Anthony: Shanae had the support of her father and her aunt. That helped her a lot. Now she is attending college.
Megan isn’t doing as well. At the end of the movie, Megan moved in with her cousin and started counseling, but she was struggling. Her mother, Vernessa, relapsed again and she was back in jail.
Megan had nobody to really rely on. She was moving from home to home and she did not have the support that she needed from her parents. I hope that Megan stays out of trouble. I do not want to see her ending up hurting someone because of her anger. Megan has to learn to stop waiting for her mother to get off drugs and just move on with her life, accomplishing the goals she has for herself.
I came into foster care because my mother was using crack. As time passed, I had to give up on my mother, let go of my anger and reach my own goals.
Girls Like Us
A film that gets system life right
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.