Halfway through my freshman year two years ago, I heard the saddest song. A girl in my English class played “The Best Deceptions” by Dashboard Confessional to accompany a short story she wrote about a cheating girlfriend. The singer’s voice whispered and then screamed. “I heard about your trip/ I heard about your souvenirs/ I heard about the cool breeze, in the cool nights/ And the cool guys that you spent them with.”
The direct lyrics moved me and I could feel the singer’s emotion; he sounded like he had just cried. His voice was pure, like he was singing live. It wasn’t at all like highly produced Top 40 singers like Justin Timberlake or Britney Spears.
Singer’s Emotions Feel Honest
At that time, I listened mostly to hip-hop and pop and watched MTV and BET. But now I craved more of the raw sound of Dashboard Confessional and the band’s singer and songwriter, Chris Carrabba.
So when I went home that day, I downloaded almost all of Dashboard Confessional’s songs. Most of them were about sad situations like infidelity and heartbreak. But they also had choruses and melodies that made each song catchy. Most of the songs were acoustic (no electric instruments) with just a guitar playing gently, then Carrabba would shout and strum his guitar harder.
I connect to the emotions Carrabba expresses because they feel honest. I respect people who can express themselves without acting like they think other people want them to. I’d like to be that way, but it’s not so easy.
Hiding My True Self
It’s hard to stay true to yourself in high school, where people can be judgmental about how you look and act. On the outside, I blend in. I look like a clean-cut, smart, perky Asian girl, but I don’t think of myself as any of that. The inner-self that only my close friends see is a sarcastic, cursing slacker.
I don’t show my emotions much because I don’t want to hurt other people’s feelings. I’m also aware that some of the things I get angry at are ridiculous, like little things people say that tick me off for no good reason.
But when I get home, I can lock myself away from the world and listen to Dashboard Confessional. I sing along to each word, and I feel better as my anger drains away. When I’m upset, I do a lot of reflecting alone. I think about why I’m mad and usually realize that it isn’t worth being angry over.
Drawn in by Whispers
The last time I felt so strongly about a band was in 8th grade, when I discovered Nirvana. I could feel the pain in the songs. I hated my life at that time because nothing was going right. My parents were fighting so much, I thought they were going to get a divorce. Nirvana made me feel it’s OK to be angry.
Chris Carrabba reminds me of Nirvana’s lead singer and songwriter, Kurt Cobain, in the way he whispers and then screams. When the words are whispered, I feel drawn in, wanting to know exactly what the singer is saying. When the words are screamed, I feel newly awake and alive.
I also like lyrics that make me think. In one of my favorite Dashboard Confessional songs, “Saints and Sailors,” Carrabba sings: “Wandering the house/ Like I’ve never wanted out/ And this is about as social as I get now/ And I’m throwing away the letters that I am writing you/ ‘Cause they would never do/ I would never do.” I like how he expresses his feeling that he could never live up to his girlfriend’s standards.
When he sings, “You smile like a saint but you curse like a sailor,” it sort of reminds me of myself. On the outside I appear nice, but the real me is often angry and curses a lot.
Thought he’d Be Geeky
Since his lyrics are mostly about rejection, I pictured Chris Carrabba as ugly and super skinny, probably a geek in high school. I liked imagining him like that because I sometimes feel geeky when I don’t want to socialize with people. I’d rather be lost in my own thoughts than to try to have a conversation with someone I don’t really know and feel awkward.
But I discovered that Carrabba wasn’t at all geeky when, several months after I first heard the band, I saw the video for “Screaming Infidelities” on MTV2. He has dark, James Dean-style hair, high cheekbones, a lean body and tattoos. It was a bonus finding out that he’s cute. I don’t think I’d admire him or the band any less, though, if he were as geeky as I thought he’d be.
I think I also pictured him as geeky because I thought that might explain why he hadn’t gotten much media attention. Back in 2001, I found a lot of fan websites about Dashboard Confessional, but the music magazines I looked at, like Blender, didn’t have any information about the band.
I Had Them to Myself
At the time, Carrabba publicized his music by touring and posting songs online that could be downloaded. I liked the idea that he went directly to the people who might like his music, rather than creating massive publicity all over TV and radio.
And it made me feel that in some way I had Dashboard Confessional to myself because the whole world didn’t know about them. Liking non-mainstream music makes me feel special, that I’m an individual who isn’t conforming to what everyone expects me to like.
Since I didn’t think of Dashboard Confessional as popular, I was surprised when they won an MTV Video Music Award in 2002. I was happy that they were getting more media attention because I thought they deserved the recognition. I wanted the world to be happy like me when listening to them.
Louder, Happier and More Popular
Then in August 2003, Dashboard Confessional released A Mark, a Mission, a Brand, a Scar. I think it’s a great CD, but it’s different from the past albums. Like on the previous albums, these songs are catchy with poetic lyrics and guitar strumming. But the band uses more loud electric guitars and strong beats than before. Only two of the songs on the album have Carrabba’s original acoustic style.
Carrabba still has the raw emotional quality I connect with, but the songs’ subjects are different. On “As Lovers Go,” Carrabba sings, “This is easy as lovers go/ So don’t complicate it by hesitating/ And this is wonderful as loving goes/ This is tailor-made, what’s the sense in waiting?” It’s joyful, unlike most of his earlier, darker and sadder songs about love.
Something else is different about this Dashboard Confessional CD-it’s gotten a lot of buzz. “Hands Down” was one of the five most-played videos on MTV2 in September. Carrabba got the cover of the October 2003 issue of Spin, and he was chosen as one of People magazine’s “Sexiest Men Alive.”
I like that Carrabba and the band are getting noticed for their wonderful work. And the more they’re on TV, the more I can see them. But I do worry about them “selling out” or losing touch with what defines them so they can get more record sales. I’m worried they’ll leave their soul-and their old fans, like me-behind.
I Want to Branch Out, Too
So far, though, the music still feels genuine to me. And as much as I love Dashboard Confessional’s past whiny records, I like their new sound, too.
It doesn’t sound like Carrabba is trying to be someone he isn’t in his new songs. It feels to me like he’s trying to branch out to please himself.
That’s what I’d like to do, too. I’d like to let out my true self more instead of keeping up an image that isn’t me. Perhaps if I wear less pink, people won’t think of me as perky. I want to try hanging out with a different group, to expand the number of people I can be myself with and get myself to be more social and outgoing. And I want to be more honest about what’s on my mind.
That’s going to take time. For now, at least, I know that if I can’t reveal more of my true self to others, I can still express myself in my room, to Dashboard Confessional.
Dashboard Confessional Helps Me Be Me
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.