Love and Diane

Watching our lives on the big screen
Love and Diane is a new, movie that shows the true story of a mother and daughter struggling to rebuild their relationship after years apart. The documentary starts when Diane, the mother, has kicked her crack addiction and gotten her teenage kids, including Love, out of foster care. Love, who is 18 and HIV positive, has just given birth to a son, named Donyaeh. Before that, Love went from foster home to foster home and spent more than six years in a group home.
Three of us from FCYU went to see the film-Tanez Best, Natasha Santos and Shannel Walker. Here’s what we thought:
Tanez: I liked how raw it was. Nothing was cut out. We watched while they ate, slept, partied and went through everything.
Natasha: It was in Flatbush, where I’ve lived, and it was realistic.
Shannel: Love even lived in the same group home I went to. And she said the same thing I said about it: it was hell.
Natasha: I really liked that I could compare it to my life. My mother and Love’s mother were similar. Like Diane, my mother constantly left us alone. We had no food, no furniture. I thought, “How can she let us live like this?”
Love told her teacher, “We don’t have any food. My mother uses drugs.” She was just hungry and wanted help. I told on my mom, too. When the cops came, my mom tried to make up lies. She said, “We just moved in this month.” I said, “No, we didn’t. We moved in six months ago.” She said, “We haven’t moved our furniture.” I said, “We never had any furniture.” I wanted to get taken away.
Shannel: When Love was taken, she had so much anger. She kicked the door off the station wagon, and she was only 8 years old. Love just wanted to be with her mother. She didn’t care if they were arguing or anything, she just wanted to be around her mother. When she ran away, she ran to her mother. But her mother was never there. She was out using drugs. Then she’d think, “Why am I running?”
Tanez: Diane wasn’t herself when she was on drugs. Drugs change people. My mother was on drugs and I was removed for being abused. My mother stopped being herself because of the drugs. She was helpless. If she could’ve helped herself, she would’ve.
Shannel: I liked that Diane showed that she went through a lot in her life-she never knew her mother or father, her brother and sister both died of alcoholism and drugs, she lost her son to suicide and she had a hard life coming up. But she’s learning from her mistakes. It took her a while. She was 47 years old, and had been clean for 10 years.
Since Love came home, Diane had been trying to help Love. If Love didn’t want to get up and feed her baby, who did it? Her mother. Love was spending her SSI on herself, and on weed. Her mother had $7 left and spent it on two cans of milk for the baby. She didn’t make right before, but she was trying to make it right then.
Tanez: Love kept blaming Diane, but I felt like, whatever Diane owed Love, now it’s over. Her mother earned some of that back. I felt sorry for Diane. She took all of that blame and sadness, and she said, “I was wrong.” If you do things that make you feel ashamed and humiliated, and then someone keeps throwing that in your face? That’s too much.
I liked that she told Love, “I can’t always make excuses for the past. I’m sorry it hurt you, and it hurt me, too. We can deal with it together, or you go your way and I’ll go mine.”
Natasha: You’re saying she didn’t appreciate her mother. But what did she have to appreciate? Look at what happened at the end. She got away from her mother, and she felt better. Her best bet was to stay away from her mother and get on her own two feet.
Tanez: Love and Diane were both little kids in grown people’s bodies. I learned that about myself by going to therapy. If you never received the love you needed as a child, you’re still a child. Love was looking for someone to take care of her. But her mother wanted to do the mothering with Love’s son, not with Love. My moms did that with my daughter. My father, too. He’s taking care of my daughter now, but he didn’t raise me.
The hardest part of the movie for me was when Love and her sister got in a fight, and Diane told her therapist, and the therapist called ACS. Donyaeh got taken away. I felt that it was harming Donyaeh more than doing good. Instead of removing him, ACS could have worked with them in the home.
Natasha: I thought it was right that Donyaeh was taken. I know that if I wasn’t removed, I’d have ended up like my parents. The cycle has to stop somewhere.
But it was sad for me after Donyaeh was taken, when Diane broke down and said, “What have I done? What have I done?” She felt it was all her fault. That was the first time in the movie when I felt for Diane. I could see that she felt something for someone other than herself. At first, I saw her as a self-centered woman, and I saw history repeating itself in the way Love treated Donyaeh. Love was blaming her mother because she was looking for a way out of blaming herself.
Tanez: At first, I didn’t think Love was going to do what she needed to do to get her son back. Love doesn’t like to be forced, but stubborn as she was, she threw it over her shoulder and did what she had to do. I loved seeing that Love was strong.
Shannel: She was lucky she had a good lawyer. You don’t find too many law guardians like that. She was straightforward, calm and she wanted to help. She told Love what she needed to do. She wasn’t, “Oh, Honey, let’s talk.” She was, “You do it or you don’t do it. Do you want Donyaeh back? Then you got to do it.”
Natasha: It was easy to understand Love’s frustration, though, and her unwillingness to deal with therapy, psychologists and court dates.
Tanez: My daughter was away in care for two years and I was locked up for those two years because of my anger, just like Love. They have me in counseling now. And it’s hard. When you’re the one in the situation, and you think you’re right, no one can tell you that you’re wrong. But sometimes you need to swallow what you think when everyone’s telling you the same thing. People tell me, “When you get angry, you scare us.” I had to go to counseling to calm it down. Love needed that, too.
Natasha: By the end of the film, Diane accomplished something big. Doing the job program was something she wanted to do. She took a big step by completing it. You saw a whole new person at the end.
At the end of the film, Love was where her mom was at the beginning. She got her apartment. That took a year, but she got it. She got herself to therapy, most of the time. And she got her son-first as a trial discharge, then as a full discharge.
When Love got Donyaeh back, she looked blank. She said, “This is what I wantâor is it?” I don’t think she was happy at all. I don’t think she wanted the responsibility. She was scared.
Tanez: I felt like the movie was a puzzle with no beginning and no end. It had no beginning because it started even before Diane and Diane’s mother. And it had no end because of what Love was doing. She got Donyaeh, but she was still missing visits with the therapist. And her mom was still coming in and out of her life, messing with her. I say to my father, who’s the same way: “Don’t do it halfway. Don’t do it on Saturday and Sunday.” Diane wasn’t sure about being Love’s mom. And Love still wasn’t sure she could be a mom, either.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.