During the 1980s, the government woke up and saw that a lot of foster youth were becoming homeless after they left the system. They began to realize that when teens age out of foster care, there is no official net to catch them if they have trouble getting on their own two feet. Aging out (emancipation) is final and net-less. Too often it results in a new batch of freshly aged-outters stuck on the streets with nowhere to turn.
Help for Foster Teens
Foster youth, the government finally figured out, needed more help preparing for life on their own. So the federal government required foster care agencies to provide independent living classes for all teens planning to leave the system to live on their own.
Now all foster care agencies must offer classes teaching life skills, like how to budget money, cook a meal, hold down a job, and find an apartment. And in 1999, the government passed the Foster Care Independence Act, which doubled the money available to help improve independent living services for teens across the country.
But Do IL Classes Work?
But are IL classes really preparing teens to make it on their own after foster care? Or do we seriously need to rethink how IL is taught?
I surveyed a bunch of foster teens and talked to a few experts to find out.
Many of the teens I surveyed said the independent living services at their agencies are helpful. Before independent living class, Jose Ortiz, 19, said, “I did not know nothing about apartments except to pay rent.”
Teens Learn Skills
Another teen said she learned to budget her money and to understand the difference between needing something and wanting it. She also learned how to satisfy both her needs and wants without going broke.
I too have gotten help in my independent living class. The lessons on how to fill out college financial aid papers and job applications were useful.
But some teens and experts feel that IL programs need a serious makeover.
Every independent living program is different, and some are definitely better than others, says Betsy Krebs, the executive director of the Youth Advocacy Center in NYC. “Too often independent living programs are only a few hours a year and don’t really provide any meaningful assistance to young adults,” says Betsy.
In New York City, for instance, teenagers are only required to have 14 hours a year of independent living classes-which isn’t a lot. And studies show that a lot of teens don’t even attend these classes. In a study by the Citizens’ Committee for Children of New York, only two agencies surveyed kept track of how many of their youth attended IL classes. Those agencies said that only between 20 and 50 percent of their teens attended the classes.
Some Don’t See the Point
Some teens complain that they don’t understand the point of independent living classes, so they don’t bother going. Others say they aren’t told when and where there IL classes are being held, or that the classes are too far from their homes.
My IL classes were about an hour and a half away from my home, which sometimes made it hard for me to attend them. When I did make it to the classes, I’d be behind and none of the directors would tell me to make up work or to team up with anybody to catch up.
To be honest, sometimes I wouldn’t go because I would have schoolwork to do or I was just too tired to be traveling so far. Like a lot of teens, I didn’t see the point in my classes.
Also, most independent classes have teens ranging from 14 to 21 years old. Instead of coming up with lessons for each age group, they cycle through the same lessons every year. But the things a 14-year-old might need to learn, like hygiene, might be too simple for a 21-year-old. This can make some people not want to go to class.
But even those kids who do attend independent living classes don’t always learn what they need to make it on their own.
According to a recent study done by the Youth Advocacy Center, many IL classes have a heavy emphasis on lecturing to teens about drug and alcohol abuse and sexually transmitted diseases, but don’t do much to teach teens how to plan for their futures and set long-term goals.
“No one is really tapping into the strengths and resources that teens have,” says Betsy Krebs.
No Substitute for Experience
Also, some of the material taught in the independent living classes are outdated. In a class I attended, teens were supposed to budget $20 for their essential needs. Smell the daisies! You can’t buy much with $20 nowadays.
And several teens I surveyed felt the missing element in most of their IL classes was hands-on experience. On paper, the idea of teaching teens independent living skills in a class sounds great. But some people learn best by doing. Princess Carr, 22, agrees. “When they put you in a apartment and you’re independent, you get skills you’ll never get any way else,” says Princess.
When Princess was in foster care, she participated in a program that gave teens their own apartments to live in with roommates. The apartment was supervised by a social worker, but gave teens actual experience living on their own. “It taught me a lot,” says Princess. “It taught me how to maintain, how to do my own laundry without bleaching all my clothes, and how to cook all my meals without burning them.”
But even for Princess, who eventually was kicked out of that program because, she says, of her own issues, that wasn’t enough to teach her all she needed about becoming self-sufficient. Princess is now homeless. She lives in a shelter and is trying to get Section 8 housing.
In Need of a Safety Net
Her situation shows just how hard it is to make it on your own after leaving care, and how important it is for IL programs to give teens good opportunities to learn how to be independent, while they can still get help from the foster care system.
After talking to a bunch of teens and experts, here are the solutions I recommend for how to prepare for independent living:
o Make IL classes a requirement, not an option. Teens will complain, but it should still be required.
o Keep paying teens a stipend to attend. No matter what, money is money, and will help teens keep attending class.
o Make sure teens understand the importance of learning IL skills. Bring in former foster youth to talk about the skills we need.
o Make IL class easy to get to. I would’ve liked an IL program closer to my home.
o Divide IL classes by age. I agree that 14 is a good age for teens to start the IL program, but I don’t think 14-year-olds should have to sit in the same classes as the 21-year-olds. Maybe some lessons require that they be in the same room, but there are just some things 21-year-olds need to know that 14-year-olds don’t. Don’t waste our time!
o Assign life projects that require teens to go on adventures where they learn by doing. For instance, in my independent living class we went to a shopping mall to learn how to make a shopping list and budget. It was useful, though I thought on the way back home we could have done more to talk about the experience and learn from it.
o Have more programs where teens get an opportunity to live independently before leaving the system.
o Train all foster parents and group home staff to help teach independent living skills in the home.
Next year I turn 21, which means I’m going to have to leave foster care. I feel like the eagle that I was riding on (foster care) is about to do a loop-de-loop and drop me from the middle of the sky to the middle of nowhere. I wish that I could trust that the foster care system was making it easier for me to leave care and be successful. I’m not sure I know what I need to make it without a net.
o Use FCYU in IL classes. (see p. 36)
Are Independent Living Classes Enough?
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.