Friday, November 1, 2002, 4:00 p.m.
The least threatening, least hardcore rock band enters Ultrasound Studios on W. 30th Street in Manhattan, talking about a history test.
Two holdouts from Generation X greet us with casual nods at the front desk. We know they have no respect for us. What place do four preppy kids, fresh off school, have in the crazy world of rock star dreams? One of them quickly shows us the studio we’ll be playing in and shuts the door behind us.
To call us inexperienced would be a gigantic understatement. I’ve only been playing for five months, and even our most experienced members, Matt and Danilo, have only been playing for a year. We’ve rented out this studio time because we want to play in our school’s inaugural Battle of the Bands show on December 13. We need to perform one original song and one cover just to be allowed to enter.
Bickering Bandmates
Matt and I, the guitarists of the group, have managed to put together a decent arrangement of chords that can get us through the verse and chorus. But we’re beating our heads against a wall trying to come up with a riff for Matt to play in the verse, while Danilo and Justin are working on a bass line and drumbeat.
Justin had spent lunch telling Matt how much creativity he lacks. Matt told Justin that he was just the drummer and nobody cared what he had to say.
That argument surfaces again in the studio, when Matt gives up on creating something of his own and begins to play “I Wanna Get Free,” by the Vines, over and over, until everyone’s head is about to explode.
These problems go back farther than lunch. They go back to the beginning of 9th grade, when we all first decided that we wanted to form a band. Danilo was going to be the singer because he could really hit a high note, and then the rest of us would decide what instruments we were going to play.
But to our dismay, Danilo finally hit puberty in the 10th grade and lost any kind of voice he had. Then Matt said that he wanted to play guitar, whether there was a band or not. He began taking lessons that September.
Inspired to Be in Band By the Band
Danilo announced that he was going to play bass, which is what I’d wanted to play. Justin was going to play keyboards and Danilo wanted me to play drums.
I refused, citing my general lack of rhythm. Then Justin announced that he’d play drums. It looked like I was out of the band because I wanted to play bass.
But I didn’t want to let go of this image of me and my friends playing to a screaming crowd. I was inspired by the movie The Last Waltz, which features the Band (yes, that’s the actual name of the group) playing their last show.
They looked so happy onstage and seemed unbelievably cool. There’s something magical to a band onstage and I wanted that. So I decided to play rhythm guitar to fit into the band.
Back in the studio, we’re definitely at the pre-magic stage. Justin and Matt are still taking shots at each other.
“Yo, it’s a bad sign if I can come up with better riffs than the guitarists,” Justin says. I try to remind him not to lump me with Matt, but Matt interrupts with, “Listen, you’re the drummer and you can’t keep a beat for more than two seconds, so shut up.”
“I haven’t had any lessons.”
“Well, you sure as hell could use them.”
Danilo saves us by coming up with a complicated, Latin-sounding bass line, reminding us that we have at least one talented person in the band. I expected the fights when the band started because we manage to fight over everything. Still, it’s frustrating because all progress stops when people shoot one-liners at each other.
I’m not discouraged, though. I read somewhere that angry relationships are sometimes the most creative. OK, so we have the anger part down. Now for the creativity.
We Start to ‘Rock and Rollllllll!!!!’
After about an hour in the studio, somehow the stars align and create the extremely rare occurrence of all of us playing well at the same time. Our first song, tentatively titled “Spanish Manzana,” is coming along. It has an accidental hybrid of Mexican music and garage rock, and the bass line fits the driving chords. We sound kind of, wellâ good!
We slip our blank tape into the recorder and get ready for our first ever recorded song. The song begins with only me strumming chords. My intro sounds nice and smooth. After two full measures of that, everybody else joins in and really kicks the song off. Matt screams, “Rock and Rollllllll!!!!”
Unfortunately, Justin is not your typical stoic and steady drummer. In fact, he gets excited in the same way a small dog might. Matt’s scream is a bit too much for Justin to handle, so the beat quickly deteriorates into something that sounds like it came from a toddler on speed beating pots and pans together. I don’t think that Led Zeppelin ever had to deal with John Bonham having fits of giddiness.
A Crowning Achievement
The next time around, we don’t even reach Justin’s entrance. I screw up on a chord change in the first measure. While a cool, collected performer just ignores his mistakes and covers them up by continuing to play, I stop and apologize to my bandmates.
For each of the next few tries, somebody eventually screws up. Finally, with only a few minutes of studio time left, somebody up there takes pity on us. We play the song well. On tape. Almost all the way through. It is definitely the crowning achievement of our musical careers.
We leave the studio with a little bit of swagger in our steps. Matt and Justin are actually complimenting each other. Our adrenaline is so high, we grill the goth band we pass in the hall because they’re looking at us like we represent everything that’s wrong with the world.
“That’s right,” I think to myself. “We may look like a Gap ad, but we just recorded almost one whole song in an hour and a half. So what’s up now?”
This is why I started learning guitar, so I could get this rush. I don’t exactly feel stage ready, but it feels like a possibility. We hurry back to my house, after rewarding ourselves with some Wendy’s takeout, to play the tape. My parents join us around the cassette player to hear our historical first tape. Andâ
Nothing. We’d forgotten to turn on the recorder.
Saturday, November 9, 8:00 p.m.
Slightly discouraged from our tape mishap, yet resilient, our band decides that we need a new vibe. So, for inspiration,we go straight to Justin’s basement on Staten Island.
To be honest, it wasn’t my ideal Saturday night. I’d planned to go out, but Matt had given me endless aggravation over how I had no dedication and that I was a loser.
Danilo had other plans too, yet we resolutely board the 6:00 ferry with Matt. Armed with my guitar and a pocketful of allergy pills (Justin has a puppy that won’t stop shedding), I feel ready to make music.
When we get to Justin’s house, we go immediately to the basement and jam for an hour. Matt needs to give the song a decent lead and Danilo and I are trying to fix the chorus and come up with a bridge. We keep at it, but it just doesn’t sound right. We need to make changes beyond forcing Justin to incorporate the cowbell into his beat.
Breaking for Cocoa Puffs
“Yo, I think Matt should come up with a riff,” says Justin. “He’s the lead guitarist, after all.”
“Listen, I don’t know what I’m doing,” Matt answers. “I don’t know the scales.” Danilo and I explain the pentatonic scale to him. After all, that’s what friends are for.
With that cleared up, we’re tired and frustrated. Do we push through? No. We go upstairs to eat Cocoa Puffs and play FIFA 2001 soccer on Playstation 2. We’re going places.
I’m convinced that it’s the FIFA and Cocoa Puffs that inspire us. The next morning, still at Justin’s, I come up with a nice chord progression and Matt doesn’t play “I Wanna Get Free” once. In fact, he comes up with a decent riff for the chorus. Danilo, as always, keeps his bass lines solid, and Justin’s drumming seems to have found the beat.
Perhaps We’re Ready for Stage?
Once again, we tape ourselves, but this time we test for about 30 minutes to make sure that we’re actually being recorded. Well, technically, the first 10 minutes are testing, and after that, Danilo and I just screw around, trying to beatbox.
Either way, the tape works. And we play well. Not exactly Grammy caliber material, but for a second effort, we manage to create a decent song.
Perhaps we really are good enough for Battle of the Bands. I’m feeling confident about being onstage with my boys before the new year. We have only three weeks left to practice, though, and we need to perfect “Spanish Manzana” and decide on a cover to play. We plan to practice at least two or three times in the coming week.
Saturday, November 16, 3:00 p.m.
We have not practiced after school this week. The problem is we had a lot of English homework, and that took priority over playing. Boy, are we cool. I’m growing more and more convinced that to be a successful musician, you need to be a slacker at everything else.
When Justin calls me, I jump into action. I’m tuning up my guitar as he straggles in. He looks like a cranky baby who’s just awoken from a nap. He’d just arrived at the South Ferry platform to go home after walking from his grandfather’s house on the Lower East Side. At the platform, Danilo had called him, and so Justin turned around and headed to my house in Greenwich Village.
Laid Low by Dodgeball
I call Matt. “Dude,” I greet him, “we’re playing today.”
“I can’t,” he moans. There’s a long pause. “I really hurt my arm playing dodgeball yesterday and I can’t strum.”
“Your arm!” My voice rises to a manic scream. Just then, Danilo calls my house.
“All right, I’m ready,” he announces.
I take a deep breath and explain to him the unique situation of our lead guitarist.
“Are you kidding?” he says. “There’s no point in having a band if this is going to happen.”
Drama Getting in the Way
I have Matt on my cell phone, asking what Danilo’s saying, and Danilo on my home phone, saying that the band is over. I relay his message to Matt. Matt gets mad. They’re speaking to me at the same time. I try to push the phones together, but they can’t hear each other.
I’m tired of hearing them. I feel like the more worked up Matt and Danilo get, the farther and farther away the day will be when our band takes the stage.
Finally, Matt declares that everyone is overreacting and Danilo says again that there’s no point in having a band. Then they both hang up. I’m left with an angry Justin, a thumping headache and no band.
Such is the life of a rock and roll star. Extreme highs and extreme lows and a whole lotta drama. Regardless, I’m now officially discouraged. I’m pretty sure this incident will blow over, but the image I’ve had of us onstage has now been replaced by a brawl over something stupid. How can we play onstage, if we can’t even get along?
Saturday, November 30, 3:00 p.m.
The band is back together again. Matt talked to Danilo, who said that he wasn’t mad and that I blew things out of proportion. Just like so many great bands before us, we’ve weathered a storm and come out united by music.
We’re in the studio again, this time working on Nirvana’s “Aneurysm,” as well as perfecting “Spanish Manzana.” The mood is light because we’ve made enough jokes about the breakup of the band and dodgeball that it’s old hat for us now. And we’re making progress.
But trying out for the Battle of the Bands is off. Everything that we’ve been working for over the past month has been put off until next year. We just didn’t have enough time to practice frequently, so we decided that it was better to chicken out than to sound like complete fools.
Aiming for Spring
We hope to do the school’s spring talent show instead. We want to play “Back in the U.S.S.R,” by the Beatles, and have Oleg, a new student from Russia, sing.
I’d hoped to be onstage in a few days, with the first successful show of our long and glorious career. I’m not that upset, though. My rock and roll dreams are still alive; they’re just in hibernation at the moment.
I’m confident that we’ll play for a crowd at some point. Plus, at the talent show, we’ll be going up against little 6th grade girls dancing to Britney Spears instead of competing against polished bands. We might win.
I’m patiently dreaming, and hoping that Oleg’s voice sounds better when he’s performing onstage than when he hums Phil Collins songs, tunelessly, at lunch.
The Making and Breaking of the Band
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.