Justin Does a Jackson

N SYNC. Britney Spears. O-Town. These are the mass-produced, company-regulated pop acts who’ve drawn criticism from music reviewers, music fans, and real musicians. They rely on a catchy hook (“I’m a slaaaa-aaave for you”), hip-hop influenced beats, and a massive crew of producers to make their sound MTV-ready. Their lyrics and music are generally cliched and uninspired, but hey, they look good and can dance.
Enter Justin Timberlake, the front man of ‘N SYNC and fantasy of every other female under 18. On his new solo release Justified, some might expect the same tired, mass-market ‘N SYNC sound.
Yet, surprisingly, the heavy-handed, over-the-top pop numbers don’t prevail. This is a pop record, but to my amazement, a surprisingly solid one.
In Tune With Neptunes
In terms of originality, Justified doesn’t explore the far reaches of the music world; it’s almost an r&b album, and sometimes tries to overpower you with hip-hop beats. (The appearance of the Clipse and Bubba Sparxxx feels forced.) But the album is backed by quality production, catchy lyrics and more than adequate vocals from Timberlake.
The Neptunes tag team of Pharrell Williams and Chad Hugo, who’ve become a staple of Billboard’s weekly Top Ten, contribute their uncontrollably danceable beats.
Their appealing “Se–orita” opens up the album, and smoothly transitions into the first single, “Like I Love You,” which has bodies doing the moonwalk again. Here, Timberlake sounds like an MTV Say What? Karaoke winner with his on-point Michael Jackson delivery.
Ends With Sappy Ballad
The Neptunes also bring in ’80s new wave/’70s soul-influenced production on “Nothin’ Else,” which feels like it belongs on a VH1 ’80s-era retrospective. “Rock Your Body”‘s disco rhythm and the lullaby-like “Take It From Here” are welcome mellow breaks from the faster songs, but “Let’s Take a Ride” and “Last Night” have formulaic rhythms and a weak delivery from Timberlake.
Hip-hop impresario Timbaland alternates with the N.E.R.D. crew on production credits; his contributions fit the album’s flow. The whistles and drumbeats of “(Oh No) What You Got” and the engaging piano work and beatboxing of “Cry Me a River” make them club friendly.
Unfortunately, to close off the album, Timberlake enlists the aid of Brian McKnight on “Never Again,” a drawn-out, sappy ballad perfect for soft-rock or adult contemporary radio stations.
The main weakness of the album lies in its repetitive themes. “Hey girl; I like you; Let’s dance; Why’d you dump me?” are predictable ideas that dominate. (Teenybopper magazines that still focus on his breakup with Britney should have a field day with this material.)
A New MJ
Yet, despite its flaws, Justified is still fun, because it doesn’t take itself too seriously. Moments of tenderness are quickly replaced by playful outbursts, head-nodding beats, and Timberlake’s high pitched, Michael Jackson-esque falsetto and tone.
Timberlake has followed Jackson’s tried-and-true formula of overproduced dance numbers balanced with ballads, which has fueled the idea that Timberlake is merely a White boy trying to be Black like Jackson. (Of course, that doesn’t say much considering Jackson’s “whiter” than anyone nowadays.)
But in light of Jackson’s recent work, maybe, in a strange twist, Timberlake has MJ’s act down better than the gloved one himself.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.