The soundtrack is one of Holly-wood’s most popular ways of marketing a film. Executives attempt to tie in a film to a radio-friendly single that’ll send listeners in droves to theaters and record stores, with the catchy song ringing in their ears.
But soundtracks are often made up of only one or two good songs, with the rest of the album containing mediocre tracks that have little, if anything, to do with the film’s plot.
The Brown Sugar soundtrack follows this formula to some extent, but is also a pretty solid compilation. Following the main theme of the film-rediscovering one’s love for hip-hop-the album varies from soulful grooves to fast-paced beats, from smooth vocals to hard rhymes. It strikes a balance between neo-soul and alternative hip-hop that generally works.
Bounce With Badu and Common
The album starts off strong, buoyed by the strength of the second track, the infectious first single, “Love of My Life.” Erykah Badu’s Billie Holiday-esque voice smoothly blends with the catchy beat and Common’s relaxed rhymes.
From there, Angie Stone takes us to church with her gospel-tinged “Bring Your Heart,” which fits the album’s flow. Angie’s contribution features a sample of “Ain’t Under-standing Mellow,” originally by Jerry Butler, formerly of the ’60s soul group The Impressions.
The soulful hooks on the r&b songs stand out more prominently than some of the rhymes, which is curious considering that the main theme of the film is hip-hop appreciation. Yet it does remind us that old-school soul has a tremendous influence on hip-hop.
‘Like a Nice Glass of Lemonade’
Among the best soul offerings are Jill Scott’s relaxing “Easy Conversation,” which goes down like a nice glass of lemonade on a warm summer day. R&b crooner Rahsaan Patterson’s “You Make Life So Good” is catchy and appealing, with his Raphael Saadiq-like delivery. And Cassandra Wilson’s gentle, slower-paced rendition of “Time After Time” does Cyndi Lauper justice.
But “Never Been,” by hip-hop soul queen Mary J. Blige, is only satisfactory with its laidback Missy Elliott production and dull rhythm that wastes the sample of “Why Oh Why.” And newcomer Jully Black’s “You Changed” gets tossed into the mediocre-song-on-a-soundtrack bin with its simplistic beat and lyrics.
And let’s not forget the hip-hop. From the lyricist fan’s perspective, there are few out there who can flow as well as Mos Def, a scene stealing co-star in the film who dominates the soundtrack with four contributions: three versions of “Brown Sugar” (enlisting the aid of Faith Evans and Black Star partner Talib Kweli), and “Breakdown,” which he performs as Chris V, the funny cab-driving rhymer from the movie.
Wanted More Old-School
Though Mos is a gifted lyricist, it would’ve been better to hear from a larger variety of rhymers. Since a prevailing theme in the film is old-school hip-hop, the producers of the album should’ve incorporated more old-school rappers into the mix.
Where’s Slick Rick or Doug E. Fresh? Listeners could’ve had a better contrast between the raw beginnings of hip-hop and the more slick sounds of now.
To find a hint of that true, unadulterated flavor on the album, check out Eric B. and Rakim’s extended remix of “Paid in Full,” a classic that’ll keep heads bobbing.
The Roots remix of “Love of My Life,” without Badu and Common, also has a bouncy, head-nodding groove, as does Blackalicious’ “It’s Going Down.” They create an alternative hip-hop vibe that strays far from the hardcore rap soundtracks out there (i.e., DMX’s Exit Wounds).
For people who enjoy the film, Brown Sugar is worth a listen, with beats that don’t overpower you and a consistent rhythm and pace. And you don’t need to see the movie to dig the soundtrack.
Sweet Soul on Sugar Soundtrack
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.