Thoughtful Rap Takes Root

“That’s not real music,” proclaimed my father one day as I played De La Soul’s Three Feet High and Rising. “That hip-hop, rap garbage, it’s just nonsense with all that cursing and shouting. Now AC/DC, Black Sabbath, that’s real music.”
I nodded, just to avoid an argument, and left for Central Park for my first hip-hop concert, the best four hours of rap garbage I’d ever heard.
Hip-hop hasn’t always been part of my life. Growing up, I usually listened to what my parents played at home. Mom preferred ’70’s pop fare like Engelbert Humperdinck and the Bee Gees, while Dad blasted classic rock records like Led Zeppelin’s ZoSo and the Beatles’ White Album.
Regarded Rap as Noise
Hearing this eclectic mix, I became open to different types of music, except for rap.
Rap was regarded as “noise,” a loud, boomingly offensive music that my parents couldn’t tolerate.
As an obedient elementary school kid, I went along with my parents’ condemnations. And it didn’t help that most stories I saw and heard in the media linked hip-hop to the downfall of our culture.
But that didn’t bother some of my peers. When I was in 5th grade, my friends imitated their older siblings and friends and got into the gangsta-rap wave of Snoop Dogg, NWA, and Ice Cube. Yet I couldn’t identify with the image, violence and anger these acts reflected.
Those artists, despite their claims to be “keeping it real,” appeared fake to me. I couldn’t understand why they celebrated the thug lifestyle rather than talk about changing it.
Discovered Alternative Hip-Hop
Then, somewhere between hitting puberty and noticing how amazing the opposite sex could be, I heard alternative hip-hop for the first time.
I was bored one night, trying to get over writer’s block. So I was messing around with my radio dial, looking for inspiration.
Suddenly this soft, eloquent beat flooded my ears. It was the Roots “What They Do,” a sharp, verbal barb that challenges materialistic rap.
“The principles of true hip-hop have been forsaken/ It’s all contractual, and about money making/ Pretend-to-be cats don’t seem to know their limitations/ Exact replication and false representation,” rhymes Black Thought. His words captured exactly how I felt about the “gangsta” image.
After hearing that song, I opened myself up to hip-hop and discovered there was an alternative to all the verbal gunplay and drugs. I started looking on the Internet and in record stores for artists without mainstream images. I discovered acts like the Coup, Digable Planets, Common and Black Star.
Reality Outside ‘Bling Bling’
But the Roots were my mainstay. By listening to such Roots classics as Do You Want More?!!!??! and Illadelph Halflife, I saw hip-hop could be intelligent lyrically and balanced out by beatboxing and live instrumentation. Rap could be fun, but also maintain a reality outside the realm of “bling, bling” and sex.
In interviews, some of these artists talked about their influences. So I began to do research on the funk, soul and old-school hip-hop artists they mentioned.
I listened to musicians ranging from A Tribe Called Quest to Miles Davis, De La Soul to Parliament Funkadelic, D’Angel to Donny Hathaway.
And I began to appreciate the music of my parents more than ever. The intelligent storytelling of alternative hip-hop led me to appreciate the songwriting of people like Stevie Wonder, James Taylor and Jim Croce.
But my parents still don’t get that hip-hop music is a reflection of the culture of the times, and just like rap doesn’t appeal to them, rock didn’t appeal to their parents’ generation.
I’m happy that they’ve at least acknowledged that hip-hop is more than just a fad. But more importantly, I’m free to listen to what I want.
Roots in Central Park
So, on a warm Sunday afternoon, sunlight beating down on me in a crowd of hundreds, there I was, getting ready to see the Roots live.
I was surprised to see such a diverse group of people: fresh-faced-or drunk-college kids, families, pot-smokers, and people who seemed more likely to be seen at a Christian evangelist gathering-in conservative clothing and crucifixes-than at a hip-hop concert.
The DJ blasted Al Green and Aretha Franklin between sets, with the crowd singing along. Lyricist Talib Kweli was host, with powerful r&b vocalist Amel Larrieux and hardcore rhymers Boot Camp Clik and Cannibal Ox opening up.
Then the crowd surged into a joyous uproar when the Roots stormed the stage, breaking into new works like “Thought at Work” and classics like “You Got Me.” The beatboxing talents of Rahzel and Scratch left me in awe.
Common joined the Roots on “Act Too (The Love of My Life).” Then newcomer Cody Chesnutt gave the crowd a taste of his funky rock.
With their fusion of rap, soul, funk, rock and jazz, the performances showed just how far hip-hop has come in bringing together different genres. In a fitting end to the night, political rap group Dead Prez ran onstage in a surprise performance, revitalizing the throng of concertgoers.
Prez launched into “Hip Hop,” which discusses how real-world issues overshadow hip-hop culture.
‘Bigger Than Hip-Hop’
Hearing Prez dispense their wisdom, I couldn’t understand how anyone could regard hip-hop as disposable music. It’s a culture, a music that’s progressing, a legitimate form of expression that can provoke change.
The concert’s closing chant reflected this idea. “It’s bigger than hip-hop, hip-hop,” proclaimed concertgoers with the packed stage of lyricists, soul singers, and rock musicians. After seeing people of different racial, social and economic backgrounds all singing in unison, I couldn’t agree more.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.