Journey Through Heartsongs took me on a melancholy, depressing trip. Journey is one of a string of Heartsongs books by Mattie J.T. Stepanek, an ailing 11-year-old boy who’s battling a rare form of muscular dystrophy. The disease took the lives of his three older siblings, and he’s the last child in his family.
Mattie’s story and his books of poetry have gotten a lot of media coverage, and the books are bestsellers. He and Oprah are apparently “very special friends,” and Mattie’s poems have won the praises of former U.S. president Jimmy Carter.
I was curious to see what the hoopla was about, since the boy’s only 11. After reading the book, though, I think sorrow is clouding people’s judgment of what’s good literature.
Writes Like a Child
What makes a good poem is a verse or a stanza that stays in the heart and mind. The bulk of the poems in Journey didn’t do that for me. Mattie writes well for someone his age, but he’s no Countee Cullen or even Dr. Seuss.
His poems don’t feel particularly deep. Then again, I don’t believe anyone is a great poet at the age of 11.
Mattie’s writing is cute and touching, but it’s also juvenile. “When I grow up,/ I think maybe/ I will be a snowman,” he writes. Other poems are little more than statements of the rough life he’s lived as a child battling a disease.
My opinion, which is probably highly unpopular, is that this young man is being peddled because he’s a sick child. People feel sympathy for sick children. I doubt so many people would be buying the Heartsongs books had it not been for his illness.
But I can’t say that Mattie’s words didn’t move me. Reading Journey, I felt a great sadness that any small boy would have to come to terms with his own mortality, the death of those that he loved, and the pain of waking up each day with a debilitating disease. Knowing that his life is fleeting he writes with an appreciation for the life that he’s lived and whatever future he believes God sees fit for him.
One Poem Touched Me Deeply
No other work in poetry or fiction has made me as painfully heartbroken as Mattie’s poem “The Left-Over Child.” To say that Mattie’s words touched me would be an understatement. About himself, Mattie writes, “Now, he’s not really a little brother anymore,/ But he’s not really the only child either./ Mattie is the left-over child,/ All alone with the parents of dead children.”
Mattie never met the first of his two siblings, but remembers the third child born. I can’t even imagine what that must feel like.
Mattie’s Remarkable Courage
At times he thinks about his death, occasionally looking forward to heaven or missing his earthly life, but he never seems to dread it. Together, his poems weave a tale of an afterlife that’s more beautiful than the life he’s leading, where he’ll rejoin those he’s lost over the years.
I guess it’s better to have a positive view of death than to fear it and think that death’s the end. But it’s still sad that someone so young lives with death hanging over him.
So while Stepanek may not be the Picasso of poetry, Journey is probably one of the more interesting autobiographies that I’ve read. Journey gives a glimpse into the life of an 11-year-old who’s suffered more than anyone should have to go through in 10 lifetimes.
I only wish I possessed a fraction of the strength and courage that Mattie holds. It’s because of that, not his writing, that makes me think he is remarkable. And I guess that’s the quality that others see as well.
Journey’s Moving, But Not Deep
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.