Sorting Through Mixed Messages

We can’t escape it. Every day we are overwhelmed with images and words that supposedly tell us about ourselves and the world we live in. But the messages we get aren’t always helpful.
I recently joined a girls’ media group at the Global Action Project, which encourages young women to critique the media we see and hear and explore expressing ourselves through different forms of media. Participating in the group has forced me to pay more attention to the media’s messages. I’ve had a lot of revelations, some of which quite disturb me.
For one, the media sends us many mixed messages. As Rasheeda Raji points out in “Not a Pretty Picture” (p. 3), teen magazines have a few serious articles meant to empower their readers, but then fill other pages with images that help them feel inadequate.
But that’s not such a surprise when you consider the role money plays. I’ve learned that if you want to know a company’s motivations, find out where and how they’re making a profit. Rasheeda explains the topic imbalance in girls’ magazines by suggesting that publishers want their readers to buy the makeup and products of their advertisers.
And Lucas Hartstone-Rose mentions in his article, “Bad News” (p. 10), how news publishers and corporate owners are mainly concerned with what stories sell, which affects what they put on their front pages.
I’ve also learned that there’s often a difference between what the media presents and real life. When a plane crashes in Sharon Feder’s neighborhood, she witnesses the media in action and describes what she sees in “Reporters on My Lawn” (p. 5). She’s dismayed by how some reporters seemed to only care about their stories and surprised at how different a reporter could act depending on whether she’s off or on camera.
Abanty Farzana gets her reality check when she’s at The Ananda Lewis Show (p. 12), where she spends seven hours with little food or water just to tape two hour-long shows. She’s starved, bored and tired, but still has to stand and clap whenever the crew tells her to.
It may seem hopeless to try to change the media. But there are ways, as Allajah Young reminds us in”Bentleys, Booties and Big Pimpin'” (p. 14). She’s fed up with the lack of originality in hip-hop music videos and suggests that viewers with the same problem write letters of complaint to video shows.
It’s also important to remember that the media’s impact doesn’t always have to be negative. We have the power to change it and the way it affects us. For me, being a writer at NYC has allowed me to express my own ideas and learn from others by receiving feedback from editors and readers.
It’s up to us to distinguish our realities from the world of media. We can lessen the control that it has over us and instead use the media to our own advantage.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.