With help, advocates say, more women could leave abusive relationships
There are lots of reasons why women don’t leave abusive relationships. Sometimes they’re emotional reasons, like they love their man, or they’ve never been on their own. Other times the reasons are more practical, like they’re afraid of what he’ll do if they leave, or they have no place to go.
And the reality is that even when people who are being battered are emotionally ready to leave, it can be incredibly hard to. The statistics prove the point. Approximately four women are killed by their husbands or boyfriends every day, according to the National Woman Abuse Prevention Project. And studies find that women who are trying to leave are at a much greater risk of being killed than women who stay.
Whatever the reasons for women staying, it can hurt their kids. “The helplessness their kids feel watching the violence creates a lot of problems as they grow up,” said Sally MacNichol, a domestic violence advocate.
Some kids who witness domestic violence turn to drugs, others become depressed and even suicidal. Some become victims of their own abusive relationships, while others hate that feeling of helplessness so much that they become abusive themselves, Ms. MacNichol said. One of the saddest fallouts of children watching violence in the home are the large numbers of young men now behind bars because they stood up to their mother’s abuser, and either killed or seriously injured him, she added.
But though everyone agrees that watching violence hurts, not everyone agrees how to protect kids from it. Some people believe that if mothers won’t or can’t get out of violent relationships, their kids should be taken out of those situations for them and put into foster care. But many domestic violence activists say that it’s better to work with moms to help them grow stronger and decide for themselves how to handle the situation. They say that way, families can be kept together. They add that if they had more and better programs in schools and community centers, counselors could work with children too.
“It would be possible to give kids more responsibility to decide when to say, ‘I know how to handle this,’ and when to say, ‘I want to get out,'” said Alyssa Del Toufo, who runs the Urban Justice Center’s Anti-Violence Project and works with Ms. MacNichol.
But even Ms. Del Toufo admits that there are dangers to doing things this way. While a mother is trying to figure out how to handle her situation, children can end up feeling overwhelmed, powerless, lost and alone. And sometimes the violence can get so out of hand that someone gets killed.
Like the politicians and the activists making public policy, it’s clear from the pages of this issue that those of us who read and work at FCYU don’t all agree on what should happen to protect kids in a home with domestic violence. There are some things, though, that can help.
In 1997, a New York state commission on domestic violence found that 57 homicides could have been prevented that year if the police and other authorities had provided greater protection to domestic violence victims.
Ms. Del Toufo and Ms. Nicholson are currently working with one precinct in East Harlem in New York to see that all victims of domestic violence get connected to a support network within 24 hours of filing a police report. They’d like to see that all victims of domestic violence receive that kind of support when their case comes to the attention of the police.
There should also be more places for women and their children to go if they leave their homes. There are approximately l,200 shelters in the United States for battered women and their children, but that isn’t enough. “Every day, many women and children are turned away,” said Ms. MacNichol. It can be particularly hard for women with teenage sons and for women who have drug problems to find a place to live. Between 20% and 50% of all homeless women and children in this country are fleeing domestic violence.
So while the debate continues over what to do for kids whose mothers won’t leave abusive relationships, one thing that’s clear is that we should be doing more for women who are ready to make a change. That will help us, their children, too.
-Reporting by Merli Desrosier
S.O.S. for Moms
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.