As a Janet fan, I constantly defend her talent. People always tell me, “She can’t sing.”
But there’s more to performing than holding a note for several seconds. Watching Janet isn’t as dull as watching Whitney or Mariah. Janet can dance, act and carry a tune reasonably well, and those factors have helped define her popularity.
Unfortunately, my girl has fallen off. Janet Jackson’s late April release, All For You, her first in four years, is disappointingly mediocre.
The album’s melodies aren’t as catchy as classic hits like “The Pleasure Principle” from Control, or “I Get Lonely” from The Velvet Rope, or “Love Will Never Do” from Rhythm Nation.
And lyrically, All For You shows little variety, with most songs dealing with sex or a no-good man.
Most Booty-Shakers Since Rhythm Nation
The best thing about her newest offering is that many of the tracks make me want to dance. Janet hasn’t produced an album with as many booty-shakers since 1989’s Rhythm Nation. Along with the two singles “Doesn’t Really Matter” and “All For You,” I enjoy “Come on Get Up.”
Its upbeat rhythm sounds like old Janet, while the lyrics maintain the newer, more erotic Janet. Listeners may be uncertain whether she’s talking about sex or dancing when she sings, “Come on get up/ Before you make me change my mind.”
Her All For You musical persona is similar to the one she donned in the early ’90s, when she transformed her image from a tough girl into a sexy woman.
Throughout the past decade, this side of Janet has been slowly manifesting, as seen through her tattoos, piercings, pushed-up breasts and raunchy lyrics.
Brazenly Sings of Sex
All For You is her most sexual offering ever, with lines like “Got a nice package alright/ Guess I’m gonna have to ride it tonight” on the title track. And “Would You Mind” (“I’m gonna kiss you/ Suck you/ Taste you/ Ride you/ Feel you/ Make you come too”) brazenly describes intercourse.
Her lustful lines aren’t appropriate for listeners in their early teens and younger, and others may find them offensive.
Even though Janet has the right to sing and write whatever she wants, I do wish she’d diversified her subject matter more. With so many tracks on her album continually referring to sex, I’ve started to wonder if that rumor about her being a sex fiend has some truth to it.
Carly Simon ‘Raps’
Other songs have a more vengeful tone. Janet samples Carly Simon’s oldie “You’re So Vain” on the hip-hop/soul track “Son of a Gun.” Janet’s no-nonsense as she busts a “baby gigolo,” letting him know she’s onto his game.
The melody’s catchy but Carly’s rhymes and her repetitive line “clouds in my coffee” do nothing for the song.
Janet unsuccessfully experiments with a few effects, such as her electronically distorted voice on “You Ain’t Right,” and the Carly Simon “rap,” but has held onto her interesting, sometimes out-of-place interludes.
Janet Sounds More Fragile
She also gives us that playful laugh she’s managed to fit in every album since 1986’s Control.
And, even though long-time producers Jimmy Jam and Terry Lewis create melodies that her voice can handle, Janet sounds more fragile than usual. Perhaps it’s due to her attempts to sound so sexy.
I hope Ms. Jackson goes back into the studio and creates another album soon because All For You isn’t going to be sufficient for Janet fans for another four years. Hopefully, she’ll sing more about her experiences outside the bedroom.
A Nasty Ms. Jackson On All For You
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.