Send This Valentine Back

In the early ’90s, the world of horror was as dead as one of Freddy Krueger’s punch lines. Then came forth Kevin Williamson and he wrote Scream and the masses said this was good. For once, the kids knew they were in a horror film. The characters had sarcastic charm, and the film put them in situations that were truly scary.
But after Scream, the flood gates opened to cheap, self-conscious horror such as Urban Legend, I Know What You Did Last Summer and the rest of the Scream franchise. (Stop kidding yourself; they sucked.)
Now comes Valentine, a film so cheesy it could’ve been made by Velveeta. While in commercials it looks cool and starts out promising, looks are deceiving.
Dissed at the Dance
The movie’s start resembles the film Carrie. A young, stuttering boy named Jeremy “the pervert” Melton (as he’s called by his classmates), asks various girls to dance.
As each girl rejects him, we see a picture of her as an adult. The poor kid finally gets a girl to dance with him, when-shock!-something horrible happens to him. We later learn he was put in a mental ward and hasn’t been seen since he was 18.
Cut to the present day. One of the girls, Shelly, is alone, studying for a test, when she meets our killer. The first slaying is usually scary and creative in this kind of horror film, but this murder is dumb. It’s almost like Shelly runs into the knife.
This scene highlights the film’s biggest problem. The situations we’re supposed to believe are so out there, I wanted to yell, “Come on!” It’s silly, but played straight, so there’s no fun in it. The film should’ve either run with the idea of parody or tried to build realistic tension, but it did neither.
Characters Are Cardboard
We meet the rest of the characters at Shelly’s funeral. They’re all cardboard creations. Kate (Marley Shelton) is sweet and perky, Paige (Denise Richards) is a sex kitten, Lily (Jessica Cauffiel) is the so-called funny one, and Dorothy (Jessica Capshaw) is labeled the “fat one.”
Calling her fat when she’s only a little chubby is totally uncalled for. How typical that in Hollywood, if you’re not 20 pounds underweight, you’ll be typecast.
We also meet Detective Vaughan (Fulvio Cecere) who gives the best performance as a sarcastic cop. When someone asks if he has a more recent picture of Melton, he cracks back, “Don’t you think we would be using it if we did?” He’s so on point it’s like he’s in another film.
Not Enough Boreanaz
Unfortunately, it’s still Valentine, and soon the ladies get threatening valentines with the initials JM, and chocolates with bugs in them. They start suspecting each other’s boy-friends.
The boyfriends are pretty slimy expect for Adam (David Boreanaz, from the TV series Angel), Kate’s boyfriend. He gives off some of the easygoing charm I’ve seen in interviews.
But while he’s billed as a major player in ads, he’s only in the film for 15 minutes. As a huge fan of Angel, this is a big disappointment to me.
The film feels a lot longer than its 90 minutes as the characters are pretty much killed at random. This film exists in B.S. (before Scream) time, as stupid characters don’t take basic actions to protect themselves.
Boring Mood Killer
The film mangles a decent concept, because vengeance is an interesting motive to explore. The plot builds few obvious connections between the past and the present; most were barely noticeable and didn’t occur to me until later.
There are a few funny moments in the film, like Adam riffing on his girlfriend’s creepy neighbor, who she says has been stealing her underwear from her laundry in the basement.
With a straight face, Adam says, “Oh no, it’s me. They make me feel free,” and then starts laughing. It gives the movie a much needed sense of relief, but these moments are few.
Valentine is a waste of time for anyone looking for something scary, and a mood killer if you’re trying to take your valentine to something fun. So if anyone sends you this valentine, please send it back unopened. You’ll be happy you did.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.