I’m a former opera singer, and proud of it. Opera changed my life and the way I look at the world, but at one point it wasn’t something I was willing to share with people because I was too embarrassed. I was a secret opera man, hiding my pre-teen passion from my friends.
My career started in 4th grade when I joined my school chorus upstate in Monticello, NY. One day, my chorus master approached me about an opportunity.
She told me a friend of hers was the chorus master for the New York City and Metropolitan Opera’s children’s choruses. She asked if I’d be interested in trying out.
Fat Female Vikings?
I was stunned. Opera! I’d never thought about that before. I thought opera was only about fat women in Viking costumes singing high notes in front of fake-looking sets.
But I told her that I was interested because, even though I had my doubts, I was secretly intrigued. I wanted to know what it’d be like to be onstage in front of so many people and sing. I wanted to see how a professional theater worked.
My dad brought me to the New York City Opera at Lincoln Center. I met several members of the children’s chorus and sat in on rehearsal with them.
Then, Ms. Horner, the chorus director, had me and another kid who was auditioning sing “America the Beautiful” and “Happy Birthday.” When we were through, she told us to wait outside while she decided if we were in.
I Got In
The minute I spent waiting was one of the longest minutes in my life. Opera didn’t excite me yet, but I didn’t want to fail a tryout and let down my chorus master. I sat in silence with the other kid until Ms. Horner came out.
“You’re both in,” she said. I breathed a sigh of relief. I didn’t want to be a failure. I couldn’t wait to tell my parents or myâ friends?!?
It hit me: I was an opera singer. What would I tell my friends? No kid I knew considered opera cool. I might as well say I’d become a yodeler. Chorus was one thing, but opera?
I thought my friends would think I was a sissy since many kids don’t consider opera to be a “manly” occupation. And if they ever saw me on stage, I was sure I’d die.
My Voice Made Me Self-Conscious
I was a high alto, a girl’s voice, and that made me self-conscious. I could just imagine my friends sitting in the audience and laughing when I’d sing, calling out, “Jon’s a girl.” I convinced myself that telling them meant certain ridicule.
When I got home, I told my mom I’d gotten in. She was happy and told me how proud she was. I felt a bit better about being in the opera.
My mom recognizing my talent made me happy, since, at the time, I waited for someone else’s compliments to feel good about myself. That’s why I was so worried about being rejected by my friends.
I was also insecure about school since I was the new kid there. I’d moved only a year before from Brooklyn, and I didn’t have the kind of trust with my new friends as I had with people I’d known my whole life. I felt like an outsider and I figured that exposing my secret would make me feel even more alienated.
I told only my best friend that I’d joined the opera. He thought it was cool and wanted to tell other people, but I made him promise he wouldn’t and he respected my wishes.
Fun Despite Shame
So every Tuesday in 5th grade, I’d leave school early and my dad would drive me two hours into the city for rehearsal. I told people I had business to attend to, but I didn’t go into specifics.
Despite my shame in school, I had fun at rehearsals. I enjoyed going to the city and getting away from country life. I also made friends at the opera, becoming especially close with Nigel and Ray, two other members of the children’s chorus.
When I would walk up to the security desk at the entrance and sign my name in the log book, I felt powerful, important. It was like I was part of the “in” crowd, which was unlike my experience at school.
But I felt torn between my life in the opera and my life outside it. When I was inside the opera house, I felt strong, but away from it, I felt like a loser for being an opera singer.
I was living in two very different worlds, straddling their borders, and I didn’t want to pull my foot out of either one. I didn’t realize that it might be possible for those worlds to mix.
My Friends Never Found Out
At the end of 5th grade, I moved back to the city and started going to a new elementary school. My old friends never found out about the opera. Even though I was glad my secret was safe, I wished I had felt comfortable enough with them to share my Lincoln Center experiences.
That year, I got my first parts in two shows: Carmen and Tosca. Carmen became my favorite opera to be in because the music was upbeat and there were plenty of fun props, like dulled-down knives.
I did the show several times over the years. The children’s chorus was in the first and fourth acts; between appearances, the other kids and I played games downstairs and ran around the maze-like hallways.
New School, Old Secret
After the season ended that year (fall and spring seasons run about two to three months each), I kept in touch with Ray and Nigel by talking to them on the phone. I even went out to visit Nigel on Long Island a couple of times.
I also started to attend yet another new school after the break, the LAB school. I was still worried about how people would respond to my opera singing, so I kept it a secret.
When the new season began, I was cast in two new operas; Carmina Burana and Attila. I was happy that I’d be doing more performances, and I felt appreciated.
Getting positive feedback on my work made me feel secure. I started to get less strict about my secret and I told close friends. Then, something happened that revealed my secret to everyone.
Spilling the Beans at Lunch
One day, I accidentally said something about “my friend from the opera” when I was talking to some students in the LAB lunchroom. They were shocked.
“Opera?” they said with wide eyes and stunned faces. My secret was out! I felt like I was going to hyperventilate. I tried to think of ways to slip out of it, but nothing came to mind. So I just gave in and told them the whole story.
Surprisingly, they asked me questions about what it was like and the guys wanted to know how many “hot” girls there were.
Of course, after word got out, there were people who said stuff like “You castrated?” or “Hey, opera boy, how’s it hanging?” but for the most part, my friends encouraged my singing.
I Was Asked to Sing in School
And so did strangers. People I didn’t know were coming up to me in the halls and asking me to sing. It was a bit embarrassing since I didn’t want so much attention, but it was better than being ridiculed. I would usually just go, “Ah, I don’t want to,” and they would let it be.
One time, though, my friends wouldn’t leave me alone, so I broke down and sang something from Carmen. I hated it because I only liked to sing during performances or when it moved me, not at random. Still, after singing, they were like, “Oh, that’s so cool!”
After all the years of keeping life at the opera secret, I felt like a big weight had been lifted from my shoulders. I didn’t feel like I was lying to people about who I was anymore. I became more open and friendly, because I was less afraid of being teased.
I’d psyched myself out. I was so worried about what other people would think of me that I neglected to realize maybe they wouldn’t say anything at all. Finding out that being in the opera wasn’t such a big deal to other people made me feel stupid for feeling I needed to hide who I was.
Eventually, when my voice changed, I left the opera. And years later, I no longer feel the need to keep my old career secret. After dodging the truth, I learned that sometimes people build things up in their heads and make them bigger deals than they really are.
SIDEBAR: Opera: Behind the Scenes
Opera’s a complicated world, full of rehearsals, costumes and elaborate sets. And then there’s the hard work and the heartbreak, at least for children’s chorus members like me, of being too old to perform anymore. The first person I met at the opera was Ms. Horner, the director of the choir; she was a gray-haired woman in her 80s who wore large glasses and walked very slowly. She wore dull gray skirts with fully buttoned earth tone blouses that looked like they came off a 1955 rack. She talked in a loud, haughty voice that made me want to back 10 feet away for fear of going deaf. She frightened me and I became unsure of what to expect. I imagined her as the evil witch in the gingerbread house who lured Hansel and Gretel to their deaths. Her assistant, Tony Piccolo, was a more soft-spoken person, with silvery hair and bright blue eyes. He wanted to be a composer, but hadn’t gotten his big break yet. I liked him more than Ms. Horner since he didn’t seem so creepy.
Drinking Onstage
They introduced me to how the chorus worked and guided me during my time there. We rehearsed every Tuesday for two hours. Each show had separate rehearsal dates; sometimes they were just for the children’s chorus and other times included the orchestra or dancers. At rehearsals, we’d learn the choreography for the production, the movement around the set (blocking) and how to act based on the show’s time period. For instance, in Europe during the 1700s, it was acceptable for kids to drink. So when we did Carmen, which took place in that era, we’d bring jugs of liquor on stage and take drinks from them. (They were empty, though; remember, it’s a show.) Action! Opera employees were fairly easygoing, but when a performance rolled around, people kicked into high gear. So much time and effort goes into making a show go right. There are at least 50 people backstage at any time during a show, and the action on stage is tremendous. My first performance, which was Carmen, overwhelmed me. There were so many other singers and actors bustling around, it was hard to move. I had to make it to my singing spot at just the right time, so I shoved through several people to get to the front. When I did, I was astonished. The audience was huge. There were thousands of people looking at me, and when I sang my first note, I nearly fainted. I felt alone even though there were so many people around me, including other kids from the chorus. A fat baritone in a dazzlingly sequined costume chimed in after every line the children’s chorus sang, and his voice was so booming that he was probably louder than all of us put together. When I wasn’t singing, I was unsure what to do.
Survivng My Nervousness
We had to stay onstage for only five minutes, but it seemed like an eternity. I couldn’t talk and I was directed to act excited and happy, but I was nervous. I survived though, and the next time on stage was a little easier, until I finally felt comfortable. I sang with the chorus for 3_ years, and over that time, Ms. Horner retired, Mr. Piccolo became the director, and I learned a lot about singing. I learned how to take better care of my voice by talking more quietly when I was in public and not eating foods like pizza or ice cream before a show. (Milk products create phlegm, which makes your voice sound hoarse.) I also learned how to get the most out of my notes by opening my mouth wider and sounding words out better by enunciating. I learned how to breathe while singing and how to sing to the audience. I couldn’t read music, though, so I’d learn my parts by listening. A Second Home Over time, my outlook on opera changed. What was once a job became a second home. I became aware of how professional theater works, the way sets are brought up in huge elevators backstage before a show, and how it takes several stage managers to give people their cues. Most of all, I learned the opera’s really one big community, working together to make something audiences can enjoy.
Aging Out
After about two years, however, I noticed that a lot of kids who’d been there when I started were no longer around. I talked with some singers who were there before I joined and they told me the kids who left had gotten too old to be in the children’s chorus anymore. I was frightened. Some of those kids were only a year older than me. I wanted to stay at the opera forever. For a while, I forgot about the age thing, but eventually I began to notice changes in my singing voice. It was getting harder for me to sing the higher parts in certain songs. I also grew several inches. At 11, I was 5’2″. By the time I turned 12, after my second season, I was 5’6″. I was getting taller than women in the adult chorus.
The End of the Road
The summer I turned 13, I grew two more inches. My voice got deeper too. I knew the end was near. I tried to make the most out of my last season. I worked my hardest and got more parts than ever. Mr. Piccolo said the quality of my work had risen. I was proud of comments like that, but I also knew that I wouldn’t be getting them much longer. So one week, in the middle of 8th grade and the end of the fall season, I made an appointment to see Mr. Piccolo. I told him I thought I was getting too big to be in the opera anymore, that my voice was getting lower every day and I soon wouldn’t be able to sing the parts. He agreed. I figured it was better to go out on top rather than when I was over the hill. I thanked him for being so kind to me and he thanked me for all my work. I had to leave a place I loved, but I realized how lucky I was to have been there at all.
