“Girlfight” Packs a Punch

Ben: Hello, I’m Ben and this is Melissa and we’re reviewing Girlfight together.
Melissa: Girlfight is the story of Diana Guzman, a high school tomboy played by Michelle Rodriguez. She decides to take up boxing, but faces discrimination because she’s female in a traditionally male sport.
Ben: I’ll say straight off that we both liked the movie.
Melissa: You end up cheering Diana as she climbs her way to being the best female boxer there is.
Ben: Being a male who isn’t very athletic at all, I have nothing bad to say about girls fighting. In fact I’m all for it. Me, I’d pick sweaty girls duking it out in the ring over sweaty guys any day. Diana may be a tomboy, but what a hottie.
Melissa: The way Michelle Rodriguez portrays Diana, she makes me believe she’s a real bad ass, especially the way her face looks twisted in anger as she cusses someone.
But she shows Diana as sensitive, too. It takes a lot of talent to pull something like that off. It’s like Rodriguez is playing two characters.
Ben: I agree that Rodriguez fit the part perfectly. Just watching her get that crazed, determined look in her eyes when she’s about to let loose made me want to beat up her opponents, too.
Melissa: Around other people, Diana acts as though she’s untouchable, that nothing hurts her. But we start to see a different side of Diana when a young male boxer named Adrian, Diana’s love interest, comes into the picture. She’s comfortable around him, and starts to open up.
Ben: I feel that we see more of Diana’s feminine side when she’s around Adrian. She does little things like letting her hair down and wearing tank tops. It’s surprising at first because prior to that all we see is Diana acting tough and putting up a front.
Melissa: Why are you saying it like that? The girl has had a tough life. You shouldn’t judge her like everyone else does in the movie.
That’s probably why she hides her emotions from everyone; all the characters in the movie assume Diana is something that she isn’t. Take her dad for example. He wants her to be a lady and a housewife. That’s not her. She wants to be a boxer.
Ben: On the contrary, I back Diana all the way, and that’s why I won’t go easy on her. Diana just wants to be treated like everyone else. She faces sexism and prejudice but that just makes her determined to fight harder.
In fact, the most emotional scene in the movie for me is when Diana finally stands up to her father and lets him know how she feels about his mistreatment of her. I think most kids today can relate to parents who don’t understand them or just don’t treat them right.
Melissa: One of the things that struck me in the film is all the posters at the gym with positive sayings. “If you’re not in the ring training, someone else is there training to kick your ass,” says one poster. “Winners never quit and quitters never win,” is another of the many mottoes in the movie.
The signs seem ironic in a way, because while you’d think the signs would apply to everyone, a lot of the boxers don’t want Diana to train. It’s as if they don’t want Diana to pay attention to the signs. But she keeps on going despite what other people think.
Ben: I used to go to a karate school when I was younger, where the teacher told us, “Winners never quit and quitters never win.” It’s funny because right after I quit the class, I won a free Snapple in the Snapple contest.
But even though I don’t find these mottoes so inspiring, I still find it hard to say anything bad about a movie that is so positive and motivating.
Melissa: The movie overall is very good, especially because Diana never lets discrimination or her sex get in the way.
Ben: Sure, you may have seen this plot before: the determined fighter who beats the odds when everyone’s against him or her. But it’s done so well that you never lose interest in the film.
Melissa: The story reminds us all that this is what everyday underprivileged kids have to go through when we have no dreams to grasp.
I went through that same feeling when people would tell me I’m not smart enough to go to college. Now I see things differently. I know I’m smart and can make it in the world. You just need heart, which anybody can have, but it helps to be a real fighter, like Diana, to make it.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.