My Secret Love

I was born and raised in the Bronx, where I learned to walk and talk tough and spit with dignity and class. I know who to watch out for on the street, like dudes who carry liquor bottles and wear too much red. (There are a lot of gang members around my way.)
The way I dress reflects my neighborhood, so most people expect my taste in music to follow the same pattern. Bronx streets + Pelle Pelle jeans + cornrows + Timberlands = hard-core rap 24/7.
That’s partially true, because hip-hop is a major part of my life. But there’s also a hidden part of me. It’s not something I like to talk about, even if you paid me. If I did, people would laugh long and loud. It’s not easy for me to admit this, butâ
I love musicals.
Mary Poppins Is My Girl
Yep. The Sound of Music, The King and I, Carousel, West Side Story…you name it, I’ve seen and enjoyed it.
I like the emotions given off by musicals, the way the story and the songs blend together to make a single presentation filled with dancing and catchy show tunes. I like watching Mary Poppins fly around with an umbrella, singing about medicine going down nicely if you take sugar with it.
But you’re not listening. You’re too busy laughing at me. The way I began this story, you probably thought I had a drug problem. If I did, I would have gladly put my name on this article. No one would laugh at me if I was addicted to cocaine.
We Go Way Back
Musicals and I go way back. The Sound of Music was the first musical I saw, back in 6th grade. At first, it looked like the beginning of another boring “class thing.”
My teacher rolled the TV into the room, switched the lights off and let the show begin. I sighed and braced myself for what I thought would be the whackest 40 minutes of my 11 years.
But then, when the characters started singing, it suddenly became interesting to me. Characters would be talking about something, then they would just jump into song. As I watched the film, I realized I was being introduced to a revolutionary concept-a full-length movie that conveyed emotions through music and singing.
In one of the most memorable scenes, the main character, Maria (played by Julie Andrews), comforts the kids she is taking care of. The children are scared of a raging storm, so she begins to sing about her “favorite things” to take their minds off their fear.
I Got to Sing
A few weeks after the viewing, the entire school had to do renditions of various musical numbers on stage in the auditorium. My class had to sing “Sixteen Going on Seventeen” from The Sound of Music. One part was sung by the girls and the other part by the fellas. We did well, and my self-confidence never faltered during the performance.
But after my performance in 6th grade, I lost interest. My attention-span was really short when it came to new things. Musicals were the last thing on my mind until my senior year of high school.
My music teacher rekindled my interest. He showed flicks like Carousel and West Side Story to our class every week as examples of different kinds of music. The other kids didn’t appreciate it at all, but every day I secretly hoped he’d continue showing them.
My music teacher was gay and White, so admitting that he liked musicals didn’t hurt his reputation at all. I, on the other hand, wouldn’t be able to take the “Oh yeah, he’s gay too” stares I knew I would get if people knew my secret.
I Came Out
But one day at New Youth Connections, I took a chance and admitted that I had watched a few musicals.
“Come on, sing a show tune you know,” someone said.
“Yeah, don’t be shy.”
“Why not?” I said after a moment’s hesitation.
I attempted to repeat my stellar 6th grade performance in response to the earnest requests of my co-workers. So I started singing that still familiar song in a mock soprano voice.
“I am 16, going on 17, I know that I’m na•veâfellows I meet may tell me I’m sweet, and willingly I beleeeeiveâ”
(OK, so for some strange reason, I only remembered the girl’s part.)
Instead of applause for my attempt to bestow culture upon them, what followed was 10 minutes of uncontrollable laughter. And mocking. Ingrates.
Musicals and Music Videos
But really, what’s so bad about liking musicals? The music is catchy and you have visuals. They’re similar to the modern music video, but they differ because videos focus mainly on money, drugs, sex or violence in its rawest form. A lot of these topics are watered down in most musicals because they were made in the beginning and middle of the century, when things were less explicit.
But today’s teens can still relate to many of the messages that musicals convey, even if they are in Technicolor. For instance, in West Side Story, Officer Krupke pisses off the Jets gang royally. They want to go out and release their anger violently, which would’ve sent them straight to the slammer.
Instead, they perform a dance and song, “Cool,” which helps them control themselves and avoid getting arrested. (The Gap had a field day adapting the song for their khaki summer line.) It was similar to Michael Jackson’s “Beat It” video in terms of attitude and how they would lash out unexpectedly with a “Pow!” or “Bam!”
Even though musicals and music videos have many similarities, kids my age who come from the block would probably never allow themselves to appreciate show tunes unless they’re being sampled by Jay-Z or Busta Rhymes. The dudes in my neighborhood and high school are all about rap and r&b. They’d rather listen to rhymes in Japanese than take in alternative styles.
My Friend Has a Secret Too
There’s a Black kid I know who listens to Smashing Pumpkins, a rock band, all the time. But he doesn’t tell anyone. His peers ridiculed him into only expressing his affinity for alternative music to his closest friends. Unlike him, I’ve made no attempt to come out of my creative closet because I want to avoid derision.
But it’s still unfair. Just because I’m a rough Bronx cat who happens to like watching films where people abruptly break into song and dance shouldn’t automatically draw people to the conclusion that I’m a freak.
I don’t want to be the butt of jokes or to be looked at as pitiful. I don’t want people to say, “My life is messed up, but I’m better than the cat who likes musicals.”
I just don’t get it. If Jay-Z can use parts of Annie and Oliver in his rhymes, why can’t I sing songs from The King and I in peace?
I doubt I’ll ever come clean about my love for show tunes until I’m older and I don’t care what others think. As for my co-workers at NYC who have a swell time taunting me every time the memory of me singing pops into their heads, I just shake it off and keep ballin’.
In other words:
” . . . Breeze it, Buzz it, Easy does it . . . Just play it cool booooyyyyyyy.”

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.