Kicked to the Curb

On December 5, thousands of protesters gathered in Union Square to speak out against Mayor Giuliani’s plans to stop homeless people from sleeping in the streets and to force people who live in shelters to work in exchange for their beds. The demonstrators came out from all over the city to get the same point across: The plan is cruel and unfair.
The Coalition for the Homeless organized the rally and all-night vigil. Police officers were there to make sure to warn the protesters that if they lay down on the ground like homeless people, they would be arrested.
No Camping
At the rally were religious leaders, politicians, advocates for the homeless and homeless people themselves. At first they tried to speak calmly about the mayor’s policies. But soon everyone was shouting: “Go to hell, Rudy!” along with, “You are a coward and a racist, Giuliani,” and, “It is evil to cast the homeless into jails!”
The next day, another protest was held at City Hall. When I got there, at 6:05 p.m., exactly five minutes after the protest started, Al Sharpton and 10 other people had already been arrested. He and the others had been arrested for spreading tents and sitting down in City Hall park. The charge was “camping in a public place.”
Kicked Out of Shelters
In the past couple of months, Mayor Giuliani has been trying to drastically change the way New York City treats homeless people. His policies have made some people so mad they protested, and some were even willing to get arrested.
This is how the plan seems to work: First, people end up forced to live on the streets because the city does not do enough to provide low-income housing or beds for the mentally ill.
Next, they are told to go to shelters or move along, or they will be arrested for sleeping on the streets.
Then, if they go to a shelter, where they are assigned a Workfare job. If they don’t accept the job assignment or they miss some hours, they are kicked out of the shelter. If they have children, and no home to go to, the city may begin proceedings to have the children placed in foster care.
Finally, if police see the person sleeping on the street again, they might bring her back to a shelter. If she resists, she could end up in jail.
‘Bedrooms Are for Sleeping’
It seems like this plan all got started in November, when Nicole Barrett, a young woman who moved to New York from Texas, was hit in the head with a brick in Midtown Manhattan by a man who the police identified as a homeless person. (In fact, he wasn’t homeless.)
As that incident was being discussed on Giuliani’s weekly call-in radio show, he announced a new homeless policy he had put together and wanted to put into effect-that the homeless would be cleared from the streets.
Giuliani memorably declared, “Streets do not exist in civilized societies for the purpose of sleeping there. Bedrooms are for sleeping.”
A ‘Compassionate’ Plan?
Soon the mayor announced his full plan, and the whole city of New York got in an uproar. Advocates for the homeless went to court to stop the policy, and until that court case is decided, it won’t go into effect.
But Mayor Giuliani feels that his decision to arrest the homeless and refuse them shelter is “compassionate and loving.” He is standing very firmly behind his rules. In fact, he has become rude about it.
In an article in The New York Times, the mayor had nothing nice to say. His statements ranged, from “I don’t care,” to “Who’s setting the debate? I am. I’ve got them all debating my policy.”
And the mayor isn’t the only one who has been unable to control his temper-advocates for the homeless are enraged. They feel that this new policy will definitely hurt the homeless.
Homeless Need Help, Not Harsh Rules
About 100,000 people in New York City have been homeless at some point during a year. Of those, about 23,000 people can be found in homeless shelters on any given night, including 9,000 kids.
That’s a lot of people who need help. But advocates for the homeless say Giuliani’s plan is not going to help them.
One group that is really doing more than voicing their opposition to the mayor’s plan is the Tier II Coalition, which provides housing and services for homeless families. They said they won’t follow any policy that causes homeless families to be evicted from any shelter without other housing arrangements being made.
They are also against taking the children of these families away and placing them in foster care. Giuliani said he’ll take away their funding-millions of dollars-if they don’t follow his rules.
Homeless Advocates Are Outraged
“I think that it is a misguided policy,” said Joan McAllister, who publishes a newsletter for the homeless. “His policies go against everything we have been trying to establish for years-to help families become self-sufficient, self-supporting, and to have stable homes.”
McAllister feels that Mayor Giuliani is focusing on the wrong issue. “What we need is more affordable housing,” she said.
Between a Rock and a Hard Place
Sister Barbara Lenniger, the vice president of Tier II, had a few words for the mayor, too. She was outraged by him and her statements did not hide that!
In the Times she was quoted as saying, “To think that he would say that if you won’t throw a mother out and take her kids away, ‘I’ll cut off your funding,’ I cannot believe that,” she said. “I cannot believe that a person of his education and religious training would say that.”
Sister Lenniger added that she considers it part of her role as a nun to provide shelter for the homeless. “If someone says that I have to choose between following Jesus Christ and Rudy Giuliani, I’ll follow Jesus Christ. And I’m not known as a religious fanatic,” she said.
These women are not alone in their anger. Thousands of people protested against these policies when Giuliani first introduced them. And when I found out exactly what the mayor is trying to do, I got really upset, too.
I mean, it is bad enough that anyone has to live or sleep on the streets. Then they’re going to get kicked out of shelters or end up spending the night in jail? What else can be done to break an individual down?
I am not saying that homeless people should be exempt from personal responsibilities like working, but I am saying that the new policies seem a bit harsh.
Instead of helping people sort out what’s wrong in their lives, they seem to sort of push the homeless between a rock and a hard place.
Mayor Giuliani is acting like the homeless are just lazy. But many poor families are just a paycheck away from being homeless, and when something goes wrong-like they lose their jobs or they decide to leave an abusive boyfriend-they end up on the streets.
No one wants to be homeless. I think they need support, not punishment. Think about it-how would you feel if it happened to you?

SIDEBAR: Putting Homeless Kids in Care: ‘The System Is Nothing to Jump Up and Shout About’
In November, Mayor Giuliani presented a plan to change how homeless people are treated by shelters in New York. One part of the mayor’s plan is to take away the children of homeless parents who get kicked out of shelters because they mess up at their workfare jobs. The idea is to put the kids in foster care to keep them from ending up on the street. But going into the foster care system is not always so much better than living in bad conditions with your own mom, said a young lady who has been in both foster care and homeless shelters-LishonŽ Bowsky, who is 19 and attends Kingsborough Community College.
Foster Care: ‘Nothing to Jump Up and Shout About!’
LishonŽ thinks the mayor is wrong for trying to refer more children to the system instead of keeping families together and trying harder to work with parents. “The foster care system is nothing to jump up and shout about!” said LishonŽ, who went into care when she was 2. When we talked about whether kids should be separated from their parents, and vice versa, LishonŽ had one thing to say: “There is nothing like your own mother.” She thinks that both the child and the mother would suffer. “I know for a fact that those kids that are taken away from their parents and placed in the foster care system will feel lonely, distraught, upset, angry and insecure all at once,” she said. “That is the worst pain to feel-ever.”
Nowhere to Run
When LishonŽ was younger, she ran away from her adoptive home and lived on the streets. Then, she moved in with a friend. But after a bad experience with her, LishonŽ had to turn to a shelter. Last summer she went to Covenant House, a shelter for teens, and after 30 days, they transferred her to another shelter called Turning Point. Even though the streets were rough, the shelter was stressful, too. The rules were very strict. Teens could get kicked out for small things, like if they answered back to a staff member, fought or broke their curfew. “They kick you out for the dumbest stuff!” LishonŽ said. “If your room isn’t kept clean, look out, you might be out that door.” At both shelters, you had to be working or looking for a job, or you would be evicted. Still, the work rules at these shelters are less strict than what Giuliani is proposing for adults. LishonŽ said she doesn’t think Giuliani really understands what poor people go through. Otherwise, he would think twice about kicking kids into foster care. “Giuliani and his wife need to fall on hard times and we’ll see if he wants his kids thrown in foster care,” she said. “How would he like those apples?”

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.