Tanya, age 21, was in foster care for 14 years until her 18th birthday, when she says she was forced to leave her foster home. When Tanya found out she’d been discharged, she was shocked: “I thought they were supposed to keep me until I was 21.” But they didn’t.
Without independent living training or knowledge of what resources were available to her, Tanya was in the dark on how to survive. Since then she’s been homeless.
Tanya spends a lot of time with her friend Dekischa, another ex-
foster youth who’s also homeless. Dekischa spends the night trying to stay awake and waiting for one of the centers for street teens, like Safe Space, to open. In the summer she sleeps on park benches.
Most of Dekischa’s meals are from the youth centers. That’s where she takes showers, naps and does her laundry. There are times when the only income she has are the subway tokens she is given at the centers.
Going to the Streets
Tanya’s and Dekischa’s cases are not unusual. In a survey of 400 homeless parents in New York City published by the Institute for Children and Poverty in 1997, 20% lived in foster care as children. And according to a 1998 Los Angeles Times article, almost a third of young adults in foster care end up homeless after they outgrow the system. The foster care system isn’t doing a good job. Many youth are leaving foster care not for safe homes and secure jobs. They’re going to the streets.
I wanted to find out why this was happening, so I interviewed several homeless youth who used to be in foster care. Tanya was among them, so was her friend Dekischa. I also talked with a young man named Thomas.
No Training
According to foster care regulations, youth from the age of 14 and up who are not planning on returning to live with their parents are supposed to be taught independent living skills, such as how to budget, how to find and keep a job and how to get and maintain an apartment. These skills will prepare them for life on their own.
But none of the youth I interviewed said that they’d received any kind of training, and most didn’t have an adult to count on for help in getting it.
As we talked, I began to see how unprepared these youth had been for life beyond the system. They were used to relying on the system, and when they were cut off from it, they had no idea how to support themselves. They had been let loose and let down before they were ready. There was a sadness surrounding them.
Sent to a Shelter
Dekischa, who went into the system at 14, said she was discharged prematurely at 18 because of a misunderstanding. She had a family emergency and had to spend a few days with an ailing relative. She said that she called and informed the staff at her group home. Still, she was considered to be AWOL. She was given a list of homeless shelters as a going away present. Any lawyer for children’s rights will tell you it’s illegal for a foster care youth to be discharged to a shelter.
When Dekischa got discharged, she knew tough times were ahead, but she didn’t know how to face them. She said that she hadn’t received any training that could’ve prepared her for these times.
All Dekischa could do was play it by ear. While looking for a permanent roof over her head, she decided to get her GED. But, she said, every time she tried to get into a program, either a friend or family member “was telling me to pack my bags and go.” So she spent most of her time looking for a place to lay her head.
Today, four years after she was discharged, Dekischa is still homeless. “Tonight, I’m staying at a friend’s house,” Dekischa said. “As far as tomorrow and the rest of the week, I don’t know.”
When she was discharged, Dekischa expected problems, but she didn’t expect it to be this hard and for this long.
Another foster care youth who was discharged prematurely is Thomas. Thomas, 20, was adopted at the age of 10. He said his adoptive parents were abusive. Eight years later, when Thomas couldn’t take it anymore and started hitting back, they called the system and asked for his removal from their home.
At the age of 18, Thomas was out on his own and without identification. Without identification, you can’t function as a part of society. You can’t get a job, can’t get into a good school, you might not even be able to get medical attention.
To survive on the streets, Thomas said, “I went asking for money, and basically stole. I had to. For the time that I was out in the streets, that’s what I had to do, and that’s what I did.”
Eventually, Covenant House was able to help Thomas get his social security card and birth certificate. Covenant House was also able to put a roof over his head.
Thomas is now working toward getting his GED and has a job as a security guard. He’s also in the Rights of Passage program at Covenant House. In this program, he’s receiving the kind of independent living training that youth are supposed to get in foster care. Thomas said while he was in foster care, he only saw his social worker twice in four years.
Tanya said that except for not having heat and a roof, she actually prefers it out on the streets, because she didn’t get along with her last social worker and her foster parents “wasn’t doing nothing. I wasn’t getting help in no type of way.”
“If they had helped me the way I had expected them to,” Dekischa said about the foster care system, “I wouldn’t be in this situation right now.”
Homeless Twice
Thomas felt that being in the system actually contributed to his present situation. “I was moving in with someone else’s family,” he said, “which meant that I was homeless. Which also predicted the future, meaning that I might be homeless when I grow up. Now look at the situation, I’m homeless again. That’s being homeless twice in one lifetime.”
But, Thomas also noted, unlike in a foster family, when you’re on your own, “You have to think about your job, you have to learn how to save money, those are things they didn’t teach meâhow to be on your own and be responsible for yourself.”
How could the foster care system be a better stepping stone for youth?
“They should have some type of real independent living program,” Tanya said, “and before they just terminate people they should make sure they have everything straight, like a job, high school diploma, at least some type of training skills before they just cut people off.”
Changes Needed
“More programs,” Dekischa said. “More places like Safe Space, because I see that the majority of kids that come into the drop-in centers are from group homes and foster families.”
Thomas said, “They should teach you better manner skills, they should teach you how to be responsible, even show you how to save money at a young age, so when you grow up, things like this don’t happen.”
Whoever said “the children are the future” wasn’t lying. It’s time to start focusing on the children in foster care. The things that Thomas, Dekischa, and Tanya are going through could have been prevented if the system had taught them independent living skills before discharging them. The system often fails to do its job, and youth are suffering the consequences. Changes have to be made to make sure that foster care youth don’t get discharged to homelessness.
SIDEBAR: Brian Moran: Kickin’ It With the Head of New York City Independent Living
Many foster youth are discharged from the system without enough independent living training. (For more information, read my previous article where I interviewed former foster youth who have been living on the streets for years.) In an attempt to improve independent living programs in New York City, ACS created the position of Assistant Commissioner and chose Brian Moran to fill it. Moran has been in this position for the past year and a half. I recently interviewed Moran about the state of independent living training in New York City. Moran, I found, is sincere about the welfare of foster youth and also realistic-he mentioned that improving IL would be an on-going process. But most of his answers were abstract, so I felt a little cheated after the interview.
Survival Skills
Moran wants to make sure that you, the foster youth, are getting the survival skills you need in one program, not, for instance, interview skills here, cooking classes there, and so on. He called that kind of training “fragmented services.” “To be honest, it’s not rocket science, what kids need,” Moran said. “They need a safe and affordable place to live. They need education. They need jobs and the ability to make money. They need healthcare. These are the major problem areas that kids face as they’re aging out of care. “We need to be able to help hook young people up with resources in the community,” Moran added. “We should be able to work with community boards in order to create employment opportunities for young people in neighborhoods.” He said that caseworkers, group home staff and foster parents would have to play a larger role in helping you get on your own two feet.
Need for Support
“We cannot be successful with kids without the support of foster parents, caseworkers, and house parents,” Moran said. “There are things that will come up in a group training, but unless they’re reinforced and unless people get individual attention on it, they’re not going to stay in a young person’s mind for that long.” Moran seemed very supportive of foster youth. (I remember when one FCYU writer had a problem getting the services she was entitled to. She sat outside Moran’s office for hours waiting to speak to him personally, and left his office satisfied that she would get the services she was entitled to.) When I asked Moran if there was a space for public assistance in his agenda, he said, “What we’re trying to do is avoid that necessity. [But] I think that there are times where we’d be doing a disservice to kids to not inform or not be able to transition them to other systems.” No Overnight Changes Moran said improvements in IL wouldn’t happen overnight. “Changes in any large system tend to be more visible over time, and very few things happen overnight in a grand fashion. But there should always be an expectation of improvement in the system.” I was already aware that it’s illegal to discharge a foster youth without giving them a 90-day notice. Moran added that it’s also illegal for a foster youth to be discharged to a shelter. He acknowledged that this law hasn’t always been rigorously enforced. “We need to help kids understand what their rights are, and what they should be expecting from the adults in their life,” he said, “and especially from ACS.”
