One Stayed In, One Left: Two Teen Mothers and the System

Michelle and Tabitha are two young mothers who became pregnant while in the foster care system. One left the system to raise her child, and the other stayed. Neither expected what lay ahead.
Tabitha Serrano is a 19-year-old single mother, and has been in foster care for 10 years. She gave birth to her son, Beron, a little over a year ago. Tabitha planned to get pregnant. She planned everything, from whom would be the father of the child, to the child’s name, but admits, “I was wrong in thinking my plan was foolproof.”
Beron is 14 months old, and Tabitha doesn’t regret giving birth to him. However, she is disappointed that she has to raise him in the foster care system. They live together at a residence in the Bronx for young mothers and their children, called Bethany House II. “I don’t think he should pay for me being in the system,” Tabitha told me, “I don’t feel his name should be in the files because his mother had him in foster care.”
‘Wanting a Baby’
Tabitha has been residing at Bethany House for the past year. I interviewed her at Rosalie Hall in the Bronx, a program for pregnant teens where she stayed during the last few months of her pregnancy.
At the age of 9, Tabitha told me, her family was torn apart. Since then, in her 10 years in the foster care system, Tabitha said that she has had nothing but bad experiences.
At the age of 17, before Beron was born, Tabitha became determined on having a child. Though she was in a foster home, Tabitha said, “I was ready to settle down, ready to get married and have a child. I wanted to be a mother.” So she and her boyfriend decided to start a family.
She was still in high school when she was planning her pregnancy, but she was working and so was her boyfriend. Tabitha wanted to leave her foster home and get a place with her boyfriend after she graduated from high school. But when she conceived, her baby’s father got cold feet and started slowly withdrawing from the picture.
“When he was saying he didn’t want the baby,” Tabitha said, “I thought it was a phase and that it would pass.” But it didn’t pass. From the look in her eyes, I saw that it was a painful memory for Tabitha.
A month before graduation Tabitha dropped out of high school because of her pregnancy, which also caused her to lose her job. The man she chose to be the father of her child was turning out to be a coward, and to top everything off, when her foster mother found out that she was pregnant, she gave Tabitha an ultimatum-get an abortion or get out!
Hard Choices
Although she was surrounded by voices of friends and family shouting abortion, Tabitha refused to give in. “He [her baby’s father] asked me to have one, but I couldn’t because I planned it.” Tabitha broke up with her boyfriend when she was four months pregnant, and only saw him twice during the remainder of her pregnancy.
Tabitha had decided to keep her baby, and although she had the support of her biological parents, she didn’t want to stay with either one of them. She could’ve gone to the Emergency Assistance Unit (EAU), where homeless people find emergency housing, but she didn’t want to end up on welfare. She had made the decision to have a child, so she was determined to get through this on her own.
A Hectic Routine
But when the social workers found out about Tabitha’s pregnancy, they suggested sending her to another foster home. Tabitha refused. Tabitha said they threatened to take her child away if she didn’t do as they said, so she decided that her child was worth the discomfort she would feel at the foster home.
It was the third foster home Tabitha had been in, but she only had to stay there a week before they sent her to Rosalie Hall. It was while living at Rosalie Hall that Tabitha received her high school diploma and found out what it meant to be a mother and make sacrifices.
Almost as if she were apologizing to her son Beron, Tabitha softly spoke about her time at Rosalie Hall just before she gave birth: “I didn’t know what to do. It wasn’t until I got to Rosalie Hall that I started planning where I was going to go when I had my baby.”
Tabitha still works full-time, and although she has graduated from high school, she still feels pressed for time. Her daily routine is hectic and starts at 5:30 in the morning. Her counselors strongly encourage her to spend quality time with her son, and so she does, even if it means going to bed at 12:30 in the morning.
For Tabitha, raising a child in the foster care system is bittersweet: “Not having anywhere to go, the baby’s father not wanting anything to do with me, the uncertainty of not knowing if I could do it by myself.”
But the staff at Bethany House have been helpful. They teach her basic things she needs to know about taking care of a baby, budgeting her money and managing her time. Tabitha admits she receives a lot of help. “I never have to worry about milk,” Tabitha said, “never have to worry about a baby-sitterâor Pampers, everything is being met.”
Tabitha says about the staff: “I need the help and they give it to me.” The same can’t be said for her baby’s father, who comes around once every other blue moon: “He plays daddy when he feels like it.”
Future Plans
Tabitha had certain expectations about being a mother, but her plans didn’t work out the way she expected them to. Despite all this, if she had the chance to do it all again, she wouldn’t change a thing: “I think everything I did and went through made me who I am. I love who I am today.”
She says becoming a mother has given her more responsibility. She plans to join the Marines, complete her college education, then become a lawyer or teacher; her pregnancy has not changed her plans, it has only slowed her down.
Tabitha has to rely on a system that filled her early childhood with bad experiences. She willingly put aside her painful past with the hopes of creating a better future for her child.
But her path is not a path she would recommend to others. She has some advice for other teens who are considering having kids: “Don’t do it! School comes first. Sex, boys, all of that can wait. Starting a family should only come when you are emotionally and financially ready.”
Michelle Brown is another young woman who was pregnant in the foster care system. But Michelle left the system to raise her child.
Michelle has a three-year-old daughter, Natia. Michelle is 23 and had been in the foster care system for five years, from 14 to 19.
Unlike Tabitha, Michelle’s pregnancy wasn’t planned, but happened on a weekend rendezvous. Being pregnant in the system wasn’t easy on her.
When Michelle told the staff at her agency, Edwin Gould Services, that she was pregnant, they said she would have to wait four months before they’d be able to transfer her to a mother and child facility. At first Michelle intended to wait those months, but her situation at Edwin Gould was getting worse.
Group Home Fights
Michelle had a number of fights at her group home, two of which were with staff members. One fight with a resident had a strong influence on Michelle’s decision to leave, since she felt that her unborn child was in danger: “I was thinking for her life, ’cause when I got into the fight the girl kicked me dead in the stomach.”
Along with what she considered a lack of medical attention, counseling, and support, the fights and the threats that followed were enough to convince Michelle that she was better off on her own. Michelle was 19 and two months pregnant when she signed herself out of the system.
But being pregnant on the streets was worse than being pregnant in care: “It’s hard as hell, believe me. There are a lot of frightful people in this city we live in.
“I started looking at my decision [to leave the system] in a different light the summer of last year,” Michelle said, “because of all the problems I was facing and all the changes my daughter was going through.” Michelle began to wonder if her decision to leave the system was truly for the best.
Bouncing Around
After leaving Edwin Gould, Michelle went to her friend Terry’s place. It was during her stay with Terry that she gave birth to Natia. Michelle and Natia bounced from one temporary home to another for the next three years. They went from one friend’s place to another, every now and then stopping at an ex-boyfriend’s home. For the first three years of her life, Natia didn’t have a steady place to call home.
After a while, Natia’s eating habits and sleeping habits started changing. The moving from place to place was starting to take a toll on her young life. Looking back, Michelle remembers, “I knew it was hard, period, raising a child. When I made the decision [to leave the system], I did not expect all the problems I went through.”
Twice during her search for a stable living situation, Michelle was in danger of losing her daughter to foster care. Both times, Terry called BCW and told them that Michelle was abusing weed and alcohol and abusing her child. Michelle was told by BCW workers that she had to spend two hours a day for six months at a rehab program as an outpatient to have her case closed.
The second time, both Natia’s father and Terry reported Michelle to BCW, but Michelle’s clean urine test and a doctor’s visit for Natia that showed no signs of abuse allowed Natia to stay with Michelle. Michelle’s thoughts at that time were, “The people who decided to call BCW on me must have really wanted my daughter. So when a worker called me and said my case was closed, I laughed and said, ‘Ha ha ha, you can’t get my daughter.'”
Cowardly Father
Michelle has virtually no relationship with Natia’s father. He never wanted her to keep Natia, and while she was in labor he was playing basketball. The only support he has ever given was $10 a week during the summer of her pregnancy.
Michelle started getting welfare a week before she gave birth, and received her GED a year and a half later. For the past six months, Michelle and Natia have been staying with Michelle’s biological father.
Second Thoughts
Like Tabitha, Michelle doesn’t regret having a child. But she does wonder if she should have left the system. Nearly all the staff in Michelle’s group home tried to talk her out of leaving the system, and if she could turn back time, Michelle says that she would’ve listened to them and stayed in the system until she aged out. Things would’ve been easier for both her and Natia.
Tabitha did have the system to fall back on; the same system that filled the early years of her life with bad experiences has redeemed itself with the assistance it has given to Tabitha and her son.
Michelle advises pregnant teens to stay in the system. “There are more free opportunities you can get thereâAs long as you know your rights, you will know when they’re putting you through the mud.”
Will Michelle ever tell Natia this story? “Yes, I definitely willâIf she gets pregnant at an early age I will be there for her.”

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.