Why is losing weight such an important priority for adolescent girls? Because our culture has convinced many of us that if you’re not thin, you can’t be beautiful.
Eve (not her real name), a senior at Bronx Science HS, started dieting when she was 16 after she gained four pounds.
At first, she just cut back on fat. But later she reduced her diet to half a bagel for breakfast, two cups of coffee, a diet Coke and a small portion of whatever her mother made for dinner.
“After a while, it became a control thing, like a power trip,” Eve confessed. “[Eating] would be giving in, losing control,” she said.
She weighed herself twice a day and recorded everything she ate in a diary. When her weight dropped to 89 pounds, she knew she had to stop.
Obsessed With Weight
“I only started eating again because I didn’t have the energy to do anything anymore. My mom would hover over me during dinner to make sure I ate everything,” Eve recalled.
The glamorization of the thin female body and the obsession with dieting have resulted in a large number of eating disorders.
We’ve been told a thousand times that beauty is on the inside. But if this is true, why does the media only focus on thin girls? Where is the heavy girl on Beverly Hills 90210?
Whenever we open a fashion magazine, we see super-thin models like Kate Moss sprawled on every page. Like me, many girls believe that models featured in magazine ads and fashion runways have the ideal look.
And some of us sacrifice our health to conform to this thin ideal.
When Ashley (not her real name), also a senior at Bronx Science, compared herself to the thin girls who dominate the fashion industry, she felt inadequate.
She wanted to be attractive. “When someone meets you, they don’t see how intelligent you are. The first thing that strikes them is your appearance,” she said.
Ashley thought the only way to be attractive was to be thin. So she began to diet.
Ashley, who is 5 feet 8 inches tall and weighs 120 pounds, says her ideal weight is 115 pounds, which is 23 pounds below her recommended weight.
“Food became the enemy…I’ve starved myself before, especially after breaking up with a boyfriend,” Ashley said. “I can’t help but think, ‘Oh my God, it must have been because I’m getting fat.’ “
Killing Our Spirits
Many girls believe that guys are attracted to fragile, underweight girls. Although this may be true for some guys, most of the guys I interviewed preferred girls who weren’t constantly dieting. They said they weren’t attracted to waifish girls distinguished by their bony, skeletal bodies.
David Washington, 16, of Environmental Studies HS, said, “I need more meat. A super thin girl might poke me.”
But for many teenage girls like me, that’s hard to believe.
The average American woman wears a size 12, not a size two. But for many women, no matter what their size, the goal is still a size two, regardless of how unrealistic and unhealthy that weight may be for them. They seem to think that they’re fat if they’re not underweight.
And the victims of the trend are not just those who diet themselves into hospitals or an early grave. They are also the girls who skip dessert and constantly exercise so they can fit into their prom dresses. They may not be destroying their health, but they’re killing their spirits.
Our Value Isn’t Weighed In Pounds
I realize that the emphasis we place on being thin is dangerous and needs to be changed, but (as much as I hate to confess it) I too am a follower of the thin is beautiful belief. For this reason, I look at myself in the mirror each day and analyze whether or not I have gained weight.
Many of us compare our bodies to the Vogue models with airbrushed thighs or the girl who sits next to us in history whose jeans are two sizes smaller than our own.
Maybe someday we will realize that our value isn’t weighed in pounds. But for now we can never be satisfied with our own bodies and will always covet someone else’s.
Afraid of Fat: When Food Is the Enemy
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.