Beauty Isn’t Just Skin Deep

While waiting for my friend in a bookstore a couple of months ago, I picked up a random magazine and began flipping through. There was an ad for the cologne Raw Vanilla. The picture showed a couple standing waist-high in the middle of the wilderness kissing. “In the raw vanilla,” the caption read. “It’s like meeting in the rainforest.”
“Wow,” I said to myself. “Such passion! That’s so romantic!” Somehow I wanted to feel like the girl in the ad.
Advertisements like this one often play on our weak spots to make us want to buy a product. They’re designed to make us feel that our lives are boring and lonely, and that only when we have what they’re selling will we become as exciting and romantic as the people they portray. In many magazines the ads are so abundant they sometimes comprise more than three-fourths of the entire issue.
In the February 1997 issue of Vogue, for instance, 217 out of 250 pages contained ads for cosmetic, fashion and health products-brands like Revlon, Maybelline, Polo and Elizabeth Arden.
Superficial, Materialistic Messages
The ads promote the idea that beauty goes only as deep as the surface of our skin or the clothes we wear and encourage us to think that the first step toward having a body like Kate Moss’s is to wear the same lipstick.
But it isn’t just the ads that instill us with this superficial, materialistic sense of who we should be. In any given issue of a magazine like Mademoiselle, Vogue, Teen, or Seventeen (to name just a few) we’re bound to get plenty of direct advice about relationships, beauty and our bodies. In an old issue of Seventeen, for instance, I found a column where a girl had written to ask how long she should wait before calling a guy she had just met. Their response was 48 hours.
Without knowing anything more about the particular circumstances under which she had met this guy or what type of person he was, giving a straight answer of 48 hours may not have been the wisest choice. These are easy solutions to complex problems and may not always apply to your situation.
Guys, Guys, Guys
Guys are a big topic in these magazines. They never fail to devote pages and pages to relationships, breakups, crushes and sex. They take us through the whole dating process from spotting a prospective boyfriend at first sight (“How to Know if He’s the One”) and how to treat him once you’ve got him (“When To Say ‘I Love You.’ “) to how to make the final phone call to break up with him (“Ten Ways to Reject Him Nicely”). It makes you wonder how they keep from running out of new things to write about.
Along with all the advertisements showing couples in intimate positions, these articles send the message that you can’t be happy-that your life is not complete or normal-without a significant other. But as a single person I know life without a boyfriend or a crush can be just as great as life with one.
I’m Out Of Style
Magazines for women and teens mainly rule our lives by telling us what to wear. As the summer hit in June, almost every magazine I looked at contained articles about this year’s hottest summer fashions-short, tight mini-skirts, wrap-around denim shorts and slim-fit tank tops. Among the pastel-colored dresses that clung to the body, I couldn’t find any images of young women wearing a simple pair of blue jeans and a T-shirt. Apparently, the clothes I like to wear were not considered in style. What was I going to do-make a dash to the nearest department store and redecorate my entire wardrobe?
While Teen, Seventeen and other magazines for young women can be informative and entertaining, teenagers often take them too seriously and start thinking they aren’t attractive unless they have the same clothes, makeup and even bodies as the models. Even worse, the severely underweight models have contributed to many girls developing diseases like bulimia, anorexia, binge-eating and obsessive-compulsive disorder.
It’s Not Worth Starving Ourselves
Like them, I have often envied the “perfect” models, the expensive clothes and all the cute guys. But I have also learned that those things are not nearly as important as my intelligence, my personality, or my ambitions in life. (Besides, who wants to miss out on all the great-tasting foods by starving ourselves all day to be as skinny as models?)
Don’t get me wrong. That doesn’t mean that I’ve thrown away all my makeup and nice clothes. It’s just that I think that what’s inside is a better measure of my character than what I wear.
Recently I’ve noticed a little improvement in the range of topics covered by a few of these magazines. The September issue of Seventeen, for example, has an article written by a Harvard student about how she dreamed of going away to college and about how homesick she felt when that time finally came. This was an article I could really learn from, about something many students like me will soon be experiencing first hand.
Time To Get Serious
In that same issue, I was even more surprised to find a story about a woman doctor who travels around to different developing countries treating children with some horrible disease. I never thought I would find any type of role model in a magazine like Seventeen.
Teen and women’s magazines should cover more topics like these, and it would be great to read more about careers, family problems like divorce, and experiences like teen pregnancy and rape. They should teach us how to get into college and earn a living and keep us up to date about current events. We can’t allow our sense of self-worth to be determined by the brand names on our clothes or the kinds of cologne we use.
Reading through the various magazines out there for girls, it’s easy to get the impression that all we care about are our looks and our boyfriends. The magazines people read tell us what is acceptable and fashionable and are supposed to represent us and our views. But ultimately it’s up to the reader to determine whether to trust her own judgment or that of some magazine editor. After all, who knows us better than ourselves?

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.