Singled Out

Have you ever gone into a record store in search of that one song you wanted, but couldn’t find it on the shelves?
Well, that’s been happening to me a lot. Last year, I wanted to get a single of Salt-n-Pepa’s song “Champagne.” It appeared on the Bulletproof soundtrack but I couldn’t find the single anywhere. A salesclerk at one record store I went to told me that if I wanted the song, I would have to buy the album.
Last summer, the Fugees’ remake of Roberta Flack’s “Killing Me Softly” was such a big hit that it was on the radio every five minutes. But, again, the single was nowhere to be found! Another song that never seemed to hit the record stores was Foxy Brown’s “Gotta Get U Home” featuring Blackstreet. I scoured Brooklyn looking for it and finally gave up. And just recently, I’ve seen Mary J. Blige’s and Heavy D.’s new albums everywhere but I haven’t seen a single off either one.
Money Down the Drain
I started wondering what was up. Are the artists I like so popular that the record companies assume that people will want to buy their whole albums, not just singles? Or are they trying to force us to buy something we don’t really want or need-like they did when vinyl records started disappearing from the stores and we were forced to buy CDs and CD players?
The last time I bought an album when I really just wanted a single was back in 1993. I purchased Salt-n-Pepa’s Very Necessary just because I liked the song “Shoop, Shoop.” I figured that since the single was so great, the entire album would be to my liking. Big mistake. After a few days of listening, I realized I couldn’t stand the rest of the album. Thirteen dollars went down the drain.
I learned from that experience never to buy an album just because I liked one song I had heard on the radio. But, quite frankly, that is exactly what record companies want music consumers to do.
Singles Are Getting Scarce
A few weeks ago, I was watching the news and a report came on about how CD and cassette singles are disappearing from the record stores. The report said this is happening because record companies want us to buy entire albums, not just hit singles. Then I read an article in The New York Times, by music critic Jon Pareles, that made the same point. “Frequently, [record] labels withdraw a single from stores just as it peaks, so consumers who want the song have to buy the whole album,” Pareles wrote.
I think this policy is unfair to consumers so I decided to contact some recording companies to find out what was up. I interviewed a spokesperson for Sony Music and he told me how they decide which songs to release as singles. “The song has to be able to have good radio airplay,” he said. “The single has to be popular enough to sell the [whole] record. It’s all about selling albums, not singles.”
The Record Companies Say, ‘Tough Luck’
The spokesperson for another record label, who agreed to be interviewed on the condition that neither he nor his company be named in this article, was even more blunt. He said that record companies release singles “to drive album sales. Record companies decrease singles to encourage more album sales.” When I asked him, “What if people only want the single?” He simply said, “Tough luck.”
So there you have it, folks: the record companies don’t care what we want; they only care about making money.
I am not angry that they have this attitude. Everyone wants to make money. That’s the whole point of getting an education or starting a business. But, as a music consumer, I dislike the idea of singles being eliminated, and I refuse to buy an album just so I can listen to one song. No matter how much I like it, one tune is not worth $13. The record companies have every right to make money but I’m not going to let them make it at my expense.
Listen Before You Buy
I’m afraid that CD singles are going the way of vinyl and turntables. Records have become scarce and it’s almost impossible to walk into a store and buy a record player. If this is the fate of the CD single, I think the best thing to do is to make sure you’ve heard all of an album before purchasing it-not just one song.
Luckily, most of the big record stores like The Wiz, HMV, and Tower Records now have listening booths that offer consumers the opportunity to listen to many popular albums before buying them. I find this convenient and thoughtful. It gives us the chance to preview an entire album before spending our money.
So, music fans, take note: the first song to get radio play off a newly released album is almost certainly going to be the best, or at least the catchiest. Just because you like that one song doesn’t mean the entire album will be good. If the record stores don’t have the single you want, don’t just buy the album because it’s there. Make sure you’ve listened to all of it before you spend your money.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.